Jordanes and Challenger, Gray & Christmas: Difference between pages

(Difference between pages)
Content deleted Content added
Nasz (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
 
m ref
 
Line 1:
'''Challenger, Gray & Christmas''', with headquarters located in [[Chicago, Illinois]], is the oldest executive outplacement firm in the US. It has offices in 52 cities in the US and [[Canada]], and has operations in [[Japan]] and [[Mexico]]. The firm also conducts regular surveys and issues reports on the state of the economy, employment, job-seeking, layoffs and [[executive compensation]]. They also conduct one-off surveys on such subjects as workplace bullying, lost productivity due to the Super Bowl, and working women. Their core business, finding jobs for laid-off executives, is unusual in that they will only accept as clients people whose former companies will sponsor the client's job search.
[[Image:Byzantium550.png|thumb|right|Mediterranean world when Jordanes wrote ''Getica''. The [[Roman Empire]], capital [[Constantinople]], is shown in pink. Conquests of [[Justinian]] shown in green.]]
<ref>{{cite web |author= |http://www.challengergray.com/services/whoarewe.aspx |title=Who are we? |publisher=Challenger, Gray & Christmas |accessdate=2007-06-22}}</ref>
'''Iordanis''', known in English as '''Jornandes''', '''Jord'anes''' or '''Jordanes''' (also '''Jordanis''' or perhaps even Iordanem, '''Iornandes,''' 'bold as a boar')<ref>{{catholic}}; qoute: ''It is not really proven, for example, that he bore "before his conversion" the martial name of Jornandes (i.e. bold as a boar), nor that after this conversion he became a monk in Thrace or in Maesia''; URL:[http://www.findthepower.net/CP/PostNewABC.php?CEC=ON&SeeAlso=Jordanis%20(Jornandes)]</ref>, was a [[6th century]] bureaucrat of the Eastern Roman Empire,<ref>"If Jordanes was a bishop (as is frequently assumed) and if he lived in Italy (also frequently assumed), those elements of his background have left no trace in his two histories" (Brian Croke, "Cassiodorus and the ''Getica'' of Jordanes" ''Classical Philology'' '''82'''.2 [April 1987, pp. 117-134] p 119.).</ref> who turned his hand to [[history]] late in life.
 
Though he wrote a history of Rome ''([[Romana (Jordanes)|Romana]]''), or compendium of universal history, often called ''[[De regnorum ac temporum successione]]'', also ''[[De breviatione chronicorum]]'', but acording to [[Theodore Mommsen|Mommsen]]: ''[[De summa temporum vel origine actibusque gentis Romanorum]]''.<ref>The New Schaff-Herzog Encyclopedia of Religious Knowledge WILHELM ALTMANN url http://www.ccel.org/s/schaff/encyc/encyc06/htm/iii.lvii.cxiv.htm page 228</ref>
 
The book most of interest to us now is the original manuscript writen by Jordanes but was burnt by Mommsen (acidentaly<!--?-->) in his workroom. We have only readable ''[[Getica(Jordanes)|Getica]]'', book written in Latin two years after the fire by German scholar Theodore Momsen<ref>[[Theodor Mommsen]], (''MGH: AA'' 5.1:vi) observed many forms of grammar and orthography that revealed a translation into Greek from a Latin original.</ref>
 
Latin was probably Jordanes' third language at [[Constantinople]]<ref>"Constantinople is "our city" (''Getica'' 38).</ref> about [[551]] CE.<ref>He mentions the great [[plague]] of 546 as having occurred "nine years ago" (''Getica'' 104.)</ref>
 
The accidents of life and time have rendered it the only source remaining to us concerning the origin of the [[Goths|Gothic]] people who occupied the shores of the [[Baltic Sea]] around today's [[Poland]], extended southward to the [[Black Sea]], formed a distinct empire and a distinct language, [[Gothic language|Gothic]], were defeated by the [[Huns]] and gradually dispersed throughout Europe, to disappear by assimilation.<ref>See [[Goths]].</ref>
 
Jordanes was asked by a friend to write this book by the church as a summary of a lost multi-volume history of the Goths by the statesman, [[Cassiodorus]]. The major factors in the selection of Jordanes for this task were his interest in history (he was working on a history of Rome), his ability to write succinctly and his own Gothic background. He had been a high-level ''notarius'', or secretary, of a small client state on the Roman frontier in [[Moesia]], modern northern [[Bulgaria]].<ref>Croke 1987.</ref>
 
Others, e.g. [[Procopius]], wrote extant works on the later history of the Goths. As the only surviving work on Gothic ''origins'', Jordanes' ''Getica'' has been the object of much critical review. Jordanes wrote in late [[Latin]], denigrated by Classicists for its non-conformance to the rules of classical Ciceronian Latin. <!--He took the view that the Goths originated in [[Scandinavia]]. comment: does this mean that he invented the idea or that there were several opinions at the time and he opted for it?--> According to his own introduction, he only had three days to review Cassiodorus' work; thus, he must have been relying on his own knowledge. Some of his statements are very succinct.
 
