Content deleted Content added
←Created page with '<!-- HBC Archive Indexerbot can blank this -->' |
Bot: Updating index |
||
| (18 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
Line 1:
<!-- HBC Archive Indexerbot can blank this -->
Report generated based on a request from [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory]]. It matches the following masks: Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive <#>, Talk:Evolution as fact and theory.<br>
{{last edited by}}
{| class="sortable"
! Discussion Topic !! Replies (estimated) !! Archive Link
|-
| Purported reason for deletion || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Purported reason for deletion]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Evolution not a scientific fact? || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Evolution not a scientific fact?]]
|-
| Evolution not a piece of data from an experiment || 8 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Evolution not a piece of data from an experiment]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Merge with Misunderstandings about evolution || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Merge with Misunderstandings about evolution]]
|-
| Microevolution versus macroevolution || 13 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Microevolution versus macroevolution]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Plumbing is a science and Cleaning Toilets is a religion || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Plumbing is a science and Cleaning Toilets is a religion]]
|-
| It seems to me that Evolution is a fact not a theory at all. || 8 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#It seems to me that Evolution is a fact not a theory at all.]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Response || 6 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Response]]
|-
| Article uses incorrect definition of "scientific fact" || 4 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Article uses incorrect definition of "scientific fact"]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Hair splitting || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Hair splitting]]
|-
| Fact Quiz || 35 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Fact Quiz]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Edwards || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Edwards]]
|-
| Fundamental flaw || 5 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Fundamental flaw]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Refuted theory || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Refuted theory]]
|-
| "Fact" || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#"Fact"]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Second sentence || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Second sentence]]
|-
| Article missing a section? || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Article missing a section?]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Other "theories" || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Other "theories"]]
|-
| definition of evolution || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#definition of evolution]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Misunderstanding of fact, theory, and everything in between || 13 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Misunderstanding of fact, theory, and everything in between]]
|-
| My changes to The Terminology of Science || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#My changes to The Terminology of Science]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Creationist rant || 4 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Creationist rant]]
|-
| Semi-protecting the article? || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Semi-protecting the article?]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Inappropriate Tone in section "Evolution as theory and fact in the literature" || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#Inappropriate Tone in section "Evolution as theory and fact in the literature"]]
|-
| directly from first source || 4 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 1#directly from first source]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Original study? || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Original study?]]
|-
| Biased towards Evolution || 20 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Biased towards Evolution]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Too difficult to edit (better way?) || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Too difficult to edit (better way?)]]
|-
| Reference error || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Reference error]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Facts are a judgement call || 14 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Facts are a judgement call]]
|-
| Persistent comments that this article is confused || 18 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 5#Persistent comments that this article is confused]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Article on Facts || 5 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Article on Facts]]
|-
| Popper's falsifiability || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Popper's falsifiability]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Is a fact || 8 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Is a fact]]
|-
| Inaccuracies || 30 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Inaccuracies]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| One and the same claim can be both fact and theory || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#One and the same claim can be both fact and theory]]
|-
| How the word evolution is used || 10 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#How the word evolution is used]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Just a thought || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Just a thought]]
|-
| Define what is meant by "evolution" || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Define what is meant by "evolution"]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Brilliant || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Brilliant]]
|-
| To: 65.87.184.50 || 23 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#To: 65.87.184.50]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Before you get too excited || 35 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Before you get too excited]]
|-
| Section on "Evolution as theory and fact in the literature" || 4 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Section on "Evolution as theory and fact in the literature"]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Boltzmann H Theorem || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Boltzmann H Theorem]]
|-
| laws and proof || 5 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#laws and proof]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Big Problem || 7 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Big Problem]]
|-
| Gravity as fact || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Gravity as fact]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| National Academy of Sciences || 5 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#National Academy of Sciences]]
|-
| Gravity and Evolution ???? || 21 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Gravity and Evolution ????]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| This article is a rant || 34 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#This article is a rant]]
|-
| The observed changes in populations || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#The observed changes in populations]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| As a rebuttal to evolutionists creationists || 8 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#As a rebuttal to evolutionists creationists]]
|-
| No original Research || 12 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#No original Research]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Some hits from "the other side" || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Some hits from "the other side"]]
|-
| NPOV tag WAS recommended by AFD closure || 11 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#NPOV tag WAS recommended by AFD closure]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| View of those opposed to evolution || 13 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#View of those opposed to evolution]]
|-
| Please return the NPOV tag || 11 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Please return the NPOV tag]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| 'Theory' should not be in contradistinction to 'fact' || 10 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#'Theory' should not be in contradistinction to 'fact']]
|-
| Who considers what fact? || 5 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Who considers what fact?]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| The Theory of Evolution is NOT True || 8 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#The Theory of Evolution is NOT True]]
|-
| Quick question || 4 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Quick question]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Unencyclopedic || 6 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Unencyclopedic]]
|-
| Page serves no purpose || 10 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Page serves no purpose]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Alternative suggestion || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Alternative suggestion]]
|-
| Another suggestion || 22 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Another suggestion]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| What is evolution? || 6 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#What is evolution?]]
