Talk:Bicycle kick and Wikipedia:Peer review: Difference between pages

Revision as of 01:39, 4 November 2005

Revision as of 21:14, 19 November 2005

Line 1:

{{Shortcut|[[WP:PR]]}}

I made an effort to edit this page earlier today to correct the information regarding the so-called bicycle kick. It was first used in a game in 1917 during the South American Championships in Argentina, and received its official desigantion as "chilena" in 1927 after it was performed multiple times by Chilean club Colo-Colo player David Arellano while on an exhibition tour through Europe. Because it was first seen in Europe performed by a Chilean player, it became designated as the "chilena", or Chilean kick. The Brazilian player who has been credited with "inventing" the move did not play until the mid-30s. Remember South America hosted the first ever World Cup in 1930, and in many ways, the game is much more popular there than anywhere else in the world. I don't understand why the monitor of this page reverted the info, when if you ask FIFA about the "chilena" kick, they will know exactly what you are talking about. The designation "bicycle kick" came much later as other players began to emulate the move, and Brazilian players internationalized it as a result of their soccer success. I guess it is yet another case of historical revisionism told from a more conventional Eurocentric approach. I think the claim above, well known in Latin America and Spain, should at least form part of the official story. If it does not, then Wikipedia is promoting half-truths in this matter.

<small>''[{{SERVER}}{{localurl:Wikipedia:Peer review|action=purge}} Purge server cache]''</small>

Credited to [[Leonidas da Silva]], who credited it to [[Petronilho de Brito]], but actually invented by a Chile player in 1917, before coming to wider attention in 1927. That's the (confusing) info. you'd get from Wikipedia about the bicycle kick! [[User:Ben davison|Ben davison]] 23:50, 25 October 2005 (UTC)

This page is for nearly Featured-standard articles that need the final checking by peers before being nominated as [[Wikipedia:Featured article candidates|Featured article candidates]]. '''Requests for peer review''' are listed here to expose articles to closer scrutiny than they might otherwise receive. See [[:Category:Wikipedia style guidelines]] and [[:Category:Wikipedia how-to]] for advice on writing [[Wikipedia:How to write a great article|great articles]]. Or look at the discussion of [[Wikipedia:The perfect article|the perfect article]] and try to reach as many of those ideals as possible. If an article needs extensive work, please list it on [[Wikipedia:Pages needing attention|Pages needing attention]], [[Wikipedia:Requests for expansion|Requests for expansion]] or [[Wikipedia:Cleanup|Cleanup]]. Please list article content disputes on [[Wikipedia:Requests for comment|Requests for comment]] rather than here.

== Sources? ==

'''Note:''' [[Peer review]] is the process of review by peers and usually implies a group of authoritative reviewers who are equally familiar and expert in the subject. The process represented by this page is not formal peer review in that sense and articles that undergo this process cannot be assumed to have greater authority than any other.

There should probably be some sources to some of this info.

Also, is a scissor kick pretty much the same thing? I can't find a clear description of it anywhere.

{{FAPath}}

{{PR-instructions}}

''See also [[Wikipedia:WikiProject Computer and video games/Peer review|Peer reviews]] for [[Wikipedia:WikiProject Computer and video games]]''

__TOC__

==Requests==

<!-- Please place new requests at the TOP of the page. Thanks! -->

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Castle of the Winds}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Logic}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Taekwondo}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Hapkido}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Sokol space suit}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Sense of community}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Indigenous Australians}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Waterfall model}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Portugal from the Restoration to the 1755 Earthquake}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Mariah Carey}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/William Tecumseh Sherman}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Civilian control of the military}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Objectivist poets}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Early life of Joseph Smith, Jr.}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Malwa}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Targeted therapy}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/New World Order (political)}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Bjørnøya}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Neurofibromatosis type II}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/FairTax}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Lloyd's of London}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Movie projector}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Soviet Union}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Bayreuth Festival}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Miyamoto Musashi}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Douglas Adams}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Voting system}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/We Belong Together}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Carl Johan Trygg}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Article 153 of the Constitution of Malaysia}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/White's Tree Frog}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Tecmo Cup Football Game}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/The Star Wars Holiday Special}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles and Fundamental Duties of India}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/2005 Philippine electoral crisis}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Omnipotence paradox}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Solid State Lighting}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Providence, Rhode Island}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Potatau Te Wherowhero}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Legal status of Taiwan}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Cerritos, California}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/1997 Pacific hurricane season}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Dennis Berry}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Dawson Creek, British Columbia}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Psilocybe cubensis}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Albanian language}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Ceteris paribus}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/The Day After}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Neuropsychopharmacology}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Economics of the Iroquois}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Religious Society of Friends}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Texas State Highway 195}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/I Heard It Through the Grapevine}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Céline Dion}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Northern Ireland naming dispute}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Claudius}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/The Waterboys}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Eton College}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Constantine Maroulis}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Delrina}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Ubykh language}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/List of NFL champions}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/BASIC programming language}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Malta}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Marching band}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Palpatine}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Fabio Lione}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Irna Phillips}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/TGV}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/History of Ireland}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Guinness}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Imperialism in Asia}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/The West Wing (television)}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Game theory}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Unclean animals}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Prester John}}

{{Wikipedia:Peer review/Manifold}}

<!--

NOTICE:

PLEASE add new entries at the top, not the bottom. Thanks.

-->

==Archives==

*'''[[Wikipedia:Peer review/November 2005]] (current)'''

*[[Wikipedia:Peer review/October 2005]]

*[[Wikipedia:Peer review/September 2005]]

*[[Wikipedia:Peer review/August 2005]]

*[[Wikipedia:Peer review/July 2005]]

*[[Wikipedia:Peer review/June 2005]]

*[[Wikipedia:Peer review/May 2005]]

*[[Wikipedia:Peer review/April 2005]]

*[[Wikipedia:Peer review/March 2005]]

*[[Wikipedia:Peer review/February 2005]]

*[[Wikipedia:Peer review/January 2005]]

*[[Wikipedia:Peer review/December 2004]]

*[[Wikipedia:Peer review/Archive 3]], [[Wikipedia:Peer review/Archive 2]], [[Wikipedia:Peer review/Archive 1]]

[[Category:Editorial validation]]

[[de:Wikipedia:Review]]

[[fr:Wikipédia:Comité de lecture]]

[[simple:Wikipedia:Peer review]]

[[fi:Wikipedia:Vertaisarviointi]]

[[zh:Wikipedia:同行评审]]