The reader should be aware that all the topics mentioned in the previous paragraph are controversial. Extremely different views have been formulated. This article attempts to steer a middle course. Links to more radical or less accepted views have been included in the External Links section. Also, ''Getica'' in both Latin and English is readily available in editions on the Internet but scanned manuscript is not available.
 
==Life and times before conversion==
===Disposition of Danubian lands after Attila===
[[Attila the Hun]] died in [[453]], of natural causes, so the major sources say. His sons planned to divide his empire as though it were a family estate. Getting word of this plan, and believing that to treat nations as you would property is a form of enslavement, [[Ardaric]] (Germanic name) , king of the [[Gepidae]], raised the standard of revolt and defeated the [[Huns]] and their allies at the [[Battle of Nedao]] in [[454]].{{Fact|date=February 2007}}
 
The Gepidae won sovereignty in [[Dacia]] with Roman blessings. Encouraged, the [[Goths]] successfully petitioned [[Marcian]], Roman emperor, for lands, and received [[Pannonia]], which included [[Vienna]] (Vindobonum). This disposition required the displacement of former [[Sarmatians]] and Huns from [[Illyricum]] within it. The [[Sciri]], the [[Sadagarii]] and part of the [[Alans]] were given [[Scythia Minor]] and [[Lower Moesia]] under a leader, Candac.{{Fact|date=February 2007}}
 
===Formation of a mixed province under Candac===
Candac did not carry a Gothic name. In the mix of peoples and languages of the times, it is hard to say what it might be. The name is parallel to Hunnic names, such as Ellac and Hernac, sons of Atilla. Hernac settled in Lesser Scythia also ([[Bulgaria]]) with some of the Huns then fleeing Pannonia.{{Fact|date=February 2007}}
 
Candac had an unnamed sister who married into the [[Amali]], a noble family of the Goths. The latter must have been present in large numbers, probably being represented by the Sciri. Candac's sister's husband was Andag, son of Andela. Their son, Gunthigis, had a Gothic name. He was probably the Gothic leader, Godigisclus, mentioned by [[Procopius]]. He became chief of staff of Candac's army, taking the name Baza (Hunnish?). As this little state was or became part of the Roman empire, Baza is probably the same as the Batza of pseudo-[[Marcellinus Comes]]. That Batza was posted to the Euphrates in [[536]] to take command of the Roman frontier there.{{Fact|date=February 2007}}
 
===Ancestry of Jordanes===
This is the historical context of Jordanes' famous statement about himself and his associates in ''Getica'', 50.266. Candac had a ''notarius'', [[Paria (6th century)|Paria]], grandfather of Jordanes and father of Alanoviiamuth or Viiamuth.<ref>''Alanoviiamuth'' does not have the form of the names of the times. It occurs in the sentence "''cuius Candacis Alanoviiamuthis patris mei genitor Paria, id est meus avus, notarius ....''" The most plausible reconstruction is "Alan. d. Uiiamuthis, an abbreviation of (Candacis) Alanorum ducis Uiiamuth, which is Gothic Veihamoths. The sentence would then read:
"of which Candac, chief of the Alans, Paria, father of my father Veihamoths, that is my grandfather, (was) secretary...."</ref>
 
If Candac was chief of the Alans in that region (which name could have included all the ethnicities) and that Jordanes' father was a Goth, what Paria's kinship by genes or law was to the Goths remains unknown. As Jordanes was ''notarius'', or secretary to Gunthigis,<ref>''Getica'' 266.</ref> his office was probably hereditary. As he was a key man to the chief, this grade of ''notarius'' is aptly likened to secretary of state.
 
===Social status and education===
Jordanes, however, describes himself as ''agramaticus''<ref>Having by-passed a formal rhetorical education in ''grammatice''.</ref> before his conversion. It is hard to imagine a secretary of state who could not read or write; therefore, he is unlikely to have meant unlettered. To read between the lines, his stressing "before my conversion" may be an effort to please the church, as all Goths at the time were suspected of [[Arianism]].<ref>Compare [[Ulfilas]].</ref>{{Fact|date=April 2007}} Otherwise we would have to presume that he underwent some sort of education in the church, in philosophy or oratory.
 
