Modal particle: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
Order
Tags: Visual edit Mobile edit Mobile web edit
'Toch' is not a modal particle in this context. There is a difference between "doe toch niet" ("oh well, don't bother, who cares), and "doe tóch niet" (actually, never mind). In the latter case, "toch" has a well-defined meaning: "alsnog" ("still"). This is also the case of the sentence in the text.
 
(25 intermediate revisions by 22 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{Short description|Concept in linguistics}}
In [[linguistics]], '''modal particles''' are always [[uninflected word]]s, and are a type of [[grammatical particle]]. They are used to indicate how the speaker thinks that the content of the sentence relates to the participants' [[grounding in communication|common knowledge]]<ref>Fabian Bross (2012): [http://helikon-online.de/2012/Bross_Particles.pdf German modal particles and the common ground]. In: Helikon. A Multidisciplinary Online Journal, 2. 182-209.</ref> or add mood to the meaning of the sentence.<ref name="Zichtbaar Nederlands">{{Cite web|url=https://zichtbaarnederlands.nl/zn/bijwoord-modale_partikels.php?taal=en|title=Modal particles: even, eens, nou, maar, misschien, ...|last=|first=|date=November 29, 2018|website=Zichtbaar Nederlands|archive-url=|archive-date=|dead-url=|access-date=}}</ref> Languages that use many modal particles in their spoken form include [[Dutch language|Dutch]], [[Danish language|Danish]], [[German language|German]], [[Hungarian language|Hungarian]], [[Russian language|Russian]], [[Telugu language|Telugu]], [[Nepali language|Nepali]], [[Indonesian language|Indonesian]], [[Chinese language|Chinese]] and [[Japanese language|Japanese]].<ref>[http://dutchcentre.group.shef.ac.uk/advanced.dutch.grammar/mod_par.php?PHPSESSID=c40f574d03dcb5ffb37b8e924fde3caaAdvanced Dutch Grammar:politeness - Beleefdheid Modal particle - Modale partikels]{{dead link|date=February 2018 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }} retrieved 2009-01-01 and [https://books.google.com/books?id=Q7MVBgAAQBAJ&pg=PT3&lpg=PT3&dq=modal+particles+chinese&source=bl&ots=treIAN1LOu&sig=uNoqM32peFpcRG3_SU9exkf13ik&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CCoQ6AEwAjgKahUKEwiG_6DZwpDHAhXDcD4KHafsCuM#v=onepage&q=modal%20particles%20chinese&f=false Modal Particles By Keith Robinson, Wang Lingli] retrieved 2015-08-04 </ref> The [[untranslatability|translation is often not straightforward]] and depends on the context.
In [[linguistics]], '''modal particles''' are a type of [[grammatical particle]] used in a sentence to add extra meaning, particularly in [[spoken language]].<ref>{{cite web |title=The various meanings of modal particles |url=https://learngerman.dw.com/en/the-various-meanings-of-modal-particles/l-61095657/gr-61546060 |website=learngerman.dw.com |publisher=[[Deutsche Welle]] |access-date=3 February 2025}}</ref> Modal particles have various functions, including adding emotion or emphasis,<ref name="Zichtbaar Nederlands">{{Cite web|url=https://zichtbaarnederlands.nl/zn/bijwoord-modale_partikels.php?taal=en|title=Modal particles: even, eens, nou, maar, misschien, ...|date=November 29, 2018|website=Zichtbaar Nederlands}}</ref> or to express how sentence content is [[grounding in communication|grounded]] in common knowledge between the speaker and participants.<ref>Fabian Bross (2012): [http://helikon-online.de/2012/Bross_Particles.pdf German modal particles and the common ground] In: Helikon. A Multidisciplinary Online Journal, 2. 182-209.</ref>
 
Languages that use many modal particles in their spoken form include [[Dutch language|Dutch]], [[Danish language|Danish]], [[German language|German]], [[Hungarian language|Hungarian]], [[Russian language|Russian]], [[Telugu language|Telugu]], [[Nepali language|Nepali]], [[Norwegian language|Norwegian]], [[Indonesian language|Indonesian]], [[Sinitic languages]], and [[Japanese language|Japanese]].<ref>[https://archive.today/20120219220327/http://dutchcentre.group.shef.ac.uk/advanced.dutch.grammar/mod_par.php?PHPSESSID=c40f574d03dcb5ffb37b8e924fde3caaAdvanced Dutch Grammar:politeness - Beleefdheid Modal particle - Modale partikels] retrieved 2009-01-01 and [https://books.google.com/books?id=Q7MVBgAAQBAJ&dq=modal+particles+chinese&pg=PT3 Modal Particles By Keith Robinson, Wang Lingli] retrieved 2015-08-04</ref> Modal particles are often context-dependent and [[untranslatability|difficult to translate]].
 
