Content deleted Content added
→Mozart's approach to composition: A grammatical error. In has been replaced by into. |
m HTTP to HTTPS for Cornell University |
||
(48 intermediate revisions by 25 users not shown) | |||
Line 1:
{{Short description|none}}
[[
Scholars have long studied how [[Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart]] created his works.
==Mozart's approach to composition==
A surviving letter of Mozart's to his father [[Leopold Mozart|Leopold]] (31 July 1778) indicates that he considered composition an active
==Sketches==
Mozart often wrote [[Sketch (music)|sketches]], from small snippets to extensive drafts, for his compositions. Though many of these were destroyed by Mozart's widow [[Constanze Mozart|Constanze]],<ref name="Solomon 1995, 310">{{harvnb|Solomon
[[Ulrich Konrad]], an expert on the sketches,<ref>{{harvnb|Solomon
This procedure makes sense of another letter Mozart wrote to Leopold, discussing his work in [[Munich]] on the opera ''[[Idomeneo]]'' (30 December 1780), where Mozart distinguishes "composed" from "written":
In Konrad's view, Mozart had completed the "draft score" of the work, but still needed to produce the completed, final version.
Of the sketches that survive, none are for solo keyboard works.
==Use of a keyboard==
[[File:Portrait of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart at the age of 13 in Verona, 1770.jpg|thumb|1770 Verona portrait of Mozart, which shows the composer playing a [[harpsichord]]]]
Mozart
<blockquote>
Konrad cites a similar letter written from Paris that indicates that Mozart didn't compose where he was staying, but visited another home to borrow the keyboard instrument there.
▲Mozart evidently needed a keyboard to work out his musical thoughts. This can be deduced from his letters and other biographical material.<ref>This point is made by the authors of the [[Cornell University]] website "Mozart and the keyboard culture of his time", which also offers digital images of the letters in question. See [http://rmc.library.cornell.edu/mozart/myth/TellTale_Letters.htm].</ref> For instance, on 1 August 1781, Mozart wrote to his father [[Leopold Mozart|Leopold]] concerning his living arrangements in Vienna, where he had recently moved:
On the other hand, Mozart was in fact able to compose without a keyboard, according to various sources. German musicologist [[Hermann Abert]] cited Mozart's first biographer [[Franz Xaver Niemetschek]] in his book, who originally wrote: "He never went to the keyboard when composing." Mozart's wife, Constanze, has also stated the same thing and added that he "only tried out a movement when it was finished".<ref>{{Cite book|last=Abert|first=Hermann|author-link=Hermann Abert|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=l6I6BwTMJ3sC|title=W. A. Mozart|date=2007-01-01|publisher=Yale University Press|isbn=978-0-300-07223-5|page=824}}</ref>
▲:"My room that I'm moving to is being prepared—I'm just off now to hire a keyboard, because I can't live there until that's been delivered, especially as I've got to write just now, and there isn't a minute to be lost."<ref>Cited from Konrad 2006, 102</ref>
▲Konrad cites a similar letter written from Paris that indicates that Mozart didn't compose where he was staying, but visited another home to borrow the keyboard instrument there. Similar evidence is found in early biographies based on [[Constanze Mozart]]'s memories.
==Incomplete works==
About 150 of Mozart's surviving works are incomplete, roughly a quarter of the total count of surviving works.<ref name="Solomon 1995, 310" />
It is not known why so many works were left incomplete.
==Improvisation==
Mozart evidently had a prodigious ability to "compose on the spot"; that is, to improvise at the keyboard.
The composer [[André Grétry]] recalled:
As a teenager visiting Italy, Mozart gave a concert in Venice (5 March 1771). According to a witness, "An experienced musician gave him a fugue theme, which he worked out for more than an hour with such science, dexterity, harmony, and proper attention to rhythm, that even the greatest connoisseurs were astounded."<ref>Quoted in Solomon (1995, 543)</ref>▼
Mozart continued to improvise in public as an adult. For instance, the highly successful concert of 1787 in [[Prague]] that premiered his [[Symphony No. 38 (Mozart)|"Prague Symphony"]] concluded with a half-hour improvisation by the composer.<ref>Solomon 1995, 419</ref> For other instances, see [[Mozart's Berlin journey]] and [[Dora Stock]].▼
The meeting of Grétry and the young Mozart apparently took place in 1766.<ref>{{harvnb|Deutsch
▲As a teenager visiting Italy, Mozart gave a concert in Venice (5 March 1771).
