Content deleted Content added
Add WP banner(s) - Fictional element redirects |
|||
| (16 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown) | |||
Line 1:
{{WikiProject banner shell|
{{WikiProject Television|stargate=yes}}
}}
==Fan Criticism==
I think I may remove the entire "Fan Criticism" section. It has no references and incorrect. I'm nowhere near a hardcore SG1 fan, and '''I''' know it's wrong. I saw one of those season opening specials on SciFi regarding the production of the show, and the creators of the show credited their major creative tool as being having the protagonists (the Stargate team of the US military) unintentionally causing the major problems that spark a galaxy wide danger, and throughout the show they try to fix mistakes they've made. That would be the exact opposite of the US being a "[[Mary Sue]]" in the show.
Line 74 ⟶ 75:
==Degeneration af this article==
I went back and reviewed June '06 versions of this article, and they were considerably better than its current state. I am going to discuss a complete rewrite with an admin, because as-is, this article seems to get worse on a daily basis. IOA is currently just a compilation of highly biased remarks and revisions to reduce the biased statements, and all these ridiculous edits have robbed it of any quality.[[User:205.188.116.71|205.188.116.71]] 05:36, 22 September 2006 (UTC)
If you really had compared the two versions, you would have noticed the current version is twice as long as the June version, this one is referenced, etc etc... And except for the "criticism" paragraph, most of the content hasn't been edited. Also, you claim most statements here are biased, but after all these "rediculous edits" even the words being used are just quotations from episodes (i.e. "watchdog" => [[The Ties That Bind (Stargate SG-1)]]). [[User:Maartentje|Maartentje]] 09:15, 22 September 2006 (UTC)
PS: One more thing, as I noted on [[Talk:Ancient Control Chair]], the outpost in Antarctica is called the Atlant'''u'''s outpost, the city in the Pegasus Galaxy Atlant'''i'''s. Just check the transcript of Lost City.
:It's '''Atlantis'''. "Terra Atlantus" was the Ancient translation. In the follow sentence Daniel translates it into (Earth) '''Atlantis''' in English. And after they realize that only the outpost was there, everyone called it the Ancient Outpost in Antartica. [[User:205.188.116.71|205.188.116.71]] 17:44, 22 September 2006 (UTC)
===Maartentje===
On a personal note, [[User:Maartentje|Maartentje]], you're ridiculous. You sit and fight with everyone, and you seem to be quite an angry person in general. Almost all of your '''30''' some odd additions to this article have turned out to be unusable, and the half-dozen+ participants in here have '''all''' come out against your poor & biased wording of paragraphs.
I don't know if it's the television show Stargate, or the general policies of Wikipedia, but something in this equation is way over your head. Well, let me rephrase, it's either ignorance or deliberate portrayal of misinformation; but if that's the case then I don't know where your (seemingly) 4th grade spelling and grammatical skills would fall into place. Find a hobby or something. I'm really tired of watching you use this article to sully the integrity of Wikipedia.[[User:205.188.116.71|205.188.116.71]] 17:44, 22 September 2006 (UTC)
Now that's what I call a [[Wikipedia:No personal attacks|personal attack]]... Apparently I'm not the only one ignorant about the finer details of Wikipedia's policy. Also, there's a difference between a friendly discussion and a fight, the only angry person I see here is you. And perhaps you hadn't noticed, but not every human being on Earth is a native speaker of English, so it's real low to point out the odd spelling mistake. And on a final note: we eventually reached a consensus about the article until you showed op complaining about the "degeneration of the article"... There were also only three people here who disagreed with me, not "half a dozen+", of which eventually only two became rude. And if the "degeneration of the article" bothers you so much, why did you only fix some tiny typo's? [[User:Maartentje|Maartentje]] 18:12, 22 September 2006 (UTC)
Personal attacks are not allowed, [[User:205.188.116.71|205.188.116.71]]. And Maartentje is right, you are the one acting aggressively. I'm not into Stargate, but according to me, the article looks fine, at least for the moment. Maybe Maartentje's unusable additions have yielded some result after all [[User:81.245.169.7|81.245.169.7]] 21:26, 22 September 2006 (UTC)
== Croatia?? ==
Way is Croatia highlighted on "Nations confirmed to participate in the Atlantis Project" map?? Croatia is not part of Atlantis expedition! --[[User:Vladar86|Vladar86]] <small>—Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|comment]] was added at 12:16, 24 October 2007 (UTC)</small><!--Template:Undated--> <!--Autosigned by SineBot-->
== Ark of Truth ==
Hey there is a new IOA guy in the Ark of Truth movie someone should add him up on here [[Special:Contributions/68.221.91.130|68.221.91.130]] ([[User talk:68.221.91.130|talk]]) 04:53, 2 January 2008 (UTC)
| |||