Revision as of 18:42, 25 October 2005 edit Adashiel (talk \| contribs) Extended confirmed users 17,302 edits →Articles currently on VfD: AfD for Wired completed (d), AfDs for DROP DEAD, List of webcomics ← Previous edit		Latest revision as of 17:26, 10 March 2021 edit undo MJL (talk \| contribs) Extended confirmed users, Page movers, New page reviewers, Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers, Template editors 42,557 edits removed Category:Webcomics work group; added Category:WikiProject Webcomics using HotCat
Line 1: {{Historical\|WP:WCXD}} ~~==VfD==~~ {{Wikipedia:WikiProject Comics/Webcomics work group/Sidebar}} [[Comixpedia]] has started a [[Comixpedia:Main Page\|Webcomic Wiki]] using the [[GFDL]] license. Well-written webcomic articles that don't make the notability criteria can be moved there: they've got a [[Comixpedia:WebcomicWiki:Wikipedia import\|Wikipedia import]] page for discussing import from Wikipedia. To maintain GFDL compliance, articles that are up for VfD will need to have their histories copied over to the talk page on WebcomicWiki. The [[interwiki link]] prefix is [[Comixpedia:Main Page\|Comixpedia:]]. This page is strongly outdated and no longer in use. ~~{{See also\|Wikipedia:WikiProject Deletion sorting/Comics and animation}}~~ ~~{{See also\|Wikipedia:WikiProject Deletion sorting/Webcomics}}~~ ==Deletion== ~~==Articles currently on VfD==~~ Comixpedia has started a [[Comixpedia:Main Page\|Webcomic Wiki]] using the [[GNU Free Documentation License]] license. Well-written webcomic articles that don't make the notability criteria can be moved there: they've got a [[Comixpedia:Project:Wikipedia import\|Wikipedia import]] page for discussing import from Wikipedia. To maintain GNU FDL compliance, if you copy an article from Wikipedia to Comixpedia, add <code><nowiki>{{credit}}</nowiki></code> ([[Comixpedia:Template:Credit]]) to the end; this will establish that the article uses content from the article of the same name at Wikipedia. The [[interwiki link]] prefix is [[Comixpedia:Main Page\|Comixpedia:]]. * [[Able and Baker]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Able_and_Baker_(2nd_nomination)]] (closing admin reversed first AfD due to error) * [[AnimeTronic]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/AnimeTronic]] * [[Chaff City]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Chaff_City]] * [[Dr McNinja]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Dr_McNinja]] * [[DROP DEAD]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/DROP_DEAD]] * [[Fat Cat Online]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Fat_Cat_Online]] * [[Fried (webcomic)]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Fried_(webcomic)]] * [[Life on Forbez]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Life_on_Forbez]] * [[List of webcomics]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/List_of_webcomics]] * [[Minding My Own Business]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Minding_My_Own_Business]] * [[New World (comic)]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/New_World_%28comic%29]] * [[The Onyx Brigade]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Onyx Brigade]] * [[Urban trash]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Urban_trash]] * [[Surreal U]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Surreal_U]] [[Comic Genesis]] also has a [http://cgwiki.comicgenesis.com/ Webcomic Wiki] for all its hosted webcomics. ~~===Articles that have had a VfD===~~ * [[8 1/2 by Eleven]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/8_1/2_by_Eleven]] * [[Able and Baker]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Able and Baker]] * [[Abstract Gender]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Abstract Gender]] * [[Acid Reflux]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acid Reflux]] '''Kept'''. * [[Apollo 9 (webcomic)]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apollo 9 (webcomic)]] * [[Avant-garde comics]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avant-garde comics]] * [[Bizarre Uprising]] at [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Bizarre Uprising]]. The result of the debate was '''No Consensus'''. * [[Bored and Evil]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bored and Evil]] * [[Buddies in Big Places]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buddies in Big Places]] * [[Comixpedia.org]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Comixpedia.org]] '''Redirected''' to [[Comixpedia]]. * [[Deathfist Ninja GKaiser]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Deathfist_Ninja_GKaiser]] * [[Eddache]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eddache]] * [[Electric Sheep Comix]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Electric Sheep Comix]] '''Kept'''. * [[Elf Only Inn]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Elf Only Inn]]. Later recreated. * [[Elf