Wikipedia:Graphics Lab/Map workshop/Archive/Mar 2020: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
ClueBot III (talk | contribs) m Archiving 1 discussion from Wikipedia:Graphics Lab/Map workshop. (BOT) |
m (GR) File renamed: File:Legality of child pornography by country.png → File:Map of child pornography legality by country.png Criterion 2 |
||
| (4 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown) | |||
Line 46:
*{{Done}} The map is [[:File:New York City Assembly Districts 1917.png|here]]. Cleanup and adding the Jamaica Bay islands would be much appreciated, but the map is mainly done. – [[User:John M Wolfson|John M Wolfson]] ([[User talk:John M Wolfson|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/John M Wolfson|contribs]]) 19:23, 21 March 2020 (UTC)
== Child pornography law map ==
<gallery>
File:Map of child pornography legality by country.png
</gallery>
;Article(s):
[[Legality of child pornography]]
;Request:
The United Kingdom and the Republic of Ireland should both be coloured either orange or yellow on this map denoting the illegality of child pornography in both countries. I'm not sure which as I'm not sure how either country regards the matter in a fictional sense, but I'm sure ample information is available to be found. This may also be helpful - [[Child pornography laws in the United Kingdom]]. [[User:Helper201|Helper201]] ([[User talk:Helper201|talk]]) 05:19, 11 October 2019 (UTC)
;Discussion:
*The color scheme is odd, as it seems to imply that child pornography should be legal. Perhaps something other than the red-green spectrum should be used. – [[User:John M Wolfson|John M Wolfson]] ([[User talk:John M Wolfson|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/John M Wolfson|contribs]]) 16:10, 20 March 2020 (UTC)
*'''Partially done''' I filled in the UK but don't know about whether Ireland allows real depictions should be used. I also changed the color scheme to address my earlier concern. – [[User:John M Wolfson|John M Wolfson]] ([[User talk:John M Wolfson|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/John M Wolfson|contribs]]) 11:50, 21 March 2020 (UTC)
== Achaemenid Empire and Royal Road ==
<gallery>
Map achaemenid empire en.png|The existing map with the [[Royal Road]] highlighted.
File:Achaemenid_Empire_cylindrical_projection.jpg|More accurate map showing the extend of [[Achaemenid Empire|Achaemenid Persia]].
Achaemenid_Empire_under_different_kings_(flat_map).svg|Another map, showing the development.
</gallery>
;Article(s):
: [[Royal Road]]
: [[Silk Road]]
: [[Historic roads and trails]]
;Request:
: The [[:File:Map achaemenid empire en.png|map used]] in the [[Royal Road]] article needs to be fixed or renewed, because it suggests that the [[Achaemenid Empire]] was "open-ended" in the Northeast. -- [[User:Bender235|bender235]] ([[User talk:Bender235|talk]]) 17:37, 6 May 2020 (UTC)
;Discussion:
: And just as I was looking for more examples, I saw that in the image description of the second map above, there was a relatively [[:File:Achaemenid Empire at its greatest extent according to Oxford Atlas of World History 2002.jpg|new map of the royal road]] uploaded already. {{tl|resolved|[[User:Bender235|bender235]] ([[User talk:Bender235|talk]]) 17:42, 6 May 2020 (UTC)}}
== Prostitution in Europe map ==
<gallery>
File:Prostitution in Europe.svg
</gallery>
;Article(s):
[[Prostitution in Europe]]
;Request:
Per what is stated in the main text of the [[Prostitution in Europe]] article, [[Bosnia and Herzegovina]] should be blue on this map and not red, as according to the main text of the linked page prostitution is legal in the country, but related activities such as solicitation and keeping a brothel are illegal. However, by having the country coloured red on the map it contradicts this by signifying that prostitution is illegal in the country. [[User:Helper201|Helper201]] ([[User talk:Helper201|talk]]) 23:01, 23 March 2020 (UTC)
;Discussion:
== Biblical Mount Sinai ==
{{Location map many | Egypt
| width = 300
| float = right
| caption = Possible locations of Mount Sinai
| mark1 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark2 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark3 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark4 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark5 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark6 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark7 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark8 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark9 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark10 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark11 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark12 = City locator Montagne.svg
| marksize = 15
|mark2size = 15
|mark3size = 15
|mark4size = 15
|mark5size = 15
|mark6size = 15
|mark7size = 15
|mark8size = 15
|mark9size = 15
|mark10size = 15
|mark11size = 15
|mark12size = 15
| label = [[Jabal Maqla]]
| position = bottom
| coordinates = {{coord|28.59674|35.33549}}
| label2 = [[Jabal al-Lawz]]
| pos2 = right
| coordinates2 = {{coord|28.654167| 35.305833}}
| label3 = [[Hala-'l Badr]]
| pos3 = left
| coordinates3 = {{coord|27.25|37.2}}
| label4 =
| pos4 =
| coordinates4 =
| label5 = [[Mount Serbal]]
| pos5 = left
| coordinates5 = {{coord|28.646389| 33.651667}}
| label6 = [[Mount Catherine]]
| pos6 = top
| coordinates6 = {{coord|28.511667| 33.9525}}
| label7 = [[Mount Sinai]]
| pos7 = bottom
| coordinates7 = {{coord|28.539417| 33.975417}}
| label8 = [[Jabal Ahmad al Baqir]]
| pos8 = top
| coordinates8 = {{coord|29.59911|35.14342}}
| label9=[[Jebel al-Madhbah]]
| pos9 = left
| coordinates9 = {{coord|30.321944|35.4475}}
| label10=[[Mount Sin Bishar]]
| pos10 = left
| coordinates10 = {{coord|29.671| 32.961}}
| label11=[[Mount Helal]]
| pos11 = left
| coordinates11 = {{coord|30.653| 34.028861}}
| label12= [[Hashem el-Tarif]]
| pos12 = left
| coordinates12 = {{coord|29.669217|34.633411}}
}}
;Article(s):
: [[Biblical Mount Sinai]]
;Request:
: Could this map be focused in so that the labels don't overlap so much? This is the lead image in a highly visible article. Thank you. [[User:Onceinawhile|Onceinawhile]] ([[User talk:Onceinawhile|talk]]) 07:18, 11 May 2020 (UTC)
;Discussion:
: {{u|Onceinawhile}} Changing the basemap to be ''Egypt Sinai'', made markers smaller when overlapping and updated the caption with locations off map. This provides a quick solution that is easy to maintain.
