Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Articles for creation/Helper script/Rewrite: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 05:08, 18 August 2014

Latest revision as of 21:38, 7 November 2014

(24 intermediate revisions by 10 users not shown)

Line 13:

|maxarchsize=95000

}}

{{Historical}}

{{Big|This page is for feedback about the rewritten Articles for creation helper script. See [[Wikipedia:AFCHRW|the rewrite page]] for more information.

<span style="font-size:1.25em">Please, {{red|'''DO NOT EDIT THIS PAGE.'''}} As the Rewrite script has now become the default, all feedback should go to [[WT:AFCH]]. Thanks! '''[[User:Theopolisme|<span style="color:#232323;">Theopolisme</span>]] <span style="color:#4F4F4F;">([[User talk:Theopolisme|<span style="color:#4F4F4F;">talk</span>]])</span>''' 20:34, 7 November 2014 (UTC)</span>

<br>''Does it look like a thread has disappeared? Check the archives →''}}

== Infoxbox, photo request ==

Line 222:

What is up with [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ernesto_Amantegui&diff=621727498&oldid=621727486 this edit]? <span style="background: turquoise; font-family: 'Segoe Script'">([[User talk:Josve05a|'''t''']])&nbsp;[[User:Josve05a|<span style="color:white;">'''Josve05a'''</span>]]&nbsp;([[Special:Contributions/Josve05a|'''c''']])</span> 05:08, 18 August 2014 (UTC)

== [0.8] Feedback about removing existing CSD-templates ==

See [[Special:Diff/626142851&oldid=626142722]]. (Might have been deleted. Please ask an admin for assistance to see the diff.)

But if t has been tagged with e.g. {{tl|db-copyvio|url=http://www.luluschocolate.com/founder.html}} and then reviewed as cv, it removes the template. (I had the nominate for deletion-tag turned off, since it was already tagged for deletion). <span style="background: turquoise; font-family: 'Segoe Script'">([[User talk:Josve05a|'''t''']])&nbsp;[[User:Josve05a|<span style="color:white;">'''Josve05a'''</span>]]&nbsp;([[Special:Contributions/Josve05a|'''c''']])</span> 22:41, 18 September 2014 (UTC)

== Check for orphans? ==

The previous script checked for [[Wikipedia:Orphan|orphans]] and added [[Template:Orphan]] as necessary. That would be a good enhancement to the new script; "orphan" is a useful maintenance category that draws attention to articles that need more integration into the encyclopedia, and the template gives one-click access to [[User:Edward/Find_link| a script]] to find links from other articles. [[User:Jodi.a.schneider|Jodi.a.schneider]] ([[User talk:Jodi.a.schneider|talk]]) 17:08, 21 September 2014 (UTC)

:That's a good idea, as long as the script does not suggest that the reviewer de-orphan the page. The reviewers have enough to do already, and each new expectation (such as adding Wikiprojects, wikidata and categories), while desirable in the long run, slows down the reviewing and makes the backlog larger. &mdash;[[User:Anne Delong|Anne Delong]] ([[User talk:Anne Delong|talk]]) 17:29, 21 September 2014 (UTC)

::I just want it to place [[Template:Orphan]] on the accepted page (as it used to). Anybody can come along and de-orphan. (As a reader, it's easy to run Edwardbot if it's a one-click operation; we don't need reviewers to do this ahead of time).[[User:Jodi.a.schneider|Jodi.a.schneider]] ([[User talk:Jodi.a.schneider|talk]]) 21:44, 21 September 2014 (UTC)

== [0.8] Feedback about WikiProject Classical music ==

WikiProject Classical music doesn't appear on the list of projects to add. Also, whenever I guess at the name of a Wikiproject and it turns out not to exist or not to be on the list, I then try to use the backspace key to remove the letters I've typed so that I can try again. At this point FireFox says "not responding", the page is greyed out and there is a 30 second or so delay. By the way, this script in general works very well. &mdash;[[User:Anne Delong|Anne Delong]] ([[User talk:Anne Delong|talk]]) 12:00, 25 September 2014 (UTC)

== [0.8] Feedback about [your topic here] ==

This is so user friendly. I'm just breezing through them. Thank you! [[User:Origamite|Origamite]]^{[[User talk:Origamite|ⓣ]][[Special:Contributions/Origamite|ⓒ]]} 04:55, 26 September 2014 (UTC)

== [0.8] Feedback about notify-ing renamed users ==

See https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk%3AMichaelwongPMNCH&diff=630027750&oldid=626217692 <span style="background: turquoise;font-family: 'Segoe Script', 'Comic Sans MS';">([[User talk:Josve05a|'''t''']])&nbsp;[[User:Josve05a|<span style="color:white;">'''Josve05a'''</span>]]&nbsp;([[Special:Contributions/Josve05a|'''c''']])</span> 20:58, 17 October 2014 (UTC)

:Pinging {{u|Theopolisme}} to make sure he hasn't forgotten about this project of his. {{=P}} <span style="background: turquoise;font-family: 'Segoe Script', 'Comic Sans MS';">([[User talk:Josve05a|'''t''']])&nbsp;[[User:Josve05a|<span style="color:white;">'''Josve05a'''</span>]]&nbsp;([[Special:Contributions/Josve05a|'''c''']])</span> 21:01, 17 October 2014 (UTC)

* What do you want the script to do about it? Even Twinkle doesn't follow userspace redirects. The reason for this as I understand it is that the number of these edge cases doesn't outweigh the coding bloat and to accommodate following the redirect. — <span class="nowrap">&#123;&#123;U&#124;[[User:Technical 13|Technical 13]]&#125;&#125; ^{([[Special:EmailUser/Technical 13|e]] • [[User talk:Technical 13|t]] • [[Special:Contribs/Technical 13|c]])}</span> 18:05, 18 October 2014 (UTC)