The key factor is perhaps that he was not a converted rustic drawn up out of his class, but a Gothic noble who had held a high office of state. His gentility is why, perhaps, he rose within the church and was assigned to summarize the work of a famous stateman. Some intimations of rusticism stem from his Latin, which is ungrammatical, but misapplication or failure to apply the rules of golden or silver Latin are characteristics of late Latin.
 
==Conversion and after==
===Paganism conversion theory===
Jordanes was the ''notarius'' of Candac's nephew, the Gothic chief [[Gunthigis]], ''ante conversionem meam'' ("before my conversion"). The Latin word has the same meaning as the English word deriving from it. The nature and details of the conversion remain obscure. By implication, it involved leaving his post as ''notarius'' and travelling to Italy with stays at various times in Rome. If the identification of his former employer is correct, the latter probably went to the Euphrates in 536 without the services of his former secretary.
 
The conversion was probably not from [[paganism]] to [[Christianity]]. The Goths had been converted with the assistance of [[Ulfilas]] (a Goth), made bishop on that account. It is possible that the state of mixed peoples in which Jordanes had been notarius remained somewhat pagan despite the Gothic connection.
 
===Arianism conversion theory===
During Ulfilas' career, however, the church branded the doctrine to which he had been converted as heretical. Ulfilas saved himself and his career by travelling to Rome and recanting. The north did not give up its [[Arianism]] easily. Some claim that the issue continues today, although there is no historical descent of today's [[unitarian]]ism (the philosophic doctrine, not the church in New England, which derives from Puritan times and the Swiss reform) from Arianism.
 
A conversion to the [[Nicene creed]] ([[trinitarian]]) and a trip to Rome to clear himself is a better explanation Jordanes' conversion, which is expressed in the virulent anti-Arianism of certain passages in ''Getica''.<ref>''Getica'' 132, 133, 138, noted by Croke 1987:125</ref> In a letter to Vigilius he mentions that he was awakened by ''vestris interrogationibus''. The word interrogatio, which derives from Roman jurisprudence and typically involved torture in that context, referred in the church to the first step of a process that became terrible to many, which we still call inquisition. Initially, however, the object of church attention was often treated with all courtesy and respect and was invited to publicly alter his views, as did Ulfilas.
 
If that is what happened, Jordanes, a high Gothic official, may have been invited to Rome, where he took the hint, so to speak, as he seems to have received the blandishment of church offices and comradeship as one of the inner circle. Whether he would have been allowed to return to his old position is another matter. In Jordanes' case there is no hint of any hypocrisy. His works are enthusiastic, even bubbling, and give the impression of frank sincerity. He probably was, in fact, converted. His extant writings are from a Nicene, not an Arian, perspective.
 
===Monasticism conversion theory===
The idea that Jordanes converted to a monkish way of life is not compatible with his subsequent church career. He may have spent some time in a monastery, as did many churchmen.
 
===Success in the church===
Not much of Jordanes' career is known: Pope [[Pelagius]] mentions a Jordanes ''defensor ecclesiae Romanae'', "Jordanes, defender of the Roman church", which may be him. The emphasis on Roman church, as opposed to some other, seems to imply the Nicene/Arian conflict. By 551 Pope [[Vigilius]], under detention in [[Constantinople]], had been joined by [[Bishop]] Jordanes of [[Crotone|Crotona]] ([[Bruttium]], [[Italy]]), commonly identified with Jordanes the historian.<ref>Croke 1987:118.</ref> He was probably not bishop of [[Ravenna]], as some say.
 
==Publications==
[[Image:The Huns at the Battle of Chalons.jpg|thumb|left|200px|Most of what we know about the battle of Chalones comes from ''The History and Deeds of the Goths'', written by Jordanes]]
===The initial stages of writing===
The two remaining publications of Jordanes were written nearly together in 551 AD while Pope [[Vigilius]] was being detained at [[Constantinople]] by [[Justinian]] for refusal to cooperate. The works were assigned the epithets of ''[[Romana (Jordanes)|Romana]]'' and ''Getica'' by [[Theodore Mommsen]] for quick reference, when they were first pubblished together as ''Iordanis Romana et Getica'' in 1882. Those names have persisted.
 