▲Mozart continued to improvise in public as an adult.
▲:''Once in Geneva I met a child who could play everything at sight. His father said to me before the assembled company: So that no doubt shall remain as to my son's talent, write for him, for to-morrow, a very difficult Sonata movement. I wrote him an Allegro in E flat; difficult, but unpretentious; he played it, and everyone, except myself, believed that it was a miracle. The boy had not stopped; but following the modulations, he had substituted a quantity of passages for those which I had written ...''<ref>Quoted in Deutsch (1965, 477)</ref>
▲The meeting of Grétry and the young Mozart apparently took place in 1766.<ref>Deutsch (1965, 477). Deutsch seems secure in the view that although Grétry does not identify the child he heard, it was in fact Mozart.</ref>
===Improvisation as a time-saving device===
[[Volkmar Braunbehrens|Braunbehrens]] suggests that on at least one occasion, Mozart met a deadline by simply not writing down part of the music and improvising it instead while performing before the audience. This was evidently true of the [[Piano Concerto No. 26 (Mozart)|Piano Concerto in D, K. 537]], premiered 24 February 1788.
{{Listen|type=music|filename=Mozart; Piano Concerto No. 26 in D Major, KV 537 "Coronation", 2. Larghetto.flac|title=Performance|description=By [[Lili Kraus]] in 1955}}
<score vorbis="1">
\new PianoStaff <<
\new Staff \relative c'' {
Line 82 ⟶ 81:
</score>
Braunbehrens and other scholars infer that Mozart could not conceivably have opened a movement with a completely unadorned melody line, and instead improvised a suitable accompaniment for the left hand.
The work was published only in 1794, three years after Mozart's death, and the publisher [[Johann André]] found some other composer (whose identity is unknown) to fill in the missing passages; these interpolations have become the standard for performance.<ref>This section is based on {{harvtxt|Braunbehrens
==Mozart's memory==
Mozart appears to have possessed an excellent memory for music, though probably not the quasi-miraculous ability that has passed into legend. In particular, the use of keyboards and sketches to compose, noted above, would not have been necessary for a composer who possessed superhuman memory.
Two of the violin sonatas gave rise to anecdotes to the effect that Mozart played the piano part at the premiere from memory, with only the violinist playing from the music. This is true for the Violin Sonata in G, K. 379/373a, where Mozart wrote in a letter to Leopold (8 April 1781) that he wrote out the violin part in an hour the night before the performance<ref>{{harvnb|Solomon
One may question whether, in these instances, Mozart remembered the entire keyboard part note-for-note. Given the independent testimony (above) for his ability to fill in gaps through improvisation, it would seem that Mozart could have done this as well in performing the violin sonatas.
Another instance of Mozart's powerful memory concerns his purported memorization and transcription of
==19th-century views==
Konrad describes the views that were prevalent during the 19th century period of Mozart scholarship.
===The Rochlitz letter===
An important source for earlier conceptions concerning Mozart's composition method was the work of the early 19th century publisher [[Friedrich Rochlitz]]. He propagated anecdotes about Mozart that were long assumed authentic, but with more recent research are now widely doubted.
