Map communication model: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 11:15, 3 September 2008

Latest revision as of 15:23, 14 August 2025

(16 intermediate revisions by 12 users not shown)

Line 1:

The '''Map Communication Model''' is a theory in [[cartography]], that characterizes mapping as a process of transmitting geographic information via the map from the cartographer to the end-user.<ref name="Ubi06"> [httphttps://ubikcan.blogspot.com/2006/08/map-communication-model-and-critical.html "The map communication model and critical cartography"], Ubikcan blogspot 8.13.2006. Retrieved 3 September 2008.</ref> It was perhaps the first paradigm to gain widespread acceptance in cartography in the international cartographic community and between academic and practising cartographers.<ref>{{cite journal |last1=Kent |first1=Alexander |title=Form Follows Feedback: Rethinking Cartographic Communication |journal=Westminster Papers in Communication and Culture |date=2018 |volume=13 |issue=2 |pages=96–112 |doi=10.16997/wpcc.296 |doi-access=free }}</ref>

== Overview ==

By the mid-20th century, cartographers<ref>[http://www.metapedia.com/wiki/index.php?title=Spo7according Theto RootsCrampton of(2001) Twenty-First Century Critical Cartography in Twentieth Century Critical Theory], retrieved 3 September 2008.</ref>"cartographers as [[Arthur H. Robinson]] and others had begun to see the map as primarily a communication tool, and so developed a specific model for map communication, the map communication model (MCM)".<ref name="JWC01">Crampton, J.W. (2001). "Maps as Social Constructions: Power, Communication, and Visualization". In: ''Progress in Human Geography''. 25, 235-252 </ref>. This model, according to Andrews (1988) "can be grouped with the other major [[Communication theory|communication modelsmodel]]s of the time, such as the Shannon-Weaver and Lasswell models of communication. The map communication model led to a whole new body of research, methodologies and map design paradigms"<ref>Andrews, S.K. (1988). "Applications of a Cartographic Communication Model to a Tactual Map Design". In: ''The American Cartographer''. 15, 183-95.</ref>

One of the implications of this communication model according to Crampton (2001) "endorsed an “epistemic break” that shifted our understandings of maps as communication systems to investigating them in terms of fields of power relations and exploring the “mapping environments in which knowledge is constructed”... This involved examining the social contexts in which maps were both produced and used, a departure from simply seeing maps as artifacts to be understood apart from this context".<ref name="JWC01">Crampton, J.W. (2001). "Maps as Social Constructions: Power, Communication, and Visualization". In: ''Progress in Human Geography''. 25, 235-252</ref>

The Map Communication Model is a processual model that characterizes mapping as a process of transmitting information (geographic information) via the map from the cartographer to the end-user. In order to see what's wrong with that, we have to first make a distinction between information and knowledge. Information is data that lets you make a decision, and since Claude Shannon's classic work on information theory in the 1930s we can define the lowest possible unit of information as two binary digits (0, 1) or bits. For example, if you're waiting in the gas chamber to hear from the governor whether to execute the prisoner, the phone can ring with a "yes" or "no" message. That's information.<ref name="Ubi06"/>

A second implication of this model is the presumption inherited from [[positivism]] that it is possible to separate facts from values. As Harley stated: Maps are never value-free images; except in the narrowest Euclidean sense they are not in themselves either true or false. Both in the selectivity of their content and in their signs and styles of representation maps are a way of conceiving, articulating, and structuring the human world which is biased towards, promoted by, and exerts influence upon particular sets of social relations. By accepting such premises it becomes easier to see how appropriate they are to manipulation by the powerful in society.<ref name="CC08">Richard Donohue (2008). [http://geographer.situatedlaboratories.org/critical_cartography.php Critical cartography] {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20080705231614/http://geographer.situatedlaboratories.org/critical_cartography.php |date=2008-07-05 }}. Retrieved 3 September 2008.</ref>

== History ==

{{Unreferenced-section|date=February 2023}}

Although this was a postwar discovery, the Map Communication Model (MCM) has its roots in [[information theory]] developed in the [[telephone]] industry before the war began. Mathematician, inventor, and teacher [[Claude Shannon]] worked at [[Bell Labs]] after completing his Ph.D. at the [[Massachusetts Institute of Technology]] in 1940. Shannon applied mathematical theory to information and demonstrated that communication could be reduced to binary digits ([[bitsbit]]s) of positive and negative circuits. This information could be coded and transmitted across a [[Electronic noise|noisy]] [[interface (computer science)|interface]] without losing any meaning. Once the information was received it was then decoded by the listener; the integrity of the information remained intact. In producing meaningful sounds that could be measured for quality, Shannon produced the beginning of information theory and [[digital communication]] through circuits of on and off [[electric switch|switches]].

Shannon developed his ideas more thoroughly in the 1940s at the same time that [[geographer]] and [[cartographer]] [[Arthur H. Robinson]] returned from the [[Second World War]] during which he had served as cartographer for the military. Robinson found that cartographers were significantly limited because artists could make more effective maps than geographers. Upon returning from the war, Robinson worked to remedy this problem at [[Ohio State University]] where he was a graduate student. His ''The Look of Maps'' emphasizes the importance of lettering, map design, map structure, color, and technique.

Information theory helped turn the map into a medium of communicating information. Although Robinson never articulated a map model that could govern the new scientific pursuit of maps, his role in the war led to an understanding of the practical need for maps based on science not art. Robinson opened the door for others to apply Shannon’s ''Mathematical Theory of Communication'' to the design of maps. British geographer [[Christopher Board]] developed the first MCM in 1967 but it was cumbersome and poorly measured a map’s information quality. The Czech Geographer Kolácný’s 1969 version made several key improvements to Board’s model. These versions of the MCM helped cartographers realize the problems that Robinson noted as a war cartographer and helped articulate the discipline in terms of science.

== References ==

Line 17 ⟶ 20:

== External links ==

* [httphttps://ubikcan.blogspot.com/2006/08/map-communication-model-and-critical.html "The map communication model and critical cartography"], Ubikcan blogspot 8.13.2006.

[[Category:Cartography]]