Content deleted Content added
rate importance=mid |
→Criticism: Can the template be removed? |
||
Line 66:
:: {{U|Very Fantastic Dude}} can you point at one, two (or more) issues you have with the article? I can't cleanup otherwise, or choose to disagree. That said, I'm not sure the advert template applies even if you feel it promotional, since Julia isn't a "product", in the sense of being sold for money, and the template is explained as "When to use: Add this to articles [when in] whole or part they are advertisements masquerading as articles." with a link to "Articles considered advertisements include those that are solicitations for a business, product or service, or are public relations pieces designed to promote a company or individual." Until we figure out/agree if the template applies at all, you could also move it to one section (there's a variant for sections) if you had only one in mind and/or use a different template that might apply. [[User:Comp.arch|comp.arch]] ([[User talk:Comp.arch|talk]]) 22:18, 12 March 2022 (UTC)
::: {{reply to|Very Fantastic Dude}} {{reply to|Comp.arch}} What do you think? I think it is time to remove this template. It has been there for 3 months and the issue has as far as I know not been very active. The only thing that I could maybe think of is moving the history section down and starting with the Language Features, because this is the section where the archievements of the language are stated (in particular the section on Notable uses). Starting with the features may set the tone of the article differently. However other sites about programming languages (eg. [[Python (programming language)]] start with the history as well. I personaly am not under the impression that this article reads like and advertisement, nor do I think that this template fits, because it does not hit any of the points in [[WP:PROMOTION]].
::: Because the discussion seems to be dormant, I will be removing this template (see point 7 of [[WP:WTRMT]]). If someone does not agree with this, please feel free to put it there again and write on the talk page.
::: Happy editing [[User:TheFibonacciEffect|TheFibonacciEffect]] ([[User talk:TheFibonacciEffect|talk]]) 23:03, 18 June 2022 (UTC)
== Vim and Emacs and other cruft ==
| |||