==Examples==
===German===
* [[{{Main|German modal particle]]sparticles}}
The German particle ''ja'' is used to indicate that a sentence contains information that is obvious or already known to both the speaker and the hearer. The sentence ''Der neue Teppich ist rot'' means "The new carpet is red". ''Der neue Teppich ist '''ja''' rot'' may thus mean "As we are both aware, the new carpet is red", which would typically be followed by some conclusion from this fact. However, if the speaker says the same thing upon first seeing the new carpet, the meaning is "I'm seeing that the carpet is obviously red", which would typically express surprise. In speech the latter meaning can be inferred from a strong emphasis on ''rot'' and higher-pitched voice.
 
===Dutch===
In Dutch, modal particles are frequently used to add mood to a sentence, especially in spoken language. For instance:<ref name="Zichtbaar Nederlands">< /ref>
 
* Politeness
**''Kan je '''even''' het licht aandoen?'' (literally: "Can you briefly turn on the light?" forwith athe shortadded while?")<br>''Even''even" here indicatesindicating that theit requested action doeswill not take much time oryou effortlong to fulfill:do "Couldso.) you quickly turn on the light for me, please?"
** ''Weet u '''misschien''' waar het station is?'' ("Do you perhaps know where the train station is?")<br> ''Misschien'' here denotes a very polite and friendly request: "Could you tell me the way to the train station, please?"
** ''Wil je '''soms''' wat drinken?'' ("Do you occasionally want a drink?")<br>''Soms'' here conveys a sincere interest in the answer to a question: "I'm curious if you would like to drink something?"
 
* Frustration
** ''Doe het toch '''toch maar'''.'' ("Do it nevertheless, however.")<br>''Toch'' here indicates anger and ''maar'' lack of consideration: "I don't really care what you think, just do it!"
** ''Ben je '''nou''' nog niet klaar?'' ("Are you still not ready yet?")<br>''Nou'' here denotes loss of patience: "Don't tell me you still haven't finished!"
 
Modal particles may be combined to indicate mood in a very precise way. WhileIn somethis combination of six modal particles canthe movefirst aroundtwo freelyemphasise whenthe stackedcommand, inthe combination,second otherstwo haveare moretoning fixeddown placesthe command, likeand inthe thisfinal combinationtwo oftransform temporalthe modalcommand particlesinto a request:
 
* ''Luister '''dan nu''''' '''''toch maar''''' '''''eens even'''''.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.dbnl.org/tekst/_for004198701_01/_for004198701_01_0036.php|title=Forum der Letteren. Jaargang 1987 · dbnl|last1=Hulshof|first1=H.|website=DBNL|publisher=dbnl|language=nl|access-date=27 July 2019}}</ref> ("Listen + at this moment + now + just + ''will you?'' + only once + only for a while", meaning: "Just listen, will you?")
* '''''dan nu toch maar eens even'''''
This combination is used to make an order '''stronger''', and than '''transforming''' that order into a '''weaker''' request:
 
Because of this progressive alteration these modal particles cannot move around freely when stacked in this kind of combination. However, some other modal particles can be added to the equation on any given place, such as '''gewoon''', '''juist''', '''trouwens.''' Also, replacing the "imperative weakener" '''maar''' by '''gewoon''' (indicating normalcy or acceptable behavior), changes the mood of the sentence completely, now indicating utter frustration with someone who is failing to do something very simple:
Luister '''dan nu''' (this moment + now: indicating impatience) '''toch maar''' (incentive + weakener: indicating transition) '''eens even''' (only this time + a short time: indicating politeness) het raam dicht.<ref>{{cite web |last1=Hulshof |first1=H. |title=Forum der Letteren. Jaargang 1987 · dbnl |url=https://www.dbnl.org/tekst/_for004198701_01/_for004198701_01_0036.php |website=DBNL |publisher=dbnl |accessdate=27 July 2019 |language=nl}}</ref> ("Just close the window, will you?")
 
**''Luister '''dan nou toch gewoon eens even'''!'' ("Listen now just regularly once for a while", meaning: "For once, can you just simply listen for a minute?")
However, replacing the "order weakener" '''maar''' by the enhancer '''gewoon''', changes the complete mood of the sentence, now indicating utter frustration with someone who is failing to do something very simple:
 
**''Luister '''dan nou toch gewoon eens even'''!'' ("Listen now just regularly once for a while", meaning: "For once, can you just simply listen for a minute?")
 
==See also==
* [[German modal particle]]s
 
==References==
Line 34 ⟶ 32:
 
{{Lexical categories|state=collapsed}}
{{Authority control}}
 
[[Category:Parts of speech]]
 
 
{{syntax-stub}}