Jeff's old partner, Mark, offers Jeff a partnership, claiming even after four years at Greendale, Jeff is still a great lawyer. Jeff says he’ll consider it.
In the study room the group reveals to Jeff the party they planned to Jeff. Later Jeff applies for graduation, which causes him to agree to a small party. LaterThat night, Jeff meetsreveals withto Britta and reveals he is conflicted about leaving Greendale including what it maycould do to Abed. Back at Greendale, Jeff rolls a die to pick who brings soda to the party to rehash Abed’s delusion of timelines. The die doesn’t land on a number which Abed insists means nothing.
Back at Greendale, Jeff rolls a die to pick who brings soda to the party to bring out Abed’s delusions of timelines. The die doesn’t land on a number which Abed insists means nothing. After the die roll, Evil Jeff appears at Greendale. In order to push Jeff toward taking the new job, Evil Jeff sets out to alienate Jeff from the study group. He insults Annie. Annie later encounters Jeff and runs away upset. Abed walks into Evil Jeff and recognizes him as a doppelganger. Abed is shot with a paintball gun and sent to the dean’s office in the darkest timeline. Abed then goes to “his” apartment and meets his counterpartdoppelganger who is no longer evil. Evil Abed gives his counterpart supplies to defeat the doppelgangers.
Jeff goes to apologize to Annie, but unknowingly meets Evil Annie, who accepts and steals his phone. Evil Jeff goes on to insult the rest of the group. Jeff arrives at his ceremony and is surprised to find no one there. Evil Annie arrives with Jeff's phone and says that hethere hasis a message from Mark and that he should returncall theMark callback. When heJeff decides to go afterchooses his friends instead, Evil Jeff shows up to shoot him, but Chang takesdives in front theof paintballit.
Jeff arrivesgoes atto Troy and Abed's to explain what happened. Nobody believes him until Abed shows uparrives and shoots a “warp paintball gun.” The Evil Study Group arrives in the prime timeline and discus their plans until the prime study group shows up. The prime group each eliminates their doppelgangers. With only Evil Jeff leftremaining, Abed explains to Jeff these events are in his mind because he was anxious about his futuregraduation. Abed tells Jeff he is not the same guy as four years ago, but a better one who has the group as his family. Jeff then defeatsshoots Evil Jeff sending him back to the darkest timeline. The episode then reverts to the moment that Jeff decided to throw the die. He decides against tossing it.
Jeff’s graduation ceremony then takes place with the group (sans Pierce). Jeff gives a heartfelt speech about his time at Greendale. Pierce breaks into the ceremony so he can graduate first. At a dinner in the study room, Jeff announces he will search for work at a small firm and not take Mark’s offer so he can stay close to the group.