|-
| The Earth Rotates Round the Sun: Fact? || 12 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#The Earth Rotates Round the Sun: Fact?]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Logic || 29 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 2#Logic]]
|-
| Several suggestions || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Several suggestions]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Great article ... keep it || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Great article ... keep it]]
|-
| Thinning the citations in the lead || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Thinning the citations in the lead]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Evolution is not a theory. Evolutionary theory is a theory. || 7 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Evolution is not a theory. Evolutionary theory is a theory.]]
|-
| Explanation of restored sentence || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Explanation of restored sentence]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Muller and Gould quotes are contradictory || 5 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Muller and Gould quotes are contradictory]]
|-
| The Real Problem || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#The Real Problem]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Inclusion of polls || 17 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Inclusion of polls]]
|-
| A joke || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#A joke]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Objections to the fact of evolution - Irrelevant for this article || 4 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Objections to the fact of evolution - Irrelevant for this article]]
|-
| Supporting evidence for the fact of evolution -- also irrelevant to this article || 7 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Supporting evidence for the fact of evolution -- also irrelevant to this article]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Introduction of fallacious material into the article || 8 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 3#Introduction of fallacious material into the article]]
|-
| Or is there a rule on this page that no change can be made without first posting it on the talk page? || 5 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#Or is there a rule on this page that no change can be made without first posting it on the talk page?]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| "Which meaning of evolution is intended, if it is not explicit, can be discerned by the context." || 39 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#"Which meaning of evolution is intended, if it is not explicit, can be discerned by the context."]]
|-
| Concern regarding first paragraph || 17 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#Concern regarding first paragraph]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| A general reminder. || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#A general reminder.]]
|-
| Removing "the observed" || 5 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#Removing "the observed"]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Cite for "changes in populations of organisms over time"? || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#Cite for "changes in populations of organisms over time"?]]
|-
| For why doesn't it say "of how"? || 4 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#For why doesn't it say "of how"?]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| falsified hypotheses || 8 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#falsified hypotheses]]
|-
| True in addition to factual || 5 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#True in addition to factual]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Looks like some inconsistencies in the article || 12 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#Looks like some inconsistencies in the article]]
|-
| Purpose of this Article || 10 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#Purpose of this Article]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Fact and Theory || 20 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#Fact and Theory]]
|-
| Source of ambiguity || 15 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#Source of ambiguity]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Controvercy || 5 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#Controvercy]]
|-
| Removal of Text || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#Removal of Text]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| The fact section doesn't seem to be parallel with the its main article || 34 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#The fact section doesn't seem to be parallel with the its main article]]
|-
| What is this article about? || 6 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#What is this article about?]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| changes in populations of biological organisms over time || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#changes in populations of biological organisms over time]]
|-
| Dawkins tackles this more expicitly in his new book || 8 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#Dawkins tackles this more expicitly in his new book]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Section on "Evolution compared with gravity" OR? || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 4#Section on "Evolution compared with gravity" OR?]]