At Constantinople the churchmen were continually badgered and their lives were threatened. The writing project apparently began as a pastime and spiritual escape. In the first sentence of ''Getica'', Jordanes compares the composition of ''Romana'' to a fishing trip, in which he glides his boat by the
:"oram tranquilli litoris",
:the "bank of a peaceful shore"
catching the little fish of the ancients.
 
===The political environment at Constantinople===
[[Justinian]] had come to power as associate emperor in [[527]], soon taking full and sole control at the natural death of his predecessor. He was already married to [[Theodora]] since [[523]]. Italy at that time was a mixture of former Romans and Italians and Goths. Relations were now peaceful, now inharmonious. As to religion, Italy was in the Roman camp, while Justinian and Theodora were eastern [[Orthodox]].
 
Justinian was known as the ''emperor who never slept''. He and Theodora (who were excellent and like-minded partners) spent every bit of their time and resources on one goal: the reunification and restoration of the Roman empire. Their methods were often extreme, even ruthless. They achieved limited success, and therefore he is known as ''the last Roman emperor'' and she ''the empress Theodora.''
 
===The rise of Vigilius===
An astute statesman, Justinian readily understood the necessity of winning over enemies by making concessions. He therefore continued the policy of recognizing the [[Papal See]] as supreme ecclesiastical authority. He hoped, however, to control it by personal influence. In 536 his wife "cut a deal" with the then papal representative, [[Vigilius]], a native Roman. In the expression, ''quid pro quo'', which is the basis of a legal agreement even today, the ''quid'' was the papacy and 700 pounds of gold. The ''quo'' was Vigilius' cooperation with Justinian.
 
Subsequently Justinian's military chief of staff, [[Belisarius]], garrisoned the city of Rome. Pope [[Silverius]] (a Gothic partisan) was removed by false accusations. Belisarius ensured that the election for the next pope favored Vigilius. Justinian, however, who acted essentially without conscience himself (believing that reasons of state took precedence), had not counted on Vigilius' conscience. The latter on the whole worked against imperial policy in favor of reason and compassion.
 
===Crisis in the papacy===
The [[Three-Chapter Controversy]], best left to another article in Wikipedia, was a complex affair within the circle of Christian churches. Justinian was asked to take a hand (as had been [[Constantine I (emperor)|Constantine I]] in others), which he did in [[543]] or [[544]], with an edict condemning the Three Chapters (which condemned somebody else). He hoped the edict would make reconciliation with the [[monophysites]] easier. Patriarchs and bishops alike were now asked to sign the edict.
 
Vigilius refused to sign. He was plucked from the middle of a service celebrating the [[Feast of St. Cecilia]] at Rome and escorted to a ship in the [[Tiber]] waiting to take him to Constantinople. Due to a sojourn in Sicily, he first arrived there in 547. He spent the next eight years there, but not just for his stubborn refusal. Justinian wished to keep him out of the wars with the Goths and violent politics that were now engulfing Italy. In [[555]] Vigilius complied with the sovereign and was permitted to leave (after the defeat of the Goths), only to die on the return voyage. The remains came home at last, to be duly buried there.
 
===The involvement of Jordanes in the crisis===
How and when Jordanes came to join Vigilius in Constantinople remains unknown. As Bishop of Crotona he would not have been in Rome at the time of Vigilius' arrest. After he joined Vigilius for whatever reason, he would not have been allowed to leave, as he shared Vigilius' conciliatory policy concerning the remaining Huns and the Goths. The last thing Justinian wanted was conciliation. He had sent Belisarius to Italy to achieve victory.
 
Romana was begun then to lighten the burden and while away the long hours. It survives under various descriptive titles, ''De summa temporum vel origine actibusque gentis Romanorum'' or sometimes ''De regnorum et temporum successione,'' or even ''Liber de origine mundi et actibus Romanorum ceterarumque gentium'', or simply ''De gestis Romanorum''. It is a hasty compilation that was begun before, but published after, the Gothic history of [[551]], covering the history of the world from the [[Creation theology|Creation]], based on [[Jerome]] and other writers, but of some value for the century [[450]]-[[550]], when Jordanes is dealing with recent history.
 
===Reassignment to Getica===
Jordanes did not intend ''Romana'' for his own eyes only, as he dedicated it to Vigilius. The latter was probably informed of it. Before it was done, Jordanes was pulled off it and put on the [[Getica]], which was to be a summarization of a voluminous work by Cassiodorus.
 
