Wikipedia:WikiProject Rowing/FISA database errors: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 17:22, 27 January 2018

Latest revision as of 15:15, 3 February 2025

(48 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)

Line 27:

| [[Natalie Yatsenko]]

| {{Q|Q47260943}}

| {{FISA | 29018 | Natalia FEDORENKO}}<br />{{FISA | 36359 | Natalia IATSENKO}}

| Probably the same person, with maiden and married name.

|-

Line 76:

| {{Q|Q47455182}}

| {{FISA | 41874 | Georgi GEORGIEV Y.}}

| This looks like a “true”"true" duplicate, but with different dates of birth. He even appears twice in the results pages of the events at which he participated.

|-

| {{FISA | 37877 | Werner LUTZ}}

| [[Werner Lutz]]

| {{Q|Q47318112}}

| {{FISA | 36852 | Lutz WERNER}}

| Competitions spread over two entries, with given and family name transposed.

|-

| {{FISA | 8144 | Maria OMELJANOVITCH}}

| [[Mariya Omelianovych]]

| {{Q|Q47462927}}

| {{FISA | 35250 | Maria DANILIUK}}

| Danyliuk (Daniliuk) is her maiden name.

|-

| {{FISA | 5337 | Irina KALIMBET}}

| [[Irina Kalimbet]]

| {{Q|Q12107942}}

| {{FISA | 10973 | Irina TIKHANOVA}}

| Tikhanova (Tikhonova) is her married name.

|-

| {{FISA | 29148 | Reda RIBINSKAITE}}

| [[Reda Ribinskaitė]]

| {{Q|Q51844396}}

| {{FISA | 10430 | Reda STANEVICIENE}}

| Stanevichene (Staneviciene) is her married name.

|-

| {{FISA | 29143 | Elena PUKAJEVA}}

| [[Yelena Pukhayeva]]

| {{Q|Q4384499}}

| {{FISA | 31024 | Olena PUKHAIEVA}}

| Russian and Ukraine spelling of the same name.

|-

| {{FISA | 8048 | Michael O'GORMAN}}

| [[Michael O'Gorman (rowing)]]

| {{Q|47452447}}

| {{FISA | 34714 | Mike GORMAN}}

| Same competitor.

|-

| {{FISA | 31309 | Ursula MAEK-WAGNER}}

| [[Ursula Wagner]]

| {{Q|7901283}}

| {{FISA | 39750 | Ursula UNGER}}

| Wagner is her maiden name, she then competed under her married name Unger; Maek is her current name.

|-

| {{FISA | 37817 | Ludmila PARFENOVA }}

| [[Ludmila Parfenova]]

| {{Q|Q47456192}}

| {{FISA | 38486 | Ludmila PARPHJOONOVA }}

| Schwede66's guess is that this is one and the same person.

|-

| {{FISA | 9747 | Rita SCHMIDT-KOEPPEN }}

| [[Rita Bludau]]

| {{Q|Q16227511}}

| {{FISA | 22825 | Rita BLUDAU }}

| Same person.

|-

| {{FISA | 27519 | Rosemary CLUGSTON }}

| [[Rosemary Mayglothling]]

| {{Q|Q47467368}}

| {{FISA | 3871 | Rosemary GLUGSTON }}<br>{{ FISA | 29837 | Rosie MAYGLOTHLING }}

| Erroneous spelling for 1980, and separate entry under married name as official

|-

| {{FISA | 2244| Thomas CROFT}}

| [[Thomas Croft Buck]]

| {{Q|Q45168053}}

| {{FISA | 34527 | Thomas BUCK}}

| An IP editor has changed the name in the article to Thomas Croft BUCK plus added another medal to the tally, which appears in the database under the second name. The rower has commented on the talk page and explained the situation, and pointed out that FISA has three entries for him; the third one as "Thomas BUCH" (Q47452625, already redirected to the main item).

|-

| {{FISA | 12198| Antonina Zelikovitch}}

| [[Antonina Makhina]]

| {{Q|Q4776350}}

| {{FISA | 6818 | Antonina Makhina-Dumtcheva}}

| First competed under her maiden name and then had two rowers as spouses (well, not simultaneously).

