|
[[sv:Wikipedia:Sidor som bör raderas]]
[[zh:Wikipedia:删除投票和请求]]====[[Government Warehouse]]====
By removing redundancy I can reduce the entire introduction into no more than three sentences which are a very plain description of "secret government warehouse", which is nearly fully explained just by it's adjectives. Thus, that definition does not belong in an encyclopedia as it is simply a definition that is only sufficient for a dictionary. And, it shouldn't even be in a dictionary. The following lists (which at the very least would make this only suitable for a List article) are simply a list of fictional items which have ever been in a "secret government warehouse" in any fiction. As a list, this seems very pointless and, indeed, useless. They are categorized by the government that owns the warehouse, and don't even show what film, literature, etc. they were in. - [[User:Centrx|Centrx]] 23:54, 28 May 2004 (UTC)
*Keep. This is well-written, encyclopedic and actually kind of fun. We're dreadfully short of fun yet topical articles. - [[User:Lucky 6.9|Lucky 6.9]] 00:52, 29 May 2004 (UTC)
* The artifacts listed need to reference whatever fictional work or conspiracy theory says they're being stored. It's flawed, but keep. Possibly list on [[Wikipedia:Unusual articles]]. -- [[User:Cyrius|Cyrius]]|[[User talk:Cyrius|✎]] 02:56, May 29, 2004 (UTC)
*Keep the current version. [[User:RickK|Rick]]'''[[User talk:RickK|K''']] 19:18, 29 May 2004 (UTC)
*Keep. [[User:Acegikmo1|Acegikmo1]] 19:29, 29 May 2004 (UTC)
*Delete; original research. Some (achem) enterprising soul has taken it upon themselves to copy the current contents (so to speak) from the two external links, both of which are lists of things that ''could'' be contained in a ''hypothetical'' fictional secret warehouse. This is basically a "list of neat stuff I think ought to be put together"; if it were listed as such, it would maybe be worth keeping, but as is it's not. Also, some of the things on this list seem to be competely made up (and by that I mean, created from the editor's imagination rather than drawn from any particular myth or work of fiction). If this article is for whatever goony reason kept, the list should be removed post-haste. -[[User:Gtrmp|Sean]] 22:40, 29 May 2004 (UTC)
*Delete, though I agree with [[User:Cyrius|Cyrius]]. The list is actually amusing and well-done. If would be amusing, well-done, ''and encyclopedic'' if and only if most items actually referenced the source that claims the item is stored in a secret government warehouse—as is currently done for the Ark of the Covenent and the Martian War Machine. At present, most of the links are bogus. Thus, the item on [[Jackalopes]] simply links to the article on Jackalopes, which says nothing about conspiracy theories or jackalopes being kept in a government warehouse. [[User:Dpbsmith|Dpbsmith]] 00:40, 30 May 2004 (UTC)
|