|-
| Encouraging use of a logical fallacy? || 7 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 5#Encouraging use of a logical fallacy?]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Causation || 5 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 5#Causation]]
|-
| Gravity and fruit flies || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 5#Gravity and fruit flies]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Tone || 43 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 5#Tone]]
|-
| Article by Gregory || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 5#Article by Gregory]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Meanings of the word 'evolution'. || 13 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 5#Meanings of the word 'evolution'.]]
|-
| Does this article properly reflect the opinions of the quoted sources? || 41 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 5#Does this article properly reflect the opinions of the quoted sources?]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Fact vs. Theory || 12 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Fact vs. Theory]]
|-
| Scientific theories || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Scientific theories]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Evolutionary theory predicts novel inventions || 7 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Evolutionary theory predicts novel inventions]]
|-
| Evolutionary theory predicts novel inventions || 7 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Evolutionary theory predicts novel inventions 2]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Predictive power || 15 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Predictive power]]
|-
| Proof || 13 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Proof]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Serious problems with this fact and theory article || 6 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Serious problems with this fact and theory article]]
|-
| Changes to lead || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Changes to lead]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Break in the proposal || 8 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Break in the proposal]]
|-
| First paragraph || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#First paragraph]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Second paragraph || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Second paragraph]]
|-
| Revised proposal in full || 12 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Revised proposal in full]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Break - mathematical theory || 11 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Break - mathematical theory]]
|-
| Proof in "Related concepts and terminology" || 3 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Proof in "Related concepts and terminology"]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Undid revision to H-W theory || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Undid revision to H-W theory]]
|-
| Hardy-Weinberg content is incorrect || 13 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Hardy-Weinberg content is incorrect]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Removing paragraph comparing evolution to gravity || 47 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Removing paragraph comparing evolution to gravity]]
|-
| Reining this debate in || 8 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Reining this debate in]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Belief in theory || 80 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 6#Belief in theory]]
|-
| A few comments || 7 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#A few comments]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Germ theory of diseases in the lead || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#Germ theory of diseases in the lead]]
|-
| Comparing evolution to gravity || 10 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#Comparing evolution to gravity]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Comparing evolution to gravity || 11 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#Comparing evolution to gravity 2]]
|-
| Redefines Wikipedia's own definition of "Theory" and "Fact" || 7 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#Redefines Wikipedia's own definition of "Theory" and "Fact"]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| inductive/deductive || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#inductive/deductive]]
|-
| "Evolution is both fact and theory" - Nope not all scientists agree || 23 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#"Evolution is both fact and theory" - Nope not all scientists agree]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Clarification on fact || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#Clarification on fact]]
|-
| Phantom Citations || 8 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#Phantom Citations]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Suggestions to Improve This Article || 20 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#Suggestions to Improve This Article]]
|-
| Evolution as theory and fact in the literature || 4 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#Evolution as theory and fact in the literature]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Phenomena of evolution || 7 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#Phenomena of evolution]]
|-
| FAQ question 4 || 36 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#FAQ question 4]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Recent change to lead || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 8#Recent change to lead]]
|-
| Revisions to first section on fact || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#Revisions to first section on fact]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Review of fact || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 7#Review of fact]]
|-
| Obscurity || 4 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 8#Obscurity]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Removal of FAQ || 5 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 8#Removal of FAQ]]
|-
| Formal inference? || 14 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 8#Formal inference?]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Material moved || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory#Material moved]]
|-
| Return previous lead || 8 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory/Archive 8#Return previous lead]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Defining evolution || 7 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory#Defining evolution]]
|-
| E as T&F "in the literature" || 2 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory#E as T&F "in the literature"]]
|- style="background: #dddddd;"
| Fitzhugh reworked || 1 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory#Fitzhugh reworked]]
|-
| Proposal to undo the removal of Prof Smiddy's quote || 7 || [[Talk:Evolution as fact and theory#Proposal to undo the removal of Prof Smiddy's quote]]
|}
| |||