|}

Line 86 ⟶ 158:

! Wikidata

! Issue

|-

| {{FISA | 23067 | Roline REPELAER VAN DRIEL}}

Line 127 ⟶ 198:

| {{Q|Q11815843}}

| Wrong gender (should be M)

|-

| {{FISA | 5565 | Seong Ok KIM}}

| [[Kim Seong-ok]]

| {{Q|Q47492166}}

| Wrong gender (should be W)

|-

| {{FISA | 8403 | Cy PEARSON}}

| [[Cy Pearson]]

| {{Q|Q61720962}}

| Wrong gender (should be M)

|-

| {{FISA | 13123 | Mark WISSING}}

| [[Mark Wissing]]

| {{Q|Q61722330}}

| Wrong gender (should be M)

|-

| {{FISA | 28055 | Masakatsu YAMANOUCHI}}

| [[Masakatsu Yamanouchi]]

| {{Q|Q56222519}}

| Wrong gender (should be M)

|-

| {{FISA | 29340 | James EDMONDS}}

| [[James Edmonds (rower)]]

| {{Q|Q56254401}}

| Wrong gender (should be M)

|-

| {{FISA | 5313 | Bettina KAEMPF-MCINTYRE}}

| [[Bettina Kämpf]]

| {{Q|Q56599881}}

| Wrong gender (should be W)

|-

| {{FISA | 28057 | Hae-eun AN}}

| [[An Hae-eun]]

| {{Q|Q56486746}}

| Wrong gender (should be W)

|-

| {{FISA | 9753 | Christl SCHMIDT-LEHNERT}}

| [[Christl Schmidt-Lehnert]]

| {{Q|Q47571258}}

| Wrong gender (should be W)

|-

| colspan="4" style="background:#eaecf0;text-align:center;" | ''difficult cases due to sparse information in FISA profile''

Line 139 ⟶ 250:

| {{Q|Q18222827}}

| Wrong gender (should be M); German competitor of the 1966 World Rowing Championships

|-

| {{FISA | 1476 | BRUECKHAENDLER }}

| (assumed) [[Jochen Brückhändler]]

| {{Q|Q48160773}}

| Wrong gender (should be M)

|-

| {{FISA | 8839 | Ch. PREY}}

| (assumed) [[Christian Prey]]

| {{Q|Q47476866}}

| Wrong gender (should be M)

|-

| {{FISA | 10930 | D. THOMETSCHEK}}

| (assumed) [[Dagobert Thometschek]]

| {{Q|Q47476813}}

| Wrong gender (should be M)

|-

| {{FISA | 6055 | P. KUHN}}

| (assumed) [[Peter Kuhn (rower)]]

| {{Q|Q47471217}}

| Wrong gender (should be M)

|-

| {{FISA | 8351 | G. PASTINE}}

| (assumed) [[Giovanni Battista Pastine]]

| {{Q|Q53815858}}

| Wrong gender (should be M)

|-

| {{FISA | 29969 | PEYRONNIE}}

| Peyronnie

| {{Q|Q61062189}}

| Wrong gender (should be M)

|}

Line 162 ⟶ 303:

| {{FISA | 4827 | Elena OPREA-HORVATH }}

| [[Elena Horvat]]

| Did she really compete at the [[1971 European Rowing Championships]] and win a bronze medal as a 13-year-old? There's an interesting discussion on the [[:de:Benutzer Diskussion:Geher#Elena Horvat|talk page of her German article]].<br>''Update 2020-03-08:'' User:MisterSynergy asked the SR experts and they are meanwhile reasonably convinced that there are two persons. "Elena Horvat" (from 1985 on "Elena Florea") competed 1981–1985 (including the 1984 Olympic gold medal win), and "Elena Oprea" competed 1971–1980 (including two Olympic participations 1976+1980 without medalling). Horvat (-Florea) was born 1958-07-04 as written in most sources; Oprea might have been born 1953-10-05, but this is not that sure; this would mean that she would have been almost 18 years old at her first appearance in 1971. This data is not yet public, but I think the SR successor website will come up with two profiles.