Only Inn]] at [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Elf Only Inn 2]]. The result of the debate was undecided, '''Kept'''. * [[Elf Only Inn]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elf Only Inn (3rd nomination)]] '''Kept'''. * [[Emperor Benedict XVI]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Emperor Benedict XVI]] * [[Entertain-Dome]] at [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Entertain-Dome]] The result of the debate was '''No Consensus'''. * [[Eversummer Eve]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eversummer Eve]] * [[Furfire]] at [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Furfire]], the result was '''No Consensus'''. * [[Gravenhurst (webcomic)]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gravenhurst (webcomic)]] * [[Growlcomic]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Growlcomic]] * [[Heroquest webcomic]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Heroquest_webcomic]] * [[The Jar]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Jar]], undeleted in light of new information. * [[Jack Nada]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Jack Nada]]. * [[JesusMan]]: Deleted by [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/JesusMan]]. * [[Loxie & Zoot]] at [[Wikipedia:Pages for deletion/Loxie & Zoot]]. '''Kept''' * [[Max Hades]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Max Hades]]. * [[Midnight Macabre]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Midnight Macabre]]. '''Kept''' * [[Natalie Dee]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natalie Dee]] '''Kept'''. * [[No Need for Bushido]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/No Need for Bushido]]. '''Kept''' * [[Of Mouse And Moon]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Of Mouse And Moon]]. * [[Our Home Planet]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Our Home Planet]]. * [[The Outer Circle]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The_Outer_Circle]] * [[Pinocchio and FooT]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pinocchio and FooT]] * [[Pirates Of Penumbra]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Pirates Of Penumbra]]. * [[Powerpuff Girls Doujinshi]] at [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Powerpuff Girls Doujinshi]]. '''No Consensus'''. * [[Rancid toast]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Rancid toast]]. * [[Rabbits (webcomic)]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rabbits (webcomic)]] * [[Razlo]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Razlo]]. * [[Rockwood (webcomic)]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rockwood (webcomic)]] * [[Robert Colin]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Colin]] * [[The Spiders]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Spiders]] '''No Consenus'''. * [[Stickman]] at [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/Stickman]]. The result of the debate was to '''redirect''' to [[Stick figure]] * [[String Finger Theatre]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/String Finger Theatre]] * [[This Comic Sucks]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/This Comic Sucks]] * [[Triangle and Robert]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Triangle and Robert]] '''Kept'''. * [[UG Madness]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/UG Madness]] * [[Welcome Consumer]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Welcome Consumer]] * {{tl\|Webcomic notability}} deleted by [[Wikipedia:Templates for deletion#Template: Webcomic notability]] * [[Wired (comic)]] deleted by [[Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Wired_(comic)]] ===Open=== ~~===Articles that may need a vote for deletion===~~ If you add an article to this list as an AfD candidate, please add to the relevant deletion discussion the following:<br/>''<nowiki> {{subst:webcomic deletion}} </nowiki>'' ~~Add any existing articles here that are non-notable or vanity [[Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Webcomics/VfD\|here]].~~ [[David Willis (cartoonist)]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Willis (cartoonist)]] [[Vera Brosgol]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vera Brosgol]] [[Felicity Flint, Agent from H.A.R.M.]] (PROD, 7 September) [[:Category:Keentoons]] at [[Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2007 April 30#Category:Keentoons]] [[:Category:Newshounds]] at [[Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2007 April 30#Category:Newshounds]] [[:Category:8-Bit Theater]] at [[Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2007 April 30#Category:8-Bit Theater]] [[:Category:Blind Ferret Entertainment]] at [[Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2007 April 30#Category:Blind Ferret Entertainment]] [[:Category:The Wotch]] at [[Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2007 