Content deleted Content added
Happy-melon (talk | contribs) →B-Class criteria: response |
|||
Line 21:
I can't find it so I though I'd ask. Is there a way to include the B-class article checklist? If not, that's fine and I'll code it into the old project template we used to use. Thanks! <font color="green" face="Comic Sans MS">[[User:Stepshep|§hep]]</font> • <font color="green" face="Comic Sans MS">[[User talk:Stepshep|¡Talk to me!]]</font> 22:43, 6 May 2008 (UTC)
:There currently isn't anything hard-coded into the banner, although there are numerous places where you can 'hang' extra code as required ({{para|BOTTOM_TEXT}} and {{para|COLLAPSED_TEXT}} are good ones). How standardised are the B-class assessments between wikiprojects? If they are almost universal, I could work something into the banner; but if the assessments are customised for each project, then it wouldn't be worth it. <font color="forestgreen">[[User:Happy-melon|'''Happy''']]</font>‑<font color="darkorange">[[User talk:Happy-melon|'''melon''']]</font> 10:29, 7 May 2008 (UTC)
:::According to the 1.0 Team
Commonly the highest article grade that is assigned outside a more formal review process. Has several of the elements described in "start", usually a majority of the material needed for a comprehensive article. Nonetheless, ''it has some gaps or missing elements or references'', ''needs editing for language usage'' or clarity, ''balance of content'', or c''ontains other policy problems'' such as copyright, ''Neutral Point Of View (NPOV) or No Original Research (NOR)''. With NPOV a well written B-class may correspond to the "Wikipedia 0.5" or "usable" standard. Articles that are close to GA status but don't meet the Good article criteria should be B- or Start-class articles.
Following that the [[Template:WPMILHIST|MILHIS]] banner seems to have the coding that does the trick. <code>{{!}} This article has been checked against the following [[Wikipedia:WikiProject Military history/Assessment#Quality scale|criteria for B-Class status]]:<br/>
# {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-1|}}}|{{{B-1|}}}|{{{B1|}}}|{{{b-1|}}}|{{{b1|}}}}}|yes| [[Image:Orange check.svg|16x16px]] | {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-1|}}}|{{{B-1|}}}|{{{B1|}}}|{{{b-1|}}}|{{{b1|}}}}}|no| [[Image:Red x.svg|16x16px]] | [[Image:Purple question mark.svg|16x16px]] }}}} Referencing and citation: {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-1|}}}|{{{B-1|}}}|{{{B1|}}}|{{{b-1|}}}|{{{b1|}}}}}|yes| ''criterion met'' | {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-1|}}}|{{{B-1|}}}|{{{B1|}}}|{{{b-1|}}}|{{{b1|}}}}}|no| ''criterion not met'' | ''not checked'' }}}}
# {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-2|}}}|{{{B-2|}}}|{{{B2|}}}|{{{b-2|}}}|{{{b2|}}}}}|yes| [[Image:Orange check.svg|16x16px]] | {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-2|}}}|{{{B-2|}}}|{{{B2|}}}|{{{b-2|}}}|{{{b2|}}}}}|no| [[Image:Red x.svg|16x16px]] | [[Image:Purple question mark.svg|16x16px]] }}}} Coverage and accuracy: {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-2|}}}|{{{B-2|}}}|{{{B2|}}}|{{{b-2|}}}|{{{b2|}}}}}|yes| ''criterion met'' | {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-2|}}}|{{{B-2|}}}|{{{B2|}}}|{{{b-2|}}}|{{{b2|}}}}}|no| ''criterion not met'' | ''not checked'' }}}}
# {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-3|}}}|{{{B-3|}}}|{{{B3|}}}|{{{b-3|}}}|{{{b3|}}}}}|yes| [[Image:Orange check.svg|16x16px]] | {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-3|}}}|{{{B-3|}}}|{{{B3|}}}|{{{b-3|}}}|{{{b3|}}}}}|no| [[Image:Red x.svg|16x16px]] | [[Image:Purple question mark.svg|16x16px]] }}}} Structure: {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-3|}}}|{{{B-3|}}}|{{{B3|}}}|{{{b-3|}}}|{{{b3|}}}}}|yes| ''criterion met'' | {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-3|}}}|{{{B-3|}}}|{{{B3|}}}|{{{b-3|}}}|{{{b3|}}}}}|no| ''criterion not met'' | ''not checked'' }}}}
# {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-4|}}}|{{{B-4|}}}|{{{B4|}}}|{{{b-4|}}}|{{{b4|}}}}}|yes| [[Image:Orange check.svg|16x16px]] | {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-4|}}}|{{{B-4|}}}|{{{B4|}}}|{{{b-4|}}}|{{{b4|}}}}}|no| [[Image:Red x.svg|16x16px]] | [[Image:Purple question mark.svg|16x16px]] }}}} Grammar: {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-4|}}}|{{{B-4|}}}|{{{B4|}}}|{{{b-4|}}}|{{{b4|}}}}}|yes| ''criterion met'' | {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-4|}}}|{{{B-4|}}}|{{{B4|}}}|{{{b-4|}}}|{{{b4|}}}}}|no| ''criterion not met'' | ''not checked'' }}}}
# {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-5|}}}|{{{B-5|}}}|{{{B5|}}}|{{{b-5|}}}|{{{b5|}}}}}|yes| [[Image:Orange check.svg|16x16px]] | {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-5|}}}|{{{B-5|}}}|{{{B5|}}}|{{{b-5|}}}|{{{b5|}}}}}|no| [[Image:Red x.svg|16x16px]] | [[Image:Purple question mark.svg|16x16px]] }}}} Supporting materials: {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-5|}}}|{{{B-5|}}}|{{{B5|}}}|{{{b-5|}}}|{{{b5|}}}}}|yes| ''criterion met'' | {{#ifeq:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-5|}}}|{{{B-5|}}}|{{{B5|}}}|{{{b-5|}}}|{{{b5|}}}}}|no| ''criterion not met'' | ''not checked'' }}}}
{{#if:{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-1|}}}|{{{B-1|}}}|{{{B1|}}}|{{{b-1|}}}|{{{b1|}}}}}{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-2|}}}|{{{B-2|}}}|{{{B2|}}}|{{{b-2|}}}|{{{b2|}}}}}{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-3|}}}|{{{B-3|}}}|{{{B3|}}}|{{{b-3|}}}|{{{b3|}}}}}{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-4|}}}|{{{B-4|}}}|{{{B4|}}}|{{{b-4|}}}|{{{b4|}}}}}{{WPMILHIST/Any|{{{B-Class-5|}}}|{{{B-5|}}}|{{{B5|}}}|{{{b-5|}}}|{{{b5|}}}}}||{{#if:{{{B-Class-1}}}{{{B-Class-2}}}{{{B-Class-3}}}{{{B-Class-4}}}{{{B-Class-5}}}|To fill out this checklist, please <span class="editlink noprint plainlinksneverexpand">[{{SERVER}}{{localurl:{{NAMESPACE}}:{{PAGENAME}}|action=edit}} add]</span> the following to the template call:<br/><small><tt><nowiki><!-- B-Class-1. It is suitably referenced, and all major points have appropriate inline citations. --></nowiki></tt></small><br/><small><tt><nowiki>|B-Class-1=yes/no</nowiki></tt></small><br/><small><tt><nowiki><!-- B-Class-2. It reasonably covers the topic, and does not contain obvious omissions or inaccuracies. --></nowiki></tt></small><br/><small><tt><nowiki>|B-Class-2=yes/no</nowiki></tt></small><br/><small><tt><nowiki><!-- B-Class-3. It has a defined structure, including a lead section and one or more sections of content. --></nowiki></tt></small><br/><small><tt><nowiki>|B-Class-3=yes/no</nowiki></tt></small><br/><small><tt><nowiki><!-- B-Class-4. It is free from major grammatical errors. --></nowiki></tt></small><br/><small><tt><nowiki>|B-Class-4=yes/no</nowiki></tt></small><br/><small><tt><nowiki><!-- B-Class-5. It contains appropriate supporting materials, such as an infobox, images, or diagrams. --></nowiki></tt></small><br/><small><tt><nowiki>|B-Class-5=yes/no</nowiki></tt></small>}}}}
|#default=}}
</code>
That looks fairly similar to the criteria set forth by [[WP:1]]. It would be nice to have it set up though, so if the article was above B-Class the checklist wouldn't appear. What do you think? <font color="green" face="Comic Sans MS">[[User:Stepshep|§hep]]</font> • <font color="green" face="Comic Sans MS">[[User talk:Stepshep|¡Talk to me!]]</font> 20:31, 7 May 2008 (UTC)
| |||