To leave Romana unfinished and suddenly take up a difficult task on a dangerous subject argues for a higher policy than his own; namely, the pope's. Jordanes said that he started the Getica at the urging of "brother" Castalius, who insisted he leave his figurative fishing trip and set sails upon the deep. Castalius probably represented the pope. Who else could "insist" that a bishop drop his pastime and move into deeper waters?
 
Jordanes tells us that he did not even have access to Cassiodorus' work at that time, and presumably could not obtain it due to his detention. He did have access to a great many other sources through the libraries in Constantinople, and he did have his knowledge from pre-conversion days, which also would have pre-disposed him to remember what Cassiodorus had said.
 
===Jordanes' political stance===
The ''De origine actibusque Getarum'' of Jordanes does not share the anti-Gothic sentiment at Constantinople of the times. Whether it can be said to reflect Gothic sympathies or rather to be an impartial authority is a matter of opinion. Jordanes perhaps absorbed into his work a fundamental idea of Cassiodorus (known from surviving works), that the only way to secure for the Goths a prosperous future was to bring about their peaceful absorption into the [[Roman Empire]]. Cassiodorus' view was shared by the churchmen of Rome, which is the reason why the pope was being detained in Constantinople.
 
Jordanes has little to say of the inner history and policy of the previous Italian kingdom of [[Theodoric]]: his interests lie, according to [[Theodor Mommsen|Mommsen]], within a triangle defined by the three points [[Sirmium]], [[Larissa]] and [[Constantinople]]. His lack of anti-[[Hun]]nish sentiment and respect for the abilities of Attila are a mark of his impartiality.
 
==Notes==
{{Reflist}}
<!--This article uses the Cite.php citation mechanism. If you would like more information on how to add references to this article, please see http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cite/Cite.php -->
<div class="references-small" style="-moz-column-count:2; column-count:2;">
<references />
</div>
 
==Editions==
<!-- mix of two reference as one *[[Theodore Mommsen]], ''Iordanis Romana et Getica''(1882), [[Weidmannsche Buchhandlung]], Berlin, centenary reprint [[Monumenta Germaniae Historica]], München (1982), ISBN 3-921575-17-6. -->
* Mierow, Charles Christopher, ''The Gothic History of Jordanes: In English with an Introduction and a Commentary'', 1915. Reprinted 2006. Evolution Publishing, ISBN 978-1-889758-77-0. [http://www.evolpub.com/CRE/CREseries.html#CRE2]
 
==References==
*{{1911}}
*{{catholic}} which was contributed or sourced by: TEUFFEL-SCHWABE, Gesch. der romischen Literatur (1890),? 485; Allgem. deutsche Biogr., XIV; WATTENBACH, Deutschlands Geschichtsquellen, 1 (1893), 72-9; POTTHAST, Bibliotheca, 1 (1896), 682-4; ACHLAND in Dict. Chris. Biog., s. v. Jordanus.
 
{{US-company-stub}}
==External links==
{{Chicago-stub}}
*Jordanes, [http://www.acs.ucalgary.ca/~vandersp/Courses/texts/jordgeti.html ''The Origins and Deeds of the Goths''], translated by Charles C. Mierow. [http://www.northvegr.org/lore/jgoth/index.php alternative].
* {{gutenberg author| id=Jordanes | name=Jordanes}}
*[http://ccat.sas.upenn.edu/~jod/texts/jordanes.html The Aims of Jordanes]
*[http://www.romansonline.com/Indx_src.asp?Doccode=Gth_01 The Origins and Deeds of the Goths]
 
{{Chicago}}
[[Category:6th century]]
[[Category:Byzantine historians]]
[[Category:Goths]]
[[Category:Early medieval Latin writers]]
[[Category:Late antique Latin writers]]
 
[[Category:Employment]]
[[bg:Йорданес]]
[[Category:Employment compensation]]
[[ca:Jordanes]]
[[Category:Marketing research companies]]
[[cy:Jordanes]]
[[Category:Public opinion research companies]]
[[da:Jordanes]]
[[Category:Executive search firms]]
[[de:Jordanes]]
[[Category:Companies based in Chicago]]
[[fr:Jordanès]]
[[it:Iordanes]]
[[he:יורדנס]]
[[hu:Iordanes]]
[[nl:Jordanes]]
[[no:Jordanes]]
[[pl:Jordanes]]
[[ro:Iordanes]]
[[ru:Иордан (историк)]]
[[sr:Јордан (историчар)]]
[[fi:Jordanes]]
[[sv:Jordanes]]
[[uk:Йордан (історик)]]