** {{Ping|Technical 13}} maybe not tag at all, and ask the reviewer to do it manually. And the tool could give the raw code for the reviewer to copy+paste to the "right" talk page. <span style="background: turquoise;font-family: 'Segoe Script', 'Comic Sans MS';">([[User talk:Josve05a|'''t''']])&nbsp;[[User:Josve05a|<span style="color:white;">'''Josve05a'''</span>]]&nbsp;([[Special:Contributions/Josve05a|'''c''']])</span> 18:56, 19 October 2014 (UTC)

** I think I would like to ''choose'' as a reviewer to message the original account or to message both accounts, the redirected and the original. [[User:Timtrent|<span style="color:#800">Fiddle</span>]] [[User talk:Timtrent|<span style="color:#070">Faddle</span>]] 19:13, 19 October 2014 (UTC)

* Let me clarify... The number of these edge cases doesn't outweigh the coding bloat and to accommodate <u>detecting</u> the redirect. — <span class="nowrap">&#123;&#123;U&#124;[[User:Technical 13|Technical 13]]&#125;&#125; ^{([[Special:EmailUser/Technical 13|e]] • [[User talk:Technical 13|t]] • [[Special:Contribs/Technical 13|c]])}</span> 21:34, 19 October 2014 (UTC)

== [0.8] Feedback about typo ==

After I enter a reason and hit "Decline submission", it says "Decling submission", not "Declining submission". [[User:Origamite|Origamite]]^{[[User talk:Origamite|ⓣ]][[Special:Contributions/Origamite|ⓒ]]} 14:27, 18 October 2014 (UTC)

:I have fixed this in the code. Only waiting for Theo to [https://github.com/WPAFC/afch-rewrite/pull/24 merge the pull request], and port it to Wikipedia. Thanks! <span style="background: turquoise;font-family: 'Segoe Script', 'Comic Sans MS';">([[User talk:Josve05a|'''t''']])&nbsp;[[User:Josve05a|<span style="color:white;">'''Josve05a'''</span>]]&nbsp;([[Special:Contributions/Josve05a|'''c''']])</span> 17:32, 18 October 2014 (UTC)

== [0.8] Feedback about talk page ==

The tool should warn if a talk page exists. <span style="background: turquoise;font-family: 'Segoe Script', 'Comic Sans MS';">([[User talk:Josve05a|'''t''']])&nbsp;[[User:Josve05a|<span style="color:white;">'''Josve05a'''</span>]]&nbsp;([[Special:Contributions/Josve05a|'''c''']])</span> 18:54, 19 October 2014 (UTC)

== Feature Request ==

Hi, I would like to see an option which allows multiple reasons for denial. This has been discussed [[Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Articles_for_creation#AfC_.26_Draft_--_potential_for_improvements.3F|here]], where there is consensus. Thanks! [[User:Darylgolden|<b style="color:#FA0">Darylgolden</b>]]^{([[User talk:Darylgolden|<b style="color:#F00">talk</b>]])} 01:58, 23 October 2014 (UTC)

== Support "details" in [[:Template:Afc decline]] ==

A recent change started supporting the "reason" tag in [[:Template:Afc decline]], but this didn't work with reasons such as a custom reason or the "dup" reason that require a second parameter. I have changed [[:Template:Afc decline]] to support a "details" parameter that passes a second parameter to [[:Template:AFC submission/comments]]. This parameter is already collected by the AFCH script for use in [[Template:AFC submission]], but needs to be passed to [[:Template:Afc decline]] as well. --[[User:Ahecht|Ahecht]] (<small>[[User_talk:Ahecht|<span style="color:#FFF;background:#00f;display:inline-block;line-height:1.1em;vertical-align:-0.3em;font-size:75%;text-align:center;"><b>TALK<br />PAGE</b></span>]]</small>) 15:15, 4 November 2014 (UTC)

:I submitted an untested pull request at https://github.com/WPAFC/afch-rewrite/pull/25 --[[User:Ahecht|Ahecht]] (<small>[[User_talk:Ahecht|<span style="color:#FFF;background:#00f;display:inline-block;line-height:1.1em;vertical-align:-0.3em;font-size:75%;text-align:center;"><b>TALK<br />PAGE</b></span>]]</small>) 15:49, 4 November 2014 (UTC)

== Difference between this page and [[Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Articles for creation/Helper script]] ==

I'm a bit confused, as [[Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Articles for creation/Helper script]] says that feedback on the AFCH script should be posted either there or to the afch-rewrite github, but the feedback link in AFCH rewrite points here. Is the intention that the other page be for the non-rewrite version (in which case it shouldn't link to the rewrite github), or is the intention that that page be used for general comments but this page be used for bug reports (in which case the intro to that page should link here)? --[[User:Ahecht|Ahecht]] (<small>[[User_talk:Ahecht|<span style="color:#FFF;background:#00f;display:inline-block;line-height:1.1em;vertical-align:-0.3em;font-size:75%;text-align:center;"><b>TALK<br />PAGE</b></span>]]</small>) 16:10, 4 November 2014 (UTC)

:Hi! Uh, yeah, about that &ndash; although I created the rewrite script, I was actually taking a (several month) wikibreak when it was made the default script. It certainly looks like there's a fair bit of overlap/confusion/etc surrounding the scripts... there should ideally only be *one* talkpage, I agree. If I have a second I'll look into consolidating them... Cheers, '''[[User:Theopolisme|<span style="color:#232323;">Theopolisme</span>]] <span style="color:#4F4F4F;">([[User talk:Theopolisme|<span style="color:#4F4F4F;">talk</span>]])</span>''' 22:19, 4 November 2014 (UTC)