Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ivy League business schools: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
GO WHARTON (talk | contribs) |
No edit summary |
||
Line 35:
:::*As I said above, I added the rankings information to make the article less POV. You might think that so diluting the POV you were conveying is tacky, but my point is that the article itself, and going through every linked b-school article and adding the phrase "it is one of the six Ivy League Business Schools" as you did is far tackier. [[User:MBAguy|MBAguy]] 18:48, 15 April 2006 (UTC)
::::*This article, before you arrived, had no POV, was neutral, and said nothing about rankings. It doesn't seem you added those rankings to achieve "less POV." You inserted the rankings stuff and your anti-Ivy POV into the article, after you nominated it. You should have left the article alone and let everyone vote the article on its own merits. But now voters have to vote on your junked-up POV version of the article. Congratulations, nice way to rig the vote. A voter earlier expressed hope for this article, partly because it wasn't defiled with rankings - but you quickly took care of that, didn't you? [[User:GO WHARTON|GO WHARTON]] 20:28, 15 April 2006 (UTC)
:::::*Please, you're embarassing yourself now. Having the article in the first place was the POV issue. What "anti-Ivy" POV are you referring to? That someone would have the audacity to list the rankings which show that Ivy League doesn't mean "best", thereby defeating your agenda in creating the article in the first place and linking to it from various pages? [[User:MBAguy|MBAguy]] 21:10, 15 April 2006 (UTC)
| |||