April 30#Category:The Wotch]] [[:Category:Order of the Stick]] at [[Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2007 April 30#Category:Order of the Stick]] ===Closed=== : ''See the [[Wikipedia:WikiProject Webcomics/Deletion/Archive\|archive]] for a list of older deletion nominations. ==== A – C ==== {{afdl\|A Pessimistic Sense of Inadequacy\|\|2006-09-15\|2006-09-20\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Abstract Gender\|Abstract Gender (2nd nomination)\|2006-09-24\|2006-09-30\|Deleted}} {{drvl\|Accidental Centaurs\|2007 March 14\|Deleted\|}} {{afdl\|Adventure Log\|\|2007-04-19\|2006-04-24\|Merged}} * {{afdl\|Agnostica\|\|2006-09-03\|2006-09-08\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Aikida\|\|2006-09-16\|2006-09-22\|Deleted}} * [[Alistair Katt]], [[Ferris the Rat]], [[Kevin J. Dog]], [[Lorna Dilbrook]], [[Renata Fayre]], [[Rochelle O'Shea]], [[Sam Shepherd (Newshounds)]] and [[Wolfram Blitzen]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alistair Katt]] '''Deleted''' ''([[July 19]] [[2006]] – [[July 24]] [[2006]])'' * {{prodded\|AOMP\|2006-09-06}} * [[:Category:Anime and manga inspired webcomics]] to [[:Category:Anime and manga webcomics]] at [[Wikipedia:Categories for deletion/Log/2006 July 11#Category:Anime and manga inspired webcomics to Category:Anime and manga webcomics]] '''Kept''' ''([[July 10]] [[2006]] – [[July 20]] [[2006]])'' * {{afdl\|Anime Arcadia\|\|2006-09-24\|2006-09-30\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Aozora\|\|2006-09-16\|2006-09-22\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Arnold & Mr. Fish\|\|2006-09-15\|2006-09-15\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Aozora: Another Blue Sky\|\|2006-08-25\|2006-08-30\|deleted}} * {{drvl\|Attitude 3: The New Subversive Online Cartoonists\|2007 March 21\|Restored}} * {{afdl\|Avalon (webcomic)\|\|2007-02-20\|2007-02-25\|Kept}} * {{prodded\|Banished!\|2006-09-19}} * {{drvl\|Barkeater Lake\|2007 April 13\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Better Days (webcomic)\|\|2006-09-06\|2006-09-11\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Big plastic factory\|\|2006-09-04\|2006-09-09\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Big Plastic Factory\|Big plastic factory (second nomination)\|2006-09-18\|2006-09-19\|Speedy Deleted}} * {{prodded\|Blue Crash Kit\|2006-09-19}} * {{afdl\|Charby the Vampirate\|\|2006-09-18\|2006-09-19\|Speedy Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Catharsis (comic)\|\|2006-09-24\|2006-09-29\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Chris Comics\|\|2006-09-24\|2006-09-29\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Clickwheel\|\|2006-09-29\|2006-10-04\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|The Coffee Achievers\|\|2006-09-18\|2006-09-24\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Comedity\|\|2006-08-31\|2006-09-06\|Deleted}} * [[Corner Pocket]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corner Pocket]] '''Speedy deleted''' ''([[August 26]] [[2006]] – [[August 27]] [[2006]])'' * {{afdl\|Cosmic hero\|\|2006-09-09\|2006-09-14\|Deleted}} * {{prodded\|Crash n' Bass!\|2006-09-12}} * {{afdl\|Cyanide and Happiness\|\|2006-09-26\|2006-10-02\|No Consensus}} ==== D – F ==== * {{afdl\|Death to the Extremist\|\|2007-03-21\|2007-03-27\|no consensus}} * [[Digital Strips]] '''Deleted''' via [[WP:PROD]] ''([[August 6]] [[2006]] – [[August 11]] [[2006]])'' * {{afdl\|Duel Class\|\|2006-09-27\|2006-10-03\|Delete}} * {{afdl\|The Disassociate\|\|2006-09-03\|2006-09-05\|Speedy deleted}} * {{afdl\|El Goonish Shive\|\|2007-02-16\|2007-02-21\|Keep and Cleanup}} * [[Everlasting Wanderers]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Everlasting Wanderers]] '''Deleted''' ''([[August 23]] [[2006]] – [[August 28]] [[2006]])'' * {{afdl\|Everybody Loves Eric Raymond\|\|2006-11-01\|2006-11-08\|No Consensus}} * {{afdl\|Exiled Arts (webcomic)\|\|2006-08-27\|2006-08-31\|deleted}} * {{afdl\|Exterminatus Now\|\|2006-09-28\|2006-10-03\|Delete}} * {{drvl\|Fighting Words\|2007 March 27\|Redirect\|}} * {{afdl\|Fluble\|\|2007-01-09\|2007-01-14\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Friend Bear\|\|2006-08-26\|2006-08-31\|Deleted and redirected to [[List of Care Bears]]}} ==== G – I ==== * {{afdl\|The Gods' Pack\|\|2006-09-18\|2006-09-23\|Deleted}} * [[Golden Throne (webcomic)]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Golden Throne (webcomic)]] '''Deleted''' ''([[August 23]] [[2006]] – [[August 28]] [[2006]])'' * {{afdl\|Gone with the Blastwave\|\|2007-01-04\|2007-01-10\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Heroes Inc.\|\|2006-08-30\|2006-09-04\|Deleted}} * [[Hockey Zombie]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hockey Zombie]] '''Deleted''' ''([[August 23]] [[2006]] – [[August 28]] [[2006]])'' * {{afdl\|HOUSD\|HOUSD (2nd nomination)\|2006-09-20\|2006-09-26\|Deleted}} {{afdl\|Insert Funn13 Here\|\|2006-08-26\|2006-08-30\|deleted}} {{afdl\|Irregular Webcomic!