Content deleted Content added
→Informal style: Reply |
→Multiple major issues: new section |
||
Line 191:
:It is not claiming to be in std namespace. While it is probably influenced by the crate https://crates.io/crates/rsmonad, I'm not sure if it's worth mentioning since the API seems pretty generic. Would some clarification help maybe? [[User:J824h|Junghyeon Park]] ([[User talk:J824h|talk]]) 07:36, 19 January 2024 (UTC)
== Multiple major issues ==
This article reads as an informal guide for programmers, contrary to [[WP:NOTAGUIDE]]. Almost half of all sources are Internet postings, conference talks, and Haskell wiki pages and many, not limited to these types, are strongly opinionated or tutorial; following these, the text comes across as [[WP:OR]] outside a few more encyclopedic sections like History. Normative statements about usage should be contextualized as proper to the norms of functional programming, where they can be supported as such, and otherwise avoided as editorial. Lengthy segments are motivated by only appeals to naturalness, enumerations of supposed advantages, or assertions about what 'many programmers prefer', if at all, and sourced only to guides and documentation, if at all. In my view, major cuts and rewrites are required. Looking at how the subject is handled in other languages, I can recommend [https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monade_(Informatik) the German article] as being a fraction of the length and proceeding from definitions to context to a focused set of examples. [[User:Terminator 2 really happened|Terminator 2 really happened]] ([[User talk:Terminator 2 really happened|talk]]) 22:06, 8 August 2024 (UTC)
| |||