{{Location map many | Egypt Sinai
| width = 300
| float = right
| caption = Possible locations of Mount Sinai, not shown are [[Jabal Maqla]], [[Jabal al-Lawz]],[[Hala-'l Badr]], [[Jebel al-Madhbah]]
| mark1 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark2 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark3 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark4 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark5 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark6 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark7 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark8 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark9 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark10 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark11 = City locator Montagne.svg
|mark12 = City locator Montagne.svg
| marksize = 15
|mark2size = 15
|mark3size = 15
|mark4size = 15
|mark5size = 15
|mark6size = 10
|mark7size = 10
|mark8size = 15
|mark9size = 15
|mark10size = 15
|mark11size = 15
|mark12size = 15
| label = [[Jabal Maqla]]
| position = bottom
| coordinates = {{coord|28.59674|35.33549}}
| label2 = [[Jabal al-Lawz]]
| pos2 = right
| coordinates2 = {{coord|28.654167| 35.305833}}
| label3 = [[Hala-'l Badr]]
| pos3 = left
| coordinates3 = {{coord|27.25|37.2}}
| label4 =
| pos4 =
| coordinates4 =
| label5 = [[Mount Serbal]]
| pos5 = left
| coordinates5 = {{coord|28.646389| 33.651667}}
| label6 = [[Mount Catherine]]
| pos6 = top
| coordinates6 = {{coord|28.511667| 33.9525}}
| label7 = [[Mount Sinai]]
| pos7 = bottom
| coordinates7 = {{coord|28.539417| 33.975417}}
| label8 = [[Jabal Ahmad al Baqir]]
| pos8 = top
| coordinates8 = {{coord|29.59911|35.14342}}
| label9=[[Jebel al-Madhbah]]
| pos9 = left
| coordinates9 = {{coord|30.321944|35.4475}}
| label10=[[Mount Sin Bishar]]
| pos10 = left
| coordinates10 = {{coord|29.671| 32.961}}
| label11=[[Mount Helal]]
| pos11 = left
| coordinates11 = {{coord|30.653| 34.028861}}
| label12= [[Hashem el-Tarif]]
| pos12 = left
| coordinates12 = {{coord|29.669217|34.633411}}
}}
:Otherwise, a custom map would be needed since the SVG locator maps don't cover the region in enough detail for this purpose. A custom map would not be as easy to edit and would require time and effort to develop. Let me know if you think this partial solution is sufficient. - [[User:DutchTreat|DutchTreat]] ([[User talk:DutchTreat|talk]]) 17:20, 12 May 2020 (UTC)
:Updated caption in proposal. - [[User:DutchTreat|DutchTreat]] ([[User talk:DutchTreat|talk]]) 17:27, 12 May 2020 (UTC)
::Thank you very much for this. This is an improvement. Your points re the custom map are very fair – I have opened a discussion at [[:Module_talk:Location_map#Cropping_maps]] regarding an alternate way of solving the problem which would also open up many new possibilities for the ___location map template. [[User:Onceinawhile|Onceinawhile]] ([[User talk:Onceinawhile|talk]]) 21:06, 12 May 2020 (UTC)
:::FYI, other options include the method described in {{tl|CSS crop}} (see [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Biblical_Mount_Sinai&oldid=956368581 this version of the article]) or using {{tl|OSM Location map}} which doesn't require making new maps for every region. [[User:Frietjes|Frietjes]] ([[User talk:Frietjes|talk]]) 00:00, 13 May 2020 (UTC)
::::Thank you {{u| Frietjes}}, and for fixing the article itself. It looks great! [[User:Onceinawhile|Onceinawhile]] ([[User talk:Onceinawhile|talk]]) 07:56, 13 May 2020 (UTC)
:::::{{ping| Frietjes}} FYI I have copied your trick at the map [[Paris Peace Conference (1919–1920)]]. [[User:Onceinawhile|Onceinawhile]] ([[User talk:Onceinawhile|talk]]) 08:10, 13 May 2020 (UTC)
::{{u|Onceinawhile}} Looks to me like your request is complete. If so, please add {{tl|Resolved}}. - [[User:DutchTreat|DutchTreat]] ([[User talk:DutchTreat|talk]]) 09:57, 15 May 2020 (UTC)
:::Yes it is. Thanks to all. [[User:Onceinawhile|Onceinawhile]] ([[User talk:Onceinawhile|talk]]) 12:58, 15 May 2020 (UTC)
{{tl|resolved|[[User:Onceinawhile|Onceinawhile]] ([[User talk:Onceinawhile|talk]]) 12:58, 15 May 2020 (UTC)}}
{{clear}}
| |||
