Wikipedia:Graphics Lab/Illustration workshop/Archive/Feb 2010: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
restore image that was relevant to discussion |
Replacing Globeanchor.svg with File:Eagle,_Globe_and_Anchor.svg (by CommonsDelinker because: File renamed: Criterion 3 (obvious error)). |
||
| (17 intermediate revisions by 10 users not shown) | |||
Line 5:
<!-- nothing or {{resolved}} or {{Stale|user}} -->
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:USSecDefflag.PNG
File:
File:SEACflag.gif
File:
File:VJCSflag.gif
File:VJCSflag.svg|'''Done'''
File:United States Department of Defense Seal.svg|Take the eagle from here...
File:SecretaryOfTheNavyFlag.png|not done
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[United States Secretary of Defense]]...etc
Line 32:
<!-- nothing or {{resolved}} or {{Stale|user}} -->
<div class="center">{{GLNF|ScrumLargeLabelled.png}}</
'''Article(s):''' [[Scrum (development)]]
'''Request:''' As the image in question is likely non-free and will get deleted, please create a original free rough equivalent [[User:Cybercobra|<b
'''Graphist opinion(s):'''
Line 43:
<!-- nothing or {{resolved}} or {{Stale|user}} -->
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Grb kotromanica.gif
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' too many to list
'''Request:''' Vectorize <
'''Graphist opinion(s):''' <s>May want to ask [[User:Sodacan|Sodacan]].</s> Requested. [[User:Connormah|Connormah]] ([[User talk:Connormah|talk]]) 00:03, 27 January 2010 (UTC)
Line 61:
<!-- nothing or {{resolved}} or {{Stale|user}} -->
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Retired_Atlantic_hurricane_tracks.png|retired atlantic hurricane tracks
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[Brazil]]
Line 83:
<!-- nothing or {{resolved}} or {{Stale|user}} -->
<div class="center"><gallery>
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[United States Capitol]]
Line 123:
{{Notice|This request also appear in Commons as [[:commons:Commons:Graphic_Lab/Illustration_workshop#Coat_of_Arms_of_Australia|Coat of Arms of Australia]].}}
<!-- nothing or {{resolved}} or {{Stale|user}} -->
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Coat of arms of Australia.svg|Unfinished SVG
File:Australian Coat of Arms.png|What it's supposed to look like
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' A plethora of articles related to Australia, including the [[Australia]] article itself.
'''Request:''' The image is an unfinished vector version of the [[Australian coat of arms]] uploaded to commons by a user who couldn't continue working on the project. The shield partitions themselves are quite easy (they can just be taken from [[List of Australian flags#States_and_Territories|state flag]] badges), so all that needs to be done is basically just adding detail the to the shield-bearers, shrubbery, etc. to conform to actual usage, and colour fixes as demonstrated by the raster image. I've also posted this at [[Talk:Australia#Vector coat of arms]], but I'm told to expect apathy over there, there've been issues with the COA since April 2007. I have no doubt an experienced vector graphics editor would find this an easy task and it would be much appreciated. —[[User talk:Happenstance|<
:This has come up several times and every time we point out that it shouldn't be vectorized. Look at the painting and you will see that it is carefully pained with tiny strokes. An SVG would be enormous and have no purpose. --[[User:Beao|Bea]]'''[[User talk:Beao|o]]''' 17:35, 14 January 2010 (UTC)
::I disagree, all non-photographic information should be turned into vector images, as our guidelines currently mandate. The vast majority of national coat of arms have already been recreated as svg's despite their complexity, and this image is not even particularly detailed compared to many that are already vector files, look at [[:File:
:::Those are not as complex in the way I'm trying to explain. But I wont stop anyone from trying to vectorize if you find it useful. --[[User:Beao|Bea]]'''[[User talk:Beao|o]]''' 14:08, 15 January 2010 (UTC)
::Last time I knew "we" regularly vectorized flags, coats, etc. Certainly a well done vector is equal to or better than a raster. See, for instance, Panonkin's magnificent [[:Image:US Great Seal Reverse.svg]] (Featured image on Commons). Having said that, there was a TERRIBLE traced vector version of this that was deleted a while ago. That I know gave alot of people a bad taste for vectorizing this. I especially second this request. [[Special:Contributions/76.117.247.55|76.117.247.55]] ([[User talk:76.117.247.55|talk]]) 02:13, 23 January 2010 (UTC)
