Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Several Monty Python sketches: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
moving the response to below the comment it was responding to |
John Carter (talk | contribs) →Several Monty Python sketches: comment |
||
Line 62:
:::My statement above was not intended to deal directly with the subject of these skits per se. I don't think any of us know one way or another whether these skits do receive substantive treatment in the relevant books yet. I know I don't, having just started doing anything with that subject today. However, I do believe that if the skits are found to be non-notable individually, they will almost certainly be turned into sections of other articles shortly thereafter. If that is the case, then deleting them now, before such notability can be established by the comparatively few individuals who have had any activity with the subject area, might prove to be counterproductive. If they do qualify as non-notable, though, like I said, I am certain the content will be merged into other articles, probably individual episode articles, and probably shortly after non-notability is determined. I just don't see a need to rush to judgement here. [[User:Warlordjohncarter|John Carter]] 20:24, 27 September 2007 (UTC)
:::*I don't think allowing non-notable plot summary articles to sit around unchallenged for six months is a "rush to judgment." [[User:Otto4711|Otto4711]] 22:33, 27 September 2007 (UTC)
::::Neither do I, and, in fact, I made no such statement. If that is the amount of time they have been "sitting around", however, I could agree that you might have been justified in starting the conversation. However, I believe with at least a few people, myself included, with any luck now engaging in at least some active work on the articles, I think it would be extremely presumptuous to assume that that much time would be required. And I could certainly agree to a potential renomination in a much shorter time if no action were taken in the interim. Actually, if that heppened, I'm fairly sure I'd support deletion myself. But I do think that perhaps a period of one or two months to work on all the articles invovled would not be necessarily onerous. [[User:Warlordjohncarter|John Carter]] 14:35, 28 September 2007 (UTC)
| |||