|-

| {{FISA | 9566 | Terence SANDERS }}

Line 186 ⟶ 327:

| {{FISA | 21802 | Robert Michael GIBSON}}

| [[Robert Gibson (rower)]]

| Two early 1980s appearances in the profile of Gibson (* 1986) belong to a different rower. [[Ted Gibson]] ([http://www.worldrowing.com/athletes/athlete/37543/gibson 37543]) would be a candidate, but this is pure speculation base on his surname, Canadian citizenship, and appearance in 1980. Also check ([http://www.worldrowing.com/athletes/athlete/19241/results/gibson-robert])

|-

| {{FISA | 24559 | Juliana TOGANEL}}; {{FISA | 27559 | James GILLAN}}

Line 247 ⟶ 388:

| [[Javier Aguirregomezcorta]]<br />[[Diego Aguirregomezcorta]]

| Seemingly related rowing persons from Bilbao, Spain. There is a 2000 Olympic M2- event participation for Argentina, which is attributed to Javier at FISA, and to Diego everywhere else (e.g. [https://www.sports-reference.com/olympics/athletes/ag/diego-aguirregomezcorta-1.html sports-reference]). They apparently did row together for Spain at international rowing events later in their careers.<br>2000 Olympics was Diego, according to the [http://library.la84.org/6oic/OfficialReports/2000/Masters/ro/ROresults.pdf official report].

|-

| {{FISA | 27253 | Mathias HAGLUND}}

| {{Q|Q49114543}}

| This is the profile of the 1912 Finnish Olympic rower [[Axel Matias Haglund]] (1884–1948). He did not compete at the 2000 World Rowing Cup.

|-

| {{FISA | 24423 | Vaclav CHALUPA SR}}

| {{Q|Q47457402}}

| Profile contains the 1989 M1x silver medal that belongs to his son, also called [[Václav Chalupa]].

|-

| {{FISA | 9537 | Valeriy SAMARA}}

| {{Q|Q47491133}}

| Profile mixes two persons

|-

| {{FISA | 26654 |Christo JELEV }}; {{FISA |26687|Atanas JELEV}}

| {{Q|Q47455166}}<br />{{Q|Q56223014}}

| According to FISA, [[Khristo Zhelev]] competed at the 1968 and 1976 Olympics. According to Sports Reference, [[Atanas Zhelev]] competed in 1968 and [[Khristo Zhelev]] competed in 1976.

|-

| {{FISA | 28789 | Thore BOERJESSON}}

| {{Q|Q9358565}}

| 1924-born Olympic competitor in 1952 (M8+); very unlikely that he competed as a lightweight rower in 1974

|}

Line 292 ⟶ 453:

| [[Eulogio Génova]]

| There's (probably) a spelling mistake in the maternal family name.

|-

| 1975 M4x

| [[Stefan Weiße]], [[Christof Kreuziger]]

| The whole M4x event is missing from the database. It appears that those rowers who only medalled in that event are also missing from the database. Update: Kreuziger is listed as {{FISA | 5967 | Christof KREUZINGER}}, and Weiße presumably as {{FISA | 11797 | Stephan WEISE}} (empty profile)

|-

| {{FISA | 30405 | Nataliya MUSTAFAYEVA }}

Line 308 ⟶ 465:

| {{Q|Q47452625}}

| Listed with American citizenship, but started for Denmark only

|-

| n/a

| [[Helmut Sauermilch]]

| Missing on FISA database

|-

| {{FISA | 3991|Frank GOTTSCHALK}}

| [[Frank Gottschalt]]

| Spelling mistake

|-

| 1999 World Rowing Cup I [http://www.worldrowing.com/events/1999-worldcup-1/womens-quadruple-sculls W4x]

| {{FISA | 10454 | Natalia STASIUK}}, {{FISA | 883 | Volha BERAZNIOVA}}, {{FISA | 12154 | Inesa JANSEN-ZAKHAREUSKAYA}}, {{FISA | 33373 | Natalia LAURYNENKA}}

