Requests for new languages/Wikipedia Sanaani: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
SharabSalam (talk | contribs) The proposal is the Sana'ani Arabic Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit |
SharabSalam (talk | contribs) →Discussion: Comment Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit |
||
Line 59:
* {{comment}} It is not true to separate the dialects from the original language because of the existence of extraneous vocabulary or the difference of the pronunciation system. The people of sanaa use the classical Arabic language in writing, creating a special language for them is a big mistake and will fail.[[User:Philip.SY|Philip.SY]] ([[User talk:Philip.SY|talk]])
* {{comment}} Well, this is the [[:en:Absurdism|Absurdism!]] and lamentable moment in the history of our WIKIMEDIA :( -- [[User:صالح|صالح]] ([[User talk:صالح|talk]]) 13:06, 4 July 2019 (UTC)
*'''Comment''' the person who made this proposal said :
: {{tq2|people in Yemen write as they talk so the proposal of Sanaani Wikipedia will be a gate of knowledge for people who can not write or speak Standard Arabic.}}
: Now that's utterly bullshit. People in Yemen write using MSA in newspapers, advertisements, TV and speak with the MSA in TV. I don't know how this proposal passed and in what ground this was passed as eligible and even after I explained and we agreed that this is still in the discussion phase someone came impolitely screaming in my talk page and reverting me.--[[User:SharabSalam|SharabSalam]] ([[User talk:SharabSalam|talk]]) 15:18, 4 July 2019 (UTC)
| |||