Module talk:Sanctions: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 05:27, 12 June 2023

Latest revision as of 04:25, 1 June 2025

(One intermediate revision by one other user not shown)

Line 4:

{{R from remote talk page}}

}}

{{notice|Actual talk discussion for this module should be redirected to '''[[Template talk:Gs]]'''}}

==TODOs / issues==

* Support alias calls (eg from {{t|Gs/alert}}) {{done}}

* Default sizes (long if restrictions, etc)

** Less options in general, standardise a style

* Move msgs out of main module

* Raw mode for table (eg for {{t|Community sanction}})

* Do something about the community sanction, block and topic ban templates

* Do something about the alert template (ref ANI discussion) - find some interested parties

* Make [[WP:GS]] more useful

** [[Wikipedia:Administrators%27_noticeboard#Community_sanctions_log_centralisation|log pages]]

*** Standardised templates to make logging easier and more searchable

* Editnotices don't show on mobile ({{phab|T201595}}).

* Trim the notices. Too much extraneous info.

===Other===

* {{EF|602}} (ie [[MediaWiki:Abusefilter-warning-DS]]) should not display "Arbitration Committee" for community sanctions (which also use 602). Hide conditionally if possible, or request separate EF?

* Combine multiple talk notice restrictions into one template

===Progress===

Also see: [[Wikipedia_talk:General_sanctions#Talk_notice_template_proposal|WT:GS § Talk notice template proposal]]

*<b>{{t|Gs/talk notice}}</b> {{done}}

**{{t|Gs/talk notice|crypto|type=long}}

**{{t|gs/talk notice|sasg}} - standard wrapper, should be replaced and obsolete

**{{t|Gs/talk notice|covid}} - standard wrapper, should be replaced and obsolete

**{{t|Gs/talk notice|mj}} - standard wrapper, should be replaced and obsolete

**{{t|Gs/talk notice|scwisil}}

*<b>{{t|Gs/alert}}</b> {{done}}

**Sync {{t|Gs/alert/sandbox}}

:<b>{{t|Gs/topics/table}}</b> (documentation table) {{done}}

**Sync {{t|Gs/topics/table/sandbox}}

*<b>{{t|Gs/topics}}</b> (helper func to return data from module, for use in other templates) {{done}}

**Sync {{t|Gs/topics/sandbox}}

**{{t|Community sanction}} - no changes required (due to above)

*<b>{{t|Gs/editnotice}}</b>

**{{t|COVID19 GS editnotice}} (should this one even exist? no page-level sanctions exist for COVID; this would be the only time any DS/GS sanction uses an editnotice in such a case. ping {{ping|L235|p=}})

**{{t|Editnotice blockchain 1RR}}

**{{t|Editnotice SCW 1RR}}

----

{{re|ProcrastinatingReader}} I mean, you're absolutely right that the COVID editnotice probably shouldn't exist. '''[[User:L235|Kevin]]''' (<small>aka</small> [[User:L235|L235]] '''·''' [[User talk:L235#top|t]] '''·''' [[Special:Contribs/L235|c]]) 19:59, 30 July 2020 (UTC)

==Talk notices==

===Parameters===

Rough plan...

* {{para|1}} / {{para|topic}} topic

* {{para|type|long/standard/mini}}. Alias {{para|2}}. Default = 'standard'. Mini is the shortest one. Standard splits up 'mini' into two paragraphs, and displays page-level restrictions. Long will also display remedies and exemptions.

* Common admin page-level sanctions:

** {{para|1rr}} 1RR is applicable to this article

** {{para|consensusrequired}} challenged edits require consensus

** {{para|brd}} BRD is required

*Custom page-level restrictions: {{para|restriction1}} (details of restriction), {{para|log1}} (diff of admin adding entry to log)

===With this template===

====Long====

{{Gs/talk notice|topic=crypto|type=long}}

====Standard====

{{Gs/talk notice|crypto|standard}}

====Mini====

{{Gs/talk notice|crypto|mini}}

====Custom restrictions====

{{Gs/talk notice|crypto|long|restriction1=Don't do XYZ etc}}

{{Gs/talk notice|crypto|long|brd=y|consensusrequired=y}}

===Reference: ArbCom===

{{tl|IPA AE |Consensus required= |BRD= }}

{{American politics AE |Consensus required= |BRD= }}

{{ArbCom Arab-Israeli enforcement}}

{{Ds/talk notice|mos}}

{{Ds/talk notice|mos|brief}}

===Reference: Community===

====Blockchain====

{{Gs/talk notice|crypto|type=long}}

{{Gs/talk notice|crypto|type=mini}}

====MJ====

{{Gs/talk notice|mj}}

====SASG====

{{gs/talk notice|sasg}}

====Generic====

{{Sanctions}}

==Edit notices==

General principle: Edit notices are best used for additional page-level restrictions; they should ''generally'' not be used if only DS is authorised. (see {{t|ArbCom Arab-Israeli editnotice}}, {{t|IPA AE/Edit notice}}, [[Special:Diff/963614122]]). As of current, that would mean editnotices be used for SCW&ISIL and Crypto only.

===Params===

*{{para|topic}}

*{{para|1rr}}, (later possibly consensusrequired, brd, 500/30) - preset/common restrictions

*{{para|restriction1}}, {{para|log1}} - custom restrictions

===With this template===

{{Gs/editnotice|crypto}}

{{Gs/editnotice|crypto|restriction1=test (A)}}

{{Gs/editnotice|crypto|1rr=yes}}

{{Gs/editnotice|crypto|consensusrequired=yes}}

{{Gs/editnotice|crypto|1rr=yes|consensusrequired=yes}}

{{Gs/editnotice|crypto|restriction1=test (B)}}

===Reference: ArbCom===

{{Contentious topics/editnotice||expiry=}}

{{ArbCom Arab-Israeli editnotice|nocat=yes}}

{{IPA AE/Edit notice|nocat=yes}}