Interwiki synchronization: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 22:37, 17 November 2008

Latest revision as of 14:28, 24 November 2015

(47 intermediate revisions by 31 users not shown)

Line 1:

{{shortcut|[[IS]]}}

{{Interwiki redirect|d:Wikidata:interwiki conflicts}}

{{Historical}}

This page is intended to host discussions between representatives from individual wikis regarding [[Help:Interwiki_linking#Interlanguage_link|interlanguage links]] between Wikipedia articles.

Interlanguage links can often become entangled in [[Interwiki conflicts|conflicts]]. For example, if the page [[:en:Emergency medical technician]] links to [[:fr:Ambulancier]], but [[:fr:Ambulancier]] links to [[:en:Paramedic]], thisthen isthat would be a conflict. This confuses the readers of Wikipedia and usually cannot be automatically maintained by interwiki bots (such as [[Interwiki.py]]). This inability to maintain links automatically frequently leads to lack of updates, stale links etc.

The task of synchronizing these links manually is hard, but challenging and interesting. A central hub for discussing this will foster further cooperation and concord between different language Wikipedias.

Line 11 ⟶ 14:

== Automated analysis ==

; Note: This database appears very outdated. It's questionable if it has ever been updated since its creation in 2008. [[User:Have mörser, will travel|Have mörser, will travel]] 18:03, 23 September 2011 (UTC)

The largest [[:en:Connected component (graph theory)|connected component]] in the graph of interlanguage links between articles contains well over 70'000 nodes (including over 3'000 from the English edition) and over 3'000'000 links.

There are 24 more connected components with over 1'000 nodes. In total, there are about 60'000 inconsistent connected components in the graph.

These figures are based on an analysis of snapshots from late August 2008.

Line 35 ⟶ 39:

Thanks, [[User:Bolo1729|Bolo1729]] 22:41, 29 October 2008 (UTC)

'''Update''': I've opened [http://wikitools.icm.edu.pl/ this service]

which presents all of the conflicts in which two or more English articles are involved (a little bit over 30'000 cases).

In each case, edit recommendations are also presented.

--[[User:Bolo1729|Bolo1729]] 17:01, 4 December 2008 (UTC)

== Opening a new case ==

Line 41 ⟶ 50:

= Current discussions =

{{/Lonesome George & Chelonoidis abingdonii}}

{{/Nymph}}

{{/Dutch Brazil}}

{{/Order of Malta}}

{{/gunpowder}}

{{/Kangaroo}}

{{/Daucus carota}}

{{/Normandy Landings}}

{{/Open source vs Open source software}}

{{/Apple vs. Malus domesticus}}

{{/Finger vs. Digit (anatomy)}}

{{/Trauma}}

{{/Featured articles}}

{{/Occultation-Eclipse}}

{{/Antarctica}}

{{/Dollar}}

{{/Epistemology}}

{{/Brand and trademark}}

{{/Remembrance day}}

Line 48 ⟶ 71:

{{/Google}}

{{/Soldier - Military personnel}}

{{/Microsoft_.NET_vs_Framework_.NET}}

{{/Rice}}

{{/Contre-la-montre-Time trial}}

{{/A Few Good Men}}

{{/Radioactivity}}

{{/publishing}}

{{/nl:Röntgenfoto vs de:Röntgen and de:Röntgenaufnahme}}

{{/curator}}

{{/Mobile and Mobile Phone Operating Systems}}

<!-- add new cases to the bottom of the list in the format: {{/CONFLICTNAME}} -->

= Archived discussions =

*[[/Tax]]

==September 2008==

* [[/Black box/]]

Line 57 ⟶ 90:

* [[/Philately/]]

* [[/Dumpling/]]

{{* [[/Epistemology}}/]]

= See also =

* [[A newer look at the interlanguage link]]

* [[Interwiki conflicts]]

* [[Help:Interwiki_linking#Interlanguage_link|Interlanguage links]]

* [[w:Wikipedia:WikiProject Interlanguage Links/Ideas from the Hebrew Wikipedia]]