| Wrong country code for the team (is "UKR" boat 2, but should be "BLR" as all of the team members are Belarusians)

|-

| {{FISA |1805|Jacobo CASTIÑEIRA}}

| [[Jacobo Castiñeira]]

| encoding error (personal name)

|-

| {{FISA |16616|Hanna JAGEFELDT}}

| [[Hanna Jagefeldt]]

| encoding error (club name in infobox)

|-

| {{FISA |22322|Fedir PYRYATYNS’KYY}}

| [[Fedir Pyryatyns'kyy]] (correct?)

| encoding error (personal name)

|-

| {{FISA |32403|Baris VESEKÇI}}

| [[Barış Vesekçi]]

| encoding error (personal name)

|-

| {{FISA |42679|Per BJÖRNSKIÖLD}}

| [[Per Björnskiöld]]

| encoding error (personal name)

|-

| {{FISA |49558|Henry CHAVES QUIRÓS}}

| [[Henry Chaves Quirós]]

| encoding error (personal name)

|-

| {{FISA |49598|Robert NIESYCZYŃSKI}}

| [[Robert Niesyczyński]]

| encoding error (personal name); also a duplicate of {{FISA|45418|Robert NIESYCZYNSKI}}

|-

| {{FISA |50130|Marcelo D’ANGELO}}

| [[Marcelo D'Angelo]]

| encoding error (personal name)

|}

== Event-level gaps and mistakes ==

{| class="wikitable"

|-

! FISA ID and name

! Issue

|-

| [http://www.worldrowing.com/events/1962-world-championships/schedule-results 1962 WRCH]

| All 7 events missing

|-

| [http://www.worldrowing.com/events/1966-world-championships/schedule-results 1966 WRCH]

| All 7 events missing

|-

| [http://www.worldrowing.com/events/1970-world-championships/schedule-results 1970 WRCH]

| All 7 events missing

|-

| [http://www.worldrowing.com/events/1974-world-championships/schedule-results 1974 WRCH]

| All events but LM1x, LM4-, and LM8+ are not connected to the rowers who participated.

|-

| 1975 WRCH M4x

| The whole M4x event is missing from the database. It appears that those rowers who only medalled in that event are also missing from the database (examples: [[Stefan Weiße]], [[Christof Kreuziger]]). Update: Kreuziger is listed as {{FISA | 5967 | Christof KREUZINGER}}, and Weiße presumably as {{FISA | 11797 | Stephan WEISE}} (empty profile)

|-

| [http://www.worldrowing.com/events/1981-world-championships/mens-pair/ 1981 WRCH M2-]

| The event is in the database, but there are no rowers linked; Both A and B final are listed with the same crews, which seem to be B finalists; the rower profiles of the A finalists appear empty for this event (example: [http://www.worldrowing.com/athletes/athlete/8627/results/pimenov-nikolai Nikolai Pimenov, 8627])

|-

| [http://www.worldrowing.com/events/1987-world-championships/ 1987 WRCH]

| The regatta (mostly) lists RUS as a participating nation but that should be URS.

|-

| 1995 World Rowing Cup II regatta (in Paris)

| There is [http://www.worldrowing.com/events/1995-worldcup-4/ 1995 World Rowing Cup IV] containing results (although it was the second World Cup of that year), and an empty [http://www.worldrowing.com/events/1995-worldcup-2/ 1995 World Rowing Cup II] regatta. The fourth regatta of that season was in [http://www.worldrowing.com/events/1995-worldcup-4-final/ Lucerne].

|-

| 2003 WRCH LTAM4+

| There was an "LTAM4+" event at the 2003 WRCH that was different from the LTAMix4+ event. However, FISA lists them as one event at [http://www.worldrowing.com/events/2003-adaptive-world-rowing-championships/lta-mixed-coxed-quadruple-sculls/ here], with the LTAM4+ as the B final of the LTAMix4+. It seems that the LTAM4+ event was only held once, and it could have been a demo event.

|}