Line 145:
<!-- nothing or {{resolved}} or {{Stale|user}} -->
<div class="center"><gallery>
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[WP:Squash]]
'''Request:''' Create a squash (sport) barnstar for the above project please. Thanks. <
Still waiting for someone to do the barnstar. You guys might want to use some images from [[WP:Squash]]. <
:I think the reason no one has done this so far is because "squash" is such a specific thing. What would a "squash" barnstar look like? I suggest that we just have a "sports articles" barnstar ,which would do the trick, would be easier to create, and would be easier to recognize. [[User:Threecheersfornick|threecheersfornick]] ([[User talk:Threecheersfornick|talk]]) 04:18, 30 January 2010 (UTC)
::You might want to use [[:File:Squash pictogram.svg|this pictogram]] or [[:File:Squash ball.svg|this squash ball]] for the barnstar. I also suggest that you use [[:File:Resilient Barnstar.png|this silverish barnstar]] or this [[:File:GoldBarnstar.png|gold]] barnstar instead of the brownish one. <
'''Graphist opinion(s):'''
Line 171:
'''Article(s):''' [[Saint Xavier's Institution]] and [[Penang]]
'''Request:''' Improve these images and remove white backgrounds <
:And convert them to PNG or SVG if possible. Thanks <
'''Graphist opinion(s):'''
Line 183:
<!-- nothing or {{resolved}} or {{Stale|user}} -->
<div class="center">
{{GLNF|Bombay Scottish School Logo.png|Bombay Scottish School Logo}}
</
'''Article(s):''' [[Bombay Scottish School, Mahim]] and [[Bombay Scottish School, Powai]]
Line 212:
== Wing_steering_components.JPG ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Wing steering components.svg|Vectorized
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[Wings]]
Line 229:
== Jammu and Kashmir ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Seal of Jammu and Kashmir.jpg
File:Seal of Jammu and Kashmir greyscale.png | enhanced version
File:Seal of Jammu and Kashmir color.png|Extracted from the JPG
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[Jammu and Kashmir]]
Line 251:
{{resolved}}
<div class="center">
{{GLNF|Australian Open.jpg|Australian Open logo}}
</
'''Article(s):''' [[Australian Open]]
'''Request:''' Can someone please improve this image and convert them to PNG or SVG? Thanks <
'''Graphist opinion(s):'''
{{Done}}. SVG is now available as [[:File:Australian Open logo.svg|Australian Open logo.svg]]. Cheers, [[User:Quibik|Quibik]] ([[User talk:Quibik|talk]]) 23:34, 30 January 2010 (UTC)
::Thank you Quibik! <
== punjabi (pa) Wikipedia logo ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Wikipedia-logo-pa.png|The pa Wikipedia logo
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' alot
'''Request:''' this image has the word ਇਕ which really should be spelled as ਇੱਕ so this typo is all over the punjabi wiki since its on the main punjabi wikipedia logo. So, would that be possible to change? <
:So, could someone fix that please? Also how would i edit png images and put text in them if i wanted to? <
::For editing PNGs (or any other bitmap images) and adding text to them, I'd recommend [[GIMP]] (http://www.gimp.org/). The text tool can be found at the main toolbar. If you need any further help, feel free to ask. —[[User:Quibik|Quibik]] ([[User talk:Quibik|talk]]) 21:04, 10 February 2010 (UTC)
'''Graphist opinion(s):'''
{{Done}}. I added the missing bit. Does it look correct? —[[User:Quibik|Quibik]] ([[User talk:Quibik|talk]]) 20:47, 10 February 2010 (UTC)
:Yes, that looks better. Thank You. but could that bit that was added be made just a little biger? its supposed to be about double the current size? <
::Are you sure about that? I added that curvy bit by superimposing text with the same size as the text in the image. So it should be scaled correctly, I think. —[[User:Quibik|Quibik]] ([[User talk:Quibik|talk]]) 22:56, 10 February 2010 (UTC)
::I uploaded a new version. I tried to scale and position it as accurately as possible. Is this better? —[[User:Quibik|Quibik]] ([[User talk:Quibik|talk]]) 23:14, 10 February 2010 (UTC)
:::Yes it is better. and Thank You Quibik. :) <
{{resolved}}
== korea ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Plum blossoms design 01.svg|''SVGized''.
