Talk:Quantum Memory Matrix: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 16:50, 22 July 2025

Latest revision as of 21:11, 22 July 2025

(2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)

Line 2:

{{WikiProject Articles for creation |ts=20250716115149 |reviewer=JeBonSer |oldid=1300737584}}

{{WikiProject Physics}}

{{WikiProject Astronomy|importance=lowhigh}}

{{WikiProject Mathematics}}

{{WikiProject Philosophy}}

Line 13:

:Thanks for flagging sourcing. A few clarifications:

:'''1 Independent, peer-reviewed literature (non-MDPI)'''

:Neukart F. et al., “QMM-Enhanced Error Correction,” Advanced Quantum Technologies (Wiley, 20242025).

: – Community-run journal published by Wiley.

:Neukart F., “Geometry-Information Duality (GID) and Black-Hole Entropy,” Annals of Physics (Elsevier, 2025).

: – Long-standing, rigorously refereed physics journal.

:These add to the previously cited articles, giving '''three separate publishers - Wiley, Elsevier, and MDPI''' -, each with independent peer review and citations by unaffiliated researchers.

:'''2 About MDPI material'''

:Community views on MDPI vary (see WP:RSMPI); nonetheless, MDPI journals are indexed in WoS and Scopus, use external reviewers, and—importantly—theand, importantly, the peer-review reports and author revisions are publicly accessible for the QMM papers. Uponupon verification, the peer review results are available online.

:'''3 Regarding qualifications'''

:According to his Wiki page, Neukart holds a PhD in Computer Science and Master’s degrees in Physics, Computer Science, and Information Technology (per the article). Under WP:EXPERT and WP:RS, interdisciplinary credentials are fully acceptable; verifiable sources, not field labels, determine reliability.

:In light of multiple peer-reviewed sources from three independent publishers and the author’s documented academic background, labeling the theory "pseudo-scientific" does not align with Wikipedia policy. The term should therefore be removed, and the article improved by citing the Wiley and Elsevier papers above. [[Special:Contributions/2601:645:8480:C020:55B5:DB16:A758:A7D5|2601:645:8480:C020:55B5:DB16:A758:A7D5]] ([[User talk:2601:645:8480:C020:55B5:DB16:A758:A7D5|talk]]) 16:32, 22 July 2025 (UTC)