\|\|2006-09-04\|2006-09-04\|Speedy kept}} ==== J – L ==== * {{afdl\|Jazz Age Chronicles\|\|2006-11-26\|2006-12-01\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Joe The Circle\|\|2006-11-23\|2006-11-29\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Kagerou (webcomic)\|\|2006-09-24\|2006-09-29\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Killer Robots from Space\|\|2006-08-26\|2006-08-30\|deleted}} * {{afdl\|Life of Wily\|\|2006-08-30\|2006-09-04\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|List of video games based on webcomics\|\|2006-08-27\|2006-08-31\|Delete}} * {{afdl\|Loserz\|\|2006-08-24\|2006-09-02\|no consensus}} * {{afdl\|Loserz\|Loserz (second nomination)\|2006-09-10\|2006-09-15\|Deleted}} ==== M – O ==== * {{afdl\|Magreaux dog\|\|2006-09-11\|2006-09-16\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Manga-gaga\|\|2006-09-09\|2006-09-14\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Masago\|\|2006-09-03\|2006-09-08\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Megaman The Megamissions\|\|2006-09-18\|2006-09-23\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Minjas\|\|2006-09-08\|2006-09-13\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Misadventures etc.\|\|2006-09-15\|2006-09-20\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Misfile\|\|2007-01-09\|2007-01-14\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Misty the Mouse\|\|2006-08-30\|2006-09-10\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Mr. Mohawk Comics\|\|2006-10-02\|2006-10-02\|Speedy Deleted}} * {{afdl\|My Nemesis\|\|2006-08-29\|2006-09-03\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Muertitos\|\|2006-09-12\|2006-09-17\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Nerd Boy\|Nerd Boy (2nd nomination)\|2007-01-03\|2007-01-10\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|No Rest for the Wicked (webcomic)\|\|2007-02-20\|2007-02-26\|Kept}} * {{afdl\|Nukeland Cinema\|\|2006-09-15\|2006-09-20\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Outsider (comic)\|Outsider (comic) (3rd nomination)\|2006-08-23\|2006-08-29\|deleted}} ==== P – R ==== * {{afdl\|Peter Is the Wolf\|\|2006-09-16\|2006-09-22\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Planet Zebeth\|Planet Zebeth (2nd nomination)\|2006-08-30\|2006-08-30\|Speedy deleted and redirect to [[Zebes]]}} * {{prodded\|Post-Nuke\|2006-09-30}} * {{afdl\|Project Jyuunishi\|\|2006-08-29\|2006-09-23\|Deleted}} * {{drvl\|Purple Pussy\|2007 April 13\|Kept}} * {{afdl\|Return to Eden - Comic\|\|2006-09-18\|2006-09-03\|Deleted}} * {{prodded\|Rob and Elliot\|2006-09-19}} ==== S – U ==== * {{prodded\|Sacred Cow Burgers\|2006-09-19}} * {{afdl\|Salo in Space\|Salo in Space (2 nomination)\|2006-08-29\|2006-09-08\|no consensus}} * {{afdl\|Septim's Pride\|\|2006-09-24\|2006-10-05\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Soapy the Chicken\|\|2006-09-17\|2006-09-17\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Slightly damned\|\|2006-08-29\|2006-09-03\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Sonic Hearts: The Hidden Memories\|\|2006-09-06\|2006-08-08\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Starslip Crisis\|\|2007-02-09\|2007-02-15\|delete and redirect to [[Blank Label Comics]]}} * {{afdl\|The Suburban Jungle\|\|2007-01-16\|2007-01-24\|No consensus}} * {{afdl\|Team Nexus\|\|2006-09-16\|2006-09-20\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|The-Slackers\|\|2006-09-11\|2006-09-16\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|The Wotch: My Sister, Myself\|\|2007-02-21\|2007-02-26\|Merge to [[The Wotch]]}} * {{afdl\|The Wotch: Cheer!\|\|2007-02-21\|2007-02-26\|Merge to [[The Wotch]]}} ==== V – Z ==== * {{afdl\|Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards\|\|2007-01-24\|2007-01-29\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards\|Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards (2nd nomination)\|2007-02-16\|2007-02-21\|Keep}} * {{drvl\|2007 Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards\|2007 February 22\|Restored}} * {{afdl\|Whiskerville\|\|2006-08-31\|2006-09-06\|Redirected to [[Whiskervilles]]}} * {{afdl\|White Ninja Comics\|White Ninja Comics (second nomination)\|2007-01-09\|2007-01-14\|Deleted}} * [[Wik Rossley]] and [[Rowley Simmons]] at [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wik Rossley]] '''Deleted''' ''([[July 15]] [[2006]] – [[July 21]] [[2006]])'' * [[:Category:WikiProject Webcomics members]] at [[Wikipedia:Categories for deletion/Log/2006 July 20#WikiProject participants]] ''[[July 20]] [[2006]] – [[July 31]] [[2006]]'' * {{afdl\|Wizzy\|\|2006-09-17\|2006-09-22\|Deleted}} * {{afdl\|World's Worst Girlfriend\|\|2006-09-18\|2006-09-25\|Deleted}} [[Category:WikiProject Webcomics]]

Wikipedia:WikiProject Comics/Webcomics work group/Deletion: Difference between revisions