</gallery></
'''Article(s):'''
Line 295:
<!-- This area is for wikigraphists: -->
{{I take|Fred the Oyster}}.<br>
::{{Done}}: Updated. --[[User:Shandris|''Shandris'']][[User:Shandris|<
:That is so much better, thank you! --[[User:Kintetsubuffalo|Chris (クリス • フィッチュ)]] ([[User talk:Kintetsubuffalo|talk]]) 05:14, 11 February 2010 (UTC)
==Article Incubator Barnstar==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Songbird-egg.svg|Incubator, something to do with an egg
File:Incubator_barnstar.png | here's a quick and dirty eggstar
File:Hatching barnstar.png | here's it hatching!
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[WP:Article Incubator]]
Line 315:
{{I take|Threecheersfornick}}
:How's this?
::Nicey <
:::'''Done''' then.
::::Umm, there's a problem, could you make it in SVG format? Thanks <
:::::I'll give it a shot. [[User:Connormah|Connormah]] ([[User talk:Connormah|talk]]) 00:02, 27 January 2010 (UTC)
:::::The original barnstar is not vector, which is why I exported the final image as raster -- I thought having that mix of raster and vector would be weird. I think it is possible to embed the raster in the SVG, or we could use a vector barnstar if it's super important. Anyways, that was my thinking. If Connormah doesn't have any luck (Which I hope , I can do another, too, but not today. Also, all of the other barnstars listed at [[WP:Barnstars]] [[User:Threecheersfornick|threecheersfornick]] ([[User talk:Threecheersfornick|talk]]) 00:13, 27 January 2010 (UTC)
Line 323:
:::::::Sorry, I've been unable to come up with anything even half-decent. [[User:Connormah|Connormah]] ([[User talk:Connormah|talk]]) 00:24, 27 January 2010 (UTC)
::::::::I like it, I will see what the project thinks! [[User:Ikip|Ikip]] 20:46, 27 January 2010 (UTC)
:::I did one too, it's sized as raster like all the other barnstars (due to the size of the original barnstar they're all based on and traditional use) at about 110-120px which is sufficent for how barnstars are used... I thought the star should be hatching from the egg... — <b>[[User:Raeky|<i
::::The hatching barnstar looks awesome. Thank you Raeky. <
== Interesting graph ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
Image:ComputerMemoryHierarchy.png
Image:ComputerMemoryHierarchy.svg|Vectorized
</gallery></
'''Article:''' [[Orders of magnitude (data)]]
Line 357:
== old IRFU flag ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:IRFU flag.svg|Public ___domain IRFU flag
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' Lots of Irish rugby related articles .
Line 371:
== Rugby barnstar ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Ru ball.svg|Rugby ball
File:Original Barnstar.png|Barnstar
File:Rugby barnstar.png|Rugby barnstar
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' Rugby barnstar
Line 402:
== Pentagon crash site ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Aerial_view_of_the_Pentagon_during_rescue_operations_post-September_11_attack.JPEG|The Pentagon damaged by fire and partly collapsed.
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[September 11 attacks]]
Line 419:
{{Resolved}}
<!-- nothing or {{resolved}} or {{Stale|user}} -->
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Microcebus scale.svg|Size comparison of a [[Mouse lemur]] to a human
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[Gray Mouse Lemur]]
Line 432:
{{Resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Sikhi1.jpg|A diagram of some of the beliefs of the Sikh religion.
File:Sikhi1.svg|Vectorized image
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[Three pillars of Sikhism]]
Line 445:
== Convert vector graphics format to replace NewickExample.jpg ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:NewickExample.eps|To replace http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:NewickExample.jpg
File:NewickExample.svg|Done
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[Newick format]]
Line 467:
== EGA progenitor ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Old EGA.png|Progenitor to the modern [[Eagle, Globe, and Anchor]], please make background transparent.