Rochlitz's forged letter also was used in earlier study to bolster the (apparently false) story that Mozart could compose relying entirely on his memory, without the use of keyboard or sketches:
The contents of the Rochlitz letter were relayed by such authorities as the mathematician [[Henri Poincaré]] and the musician [[Albert Lavignac]]<ref>{{cite book|last=Lavignac|first=Albert|author-link=Albert Lavignac
Although it has been influential in historical conceptions of Mozart, the letter is no longer regarded as an accurate description of Mozart's compositional process.<ref>Konrad, 101</ref> On the other hand, Mozart's first biographer, in collaboration with Mozart's wife, related a congruent account of how Mozart composed:▼
▲
:''Mozart wrote everything with a facility and rapidity, which perhaps at first sight could appear as carelessness or haste; and while writing he never came to the klavier. His imagination presented the whole work, when it came to him, clearly and vividly. …. In the quiet repose of the night, when no obstacle hindered his soul, the power of his imagination became incandescent with the most animated activity, and unfolded all the wealth of tone which nature had placed in his spirit …. Only the person who heard Mozart at such times knows the depth and the whole range of his musical genius: free and independent of all concern his spirit could soar in daring flight to the highest regions of art.''<ref>Niemtschek, pp. 54-5</ref>▼
▲
▲The contents of the Rochlitz letter were relayed by such authorities as the mathematician [[Henri Poincaré]] and the musician [[Albert Lavignac]]<ref>Albert Lavignac, ''L'éducation musicale'', p. 290</ref> and had a great influence on the popular view of Mozart's compositional process. As late as 1952 a volume of collected papers from a symposium on the creative process reproduce the letter, albeit with a warning that "the authenticity of this letter remains in doubt".<ref>Brewster Ghiseli (editor), ''The Creative Process: A Symposium'', University of California Press, 1952, p. 34</ref>
==Notes==
{{Reflist
'''Sources'''
*{{cite book|last=Braunbehrens|first=Volkmar|author-link=Volkmar Braunbehrens|year=1990|title=Mozart in Vienna: 1781–1791|___location=New York|publisher=Grove Weidenfeld}}
*
*{{cite encyclopedia|last=Irving
*{{cite encyclopedia|last=Keefe
*
*
*{{cite book|last=Solomon|first=Maynard|author-link=Maynard Solomon|year=1995|title=Mozart: A Life|___location=New York|publisher=Harper Perennial}}
*
==Further reading==
*[[Ulrich Konrad|Konrad, Ulrich]] "How Mozart Went about Composing: A New View" in
▲*[[Otto Erich Deutsch|Deutsch, Otto Erich]] (1965) ''Mozart: A Documentary Biography''. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
▲*Irving, John (2006) "Sonatas," in Cliff Eisen and Simon P. Keefe, ''The Cambridge Mozart Encyclopedia''. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
▲*Keefe, Simon P. (2006) "Rochlitz, (Johann) Friedrich," in Cliff Eisen and Simon P. Keefe, ''The Cambridge Mozart Encyclopedia''. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
▲*Konrad, Ulrich (2006) "Compositional method," in Cliff Eisen and Simon P. Keefe, ''The Cambridge Mozart Encyclopedia''. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
▲*Niemtschek, Franz (1798), Leben des K.K. Kapellmeisters Wolfgang Gottlieb Mozart, nach Originalquellen beschrieben.
▲*[[Neal Zaslaw|Zaslaw, Neal]] (1994) "Mozart as a working stiff," in James M. Morris, ed., ''On Mozart'', Cambridge University Press. An influential assertion of the practicality of Mozart's motivations in composition, attacking older conceptions as romanticized and unrealistic.
▲*[[Ulrich Konrad|Konrad, Ulrich]] "How Mozart Went about Composing: A New View" in the Mozart Society of America Newsletter, Volume VIII, Number 2 (27 August 2004) (an English translation of the overview in his 1992 book)
*Konrad, Ulrich (1992) "Mozarts Schaffensweise", Göttingen: Vandehoeck & Ruprecht. (Abhandlungen der Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen Philologisch-Historische Klasse 3. Folge Band 201)
==External links==
*[http://www.bl.uk/onlinegallery/ttp/mozart/accessible/introduction.html ''Verzeichnüss aller meiner Werke'' (Mozart's Thematic Catalogue)]
{{Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart}}
{{Portal bar|Classical music}}
{{DEFAULTSORT:Mozart's Compositional Method}}
[[Category:Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart|Compositional method]]
[[Category:
|