Grants talk:Project/Building up performing arts data in Wikidata: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
No edit summary |
|||
Line 133:
===Deliverables of the first project===
'''Feedback:'''
* “The set of items of the last year have not been uploaded as promised.”
* “Slightly inclined to "no" because the deliverables of last year seem to be less impactful as expected. Considering the planning to apply for a second round, I would have preferred to push more the work package of tests for uploading than the training sessions.”
'''Response:'''
In quantitative and qualitative terms, we reached and exceeded all our targets:
Line 154:
Our group has displayed an aptitude at quickly identifying challenges and at adapting to overcome these challenges and to deliver impact. We have also reported in a transparent manner on both our successes and challenges. We think these are qualities of strong project management. [[User:Fjjulien|Fjjulien]] ([[User talk:Fjjulien|talk]]) 16:18, 28 March 2021 (UTC)
=== Diversity ===
'''Feedback:'''
Line 181:
We are committed to undertaking these activities in ways that respect the rights of Indigenous peoples for self-determination and data sovereignty. This implies not imposing predetermined solutions and timelines to our Indigenous colleagues. Which, in turn, implies not making any promise to the Wikimedia Foundation in this project grant. [[User:Fjjulien|Fjjulien]] ([[User talk:Fjjulien|talk]]) 21:36, 28 March 2021 (UTC)
=== Evaluation plan ===
'''Comment:'''
Line 195:
[[User:Fjjulien|Fjjulien]] ([[User talk:Fjjulien|talk]]) 20:20, 28 March 2021 (UTC)
=== Wider Wikimedia community ===
'''Comment:'''
* “Has the potential to have an impact on the wider Wikimedia movement but there seems to be a limited focus on communicating with or advocating within the wider Wikimedia community.
Since the comments about the previous project suggest that it has been challenging to retain the workshop participants, would it be useful to create pathways for the existing editing community to become more aware of the issues around performing arts data?”
'''Response:'''
* We are already in touch with many Wikimedia affiliates: Wikimedia Sweden, Wikimedia UK, Wikimedia Belgium and, of course, Wikimedia Canada. Our current Wikidata experts who assist us with workshops, complex queries and batch uploads – [[User:Simon_Villeneuve|Simon Villeneuve]] and [[User:Dirac|Dirac]] – are from the wider Wikimedia movement and they were recommended by Wikimedia Canada.
* We have been increasingly using talk pages to facilitate and to document discussions (see this talk page for [[wikidata:Talk:Q105815710|Q105815710]]. We have also been using the project chat and the French bistro to notify the community and to seek input. We will continue to do so in the next project.
* We welcome suggestions from advisors on means to communicate with the wider Wikimedia community.
[[User:Fjjulien|Fjjulien]] ([[User talk:Fjjulien|talk]]) 21:36, 28 March 2021 (UTC)
=== Rationale for the proposed project ===
'''Comments:'''
* “The blocking problem is not clear. This year the project is based mainly on the uploading of items.”
* “It is unclear how this will be implemented to the extent that was proposed. If this can be clarified, it will be helpful.”
'''Response:'''
A response has been prepared and is being vetted by project partners.
=== Budget ===
'''Comments:'''
* “The budget is realistic but not sufficiently detailed.”
* “A question about the budget - is the associated costs only for the person-hours to achieve those activities outlined in the budget or do they cover other expenses?”
* “It is unclear if the other funding sources are proposed or already awarded. I would request this be clarified, along with more specific explanations for what the participants will do over the proposed time period.”
* “the budget has to provide more details about the activities to be funded.”
'''Response:'''
A response has been prepared and is being vetted by project partners.
=== Impact and scalability ===
'''Comments:'''
* “The potential impact is probably modest but risks are likely low taking into account the results of the previous grant.”
* “Not relevant impact except the creation of models in Wikidata. This is a second step while in my opinion the biggest one (training) has been already released.”
* “The project fits with Wikimedia's strategic priorities through its sustainability and scalability are less clear.”
'''Response:'''
A response will be provided soon.
| |||