Talk:Comparison of C Sharp and Java: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 05:38, 6 March 2006

Revision as of 05:34, 7 March 2006

Line 228:

*Tone: Most encyclopedias avoid direct comparisons of subjects, and for good reason. Rather than a prosaic discussion of fundamental differences, this page seems to provide large bulleted lists of features of dubious importance.

&mdash;<tt>[[User:donhalcon|donhalcon]]</tt>^{[[User talk:donhalcon|╤]]} 05:38, 6 March 2006 (UTC)

:*Advert: Does the page really have a C# bias? I think it is a neutral fact that C# has more features than Java. Whether or not more is better and whether the features are actually useful is left to the reader.

:*Importance: I'm willing to concede that the article contains no information not found in [[C Sharp]] or [[Java programming language]], but that's true of all comparison articles.

:*Tone: The article is more encylopedic than [[Comparison_of_browsers]], but that isn't setting the bar particularly high. It's substantially similar to [[Comparison of Java and C++]], which I see you've also marked for cleanup. I suppose we might look to [[Abrahamic religion]] as an alternative model.

:I think it might be a worthwhile experiment to convert parts of the article to prose. Maybe over the weekend if I have time. [[User:Tbjablin|Tbjablin]] 05:34, 7 March 2006 (UTC)