File:USMC oldEGA button.jpg|Modern incarnation (just for fun, no work needed)
File:
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[Eagle, Globe, and Anchor]], [[United States Marine Corps History Division]], possibly [[History of the United States Marine Corps]] later
Line 488:
== SVG of Clicktime.com logo ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
:File:CT Prod logo.jpg <!--Non-Free file removed by DASHBot-->|Logo for Clicktime.com
:File:ClickTime.com logo.svg <!--Non-Free file removed by DASHBot-->|Vectorized
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[Clicktime.com]]
Line 514:
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
:File:Fiji Girl Guides Association.png <!--Non-Free file removed by DASHBot-->|blue/gold should be changed to pale green/red, '''remove all black bordering as unnecessary'''
Line 531:
:File:Uganda Girl Guides Association.svg <!--Non-Free file removed by DASHBot-->|Vectorised
File:WikiProject_Scouting_trefoil_blank.svg|Blank template
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' multiple
Line 550:
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Serial Killer Task Force.jpg
File:Serial Killer Task Force.svg
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' Serial Killer Task Force
Line 565:
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Flag of Burma 1943.gif|Original GIF
File:Flag of Burma 1943.svg|SVG
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' multiple
Line 604:
==L-arginine ethyl ester==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:L-Arginine_Ethyl_Ester.png
File:L-Arginine_Ethyl_Ester.svg|Vector version.
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[User:Healthycare/L-arginine_ethyl_ester]]
Line 637:
== Keep Calm and Carry On ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Keep-calm-and-carry-on.svg|"Keep Calm and Carry On", a famous poster produced by the [[Ministry of Information (United Kingdom)|Ministry of Information]] in WWII
File:Keep Calm and Carry On Poster.svg|Retraced poster
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[Keep Calm and Carry On]], [[motivational poster]], [[Ministry of Information (United Kingdom)]]
Line 652:
:::I've just been contacted by [[User:WebHamster|WebHamster]] to let me know (so I can respond here) that he has corrected the rotation on the text (and uploaded and replaced the original vector version). Apparently it's a bit of an optical illusion as it was only 0.036 degrees off true. --[[User:Fred the Oyster|Fred the Oyster]] ([[User talk:Fred the Oyster|talk]]) 14:09, 8 February 2010 (UTC)
::::While that's most surely an improvement, I have a source with a higher-resolution file that will eliminate, for example, the circle irregularities near the crown. I'll proceed to do this anyways. [[User:Mononomic|Mononomic]] ([[User talk:Mononomic|talk]]) 23:44, 8 February 2010 (UTC)
*'''Comment:''' I read that the letters in the original poster do not belong to any font type, that they were hand made by a graphic designer. If that is true it would be good to work from a raster picture of a original poster or at least to use it to check if those problems were also there. <small><span style="border:1px solid black;padding:0.5px;">[[User:franklin.vp|<
:*I've heard the same. I'm still trying to acquire that high-resolution image. If that falls through, I'll just have to trace it by hand from another image. [[User:Mononomic|Mononomic]] ([[User talk:Mononomic|talk]]) 03:21, 20 February 2010 (UTC)
{{done}} I've completed the vectorization, and have uploaded it to Commons as [[:File:Keep Calm and Carry On Poster.svg]]. It should be significantly better, as I've retraced it from a variety of different images from scratch. It should be much straighter and much more accurate. Let me know what you think. Cheers! [[User:Mononomic|Mononomic]] ([[User talk:Mononomic|talk]]) 01:39, 21 February 2010 (UTC)
Line 659:
== Royal Flag of Swaziland ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:
File:
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[Flag of Swaziland]]
Line 673:
== Golf course diagram ==
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:2009-07-18-GolfField-17.JPG
File:Golf_field.svg|Vector.
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[Golf]]
Line 700:
{{resolved}}
<div class="center"><gallery>
File:Taj floorplan.gif|GIF
File:Taj floorplan.svg|SVG
</gallery></
'''Article(s):''' [[Taj Mahal]]
| |||
