Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 04:07, 7 April 2006

Revision as of 05:13, 7 April 2006

Line 167:

=====Response to Jareth, Mailer Diablo, and Kirill Lokshin=====

If the committee elects to take up the grievances of this growing crowd of ochlocrats, I hope it pays careful attention to the entirely spurious RfC these three users framed. I would be ashamed of myself if I had let it change my behavior. The three of them insisted -- quite explicitly -- that Wikipedia's core policies of NPOV, NOR, and verifiability, were subordinate to consensus, and could be disregarded by agreement of editors. I think the response I gave then, at the link Lokshin provides, states my position as well as I would do now, and commend it to the committee's attention. The RfC itself is an outright cry of defiance against clearly established Wikipedia policies; it cites such mortal Wikisins as reporting an undisputed 3RR violation by another user and reporting a user (the same user) for violating the probation imposed by this committee. I am surprised they have come here at all; their complaints are more appropriately directed to a Committee on UnWikipedian Activities, since they propose ignoring Wikipedia's core policies and repressing disagreeing views, or perhaps to a comité de salut public. [[User:Monicasdude|Monicasdude]] 23:06, 6 April 2006 (UTC)

=====Response to [[User:TKE]]=====

I strongly believe that the statements made by TKE regarding the current state of the Afd process are grossly inaccurate. I therefore have reviewed roughly the last two dozen AfD nominations on which I voted keep, to see which view of the process is more accurate. There should be little doubt that the description I provide is more accurate than that presented by User:TKE:

[[The_Handsomest_Drowned_Man_in_the_World|The Handsomest Drowned Man In The World]]

Talk page activity: none

[[N._Namasivayam|N. Namasivayam]]

Talk page activity: none

[[Idar_Kreutzer|Idar Kreutzer]]

Talk page activity: none

[[Bernd_Sebastian_Kamps|Bernd Sebastian Kamps]]

Talk page activity: appropriate

[[AJ_Roach|AJ Roach]]

Talk page activity: none

[[Sean_Hood|Sean Hood]]

Talk page activity: none

Afd nom 3 minutes after last edit by initial author

[[Ben_myers|Ben myers]]

Talk page activity: none

Afd nom 1 minute after last edit by initial author

[[David_Haugh|David Haugh]]

Talk page activity: none

[[Chris_Skrebowski|Chris Skrebowski]]

Talk page activity: none

Initial prod 14 minutes after article creation

[[Bernard_Ramsey|Bernard Ramsey]]

Talk page activity:none

Initial prod 4 minutes after last edit by article creator

[[Prison_Planet|Prison Planet]]

Talk page activity: none relevant

Initial prod 12 minutes after article creation

[[Girl_Power%21_Live_In_Istanbul|Girl Power]]

Talk page activity: none

Initial prod 25 minutes after article creation

[[Robert_Colin_Boyd|Robert Colin Boyd]]

Talk page activity: none

[[Eire_Og|Eire Og]]

Talk page activity: none

[[Hamblen_Elementary_School_%28Spokane%2C_Washington%29|Hamblen Elementary School]]

Talk page activity: none

[[Emanuel_Wynn|Emanuel Wynn]]

Talk page activity: some

[[Lakeshore_catholic_highschool|Lakeshore Catholic High School]]

Talk page activity: none

[[Real_bills_doctrine|Real bills doctrine]]

Talk page activity: request for peer review, but not by nominator

[[Fred_Carama|Fred Carama]]

Talk page activity: none

Afd nomination 7 minutes after last edit by article creator, tagged as minor edit w/no mention of AfD

[[Insurance_hall_of_fame|Insurance hall of fame]]

Talk page activity: none

Prod 1 minute after last edit by article creator

[[Timothy_Kanold|Timothy Kanold]]

Talk page activity: none

[[Tari_Schreider|Tari Schreider]]

Talk page activity: none

Prod 3 minutes after article creation

[[Thomas_Bannister|Thomas Bannister]]

Talk page activity: none

Prod 3 minutes after article creation

[[Subbaraju_Raju_Gokaraju|Subbaraju Raju Gokaraju]]

Talk page activity: none

[[Rick_Telander|Rick Telander]]

Talk page activity: none

[[Kristen_Ghodsee|Kristen Ghodsee]]

Talk page activity: none (despite 2 prods)

[[Hikari_Hayashibara|Hikari Hayashibara]]

Talk page activity: none related to deletion

[[Ernest_Rides_Again|Ernest Rides Again]]

Talk page activity: none

Prod 7.5 hours after last edit by article creator

I would think it quite clear that the practices I cited, and that Jimmy Wales earlier criticized, remain substantially unchanged. [[User:Monicasdude|Monicasdude]] 05:13, 7 April 2006 (UTC)

==== Statement by [[User:JIP]] ====