Wikipedia

Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/GamerGate/Proposed decision: Difference between revisions

Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
Case closed
Line 1:
{{Casenav|case name=GamerGate|clerk1=Ks0stm|clerk2=Sphilbrick|draft arb=Roger Davies|draft arb2=Beeblebrox|active=14|inactive=5|recused=0}}
{{Casenav}}
 
Under no circumstances may this page be edited, except by members of the Arbitration Committee or the case Clerks. Please submit comment on the proposed decision to the [[{{TALKPAGENAME}}|talk page]].
Line 2,020:
==Motion to close==
===Implementation notes===
''Clerks and Arbitrators should use this section to clarify their understanding of the final decision—at a minimum, a list of items that have passed. Additionally, a list of which remedies are conditional on others (for instance a ban that should only be implemented if a mentorship should fail), and so on. Arbitrators should not pass the motion to close the case until they are satisfied with the implementation notes.''
{{ACImplNotes
|updated = <b>[[User:Callanecc|Callanecc]]</b> ([[User talk:Callanecc|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Callanecc|contribs]] • [[Special:Log/Callanecc|logs]]) 23:10, 28 January 2015 (UTC) <!--(replace after each update)-->
|principles =
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Purpose of Wikipedia |number=1 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Battlefield conduct |number=2 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Biographical content |number=3 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Administrators and BLPs |number=4 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Accuracy of sources |number=5 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Administrators and 'involvement' |number=6 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Single purpose accounts |number=7 |support=13 |oppose=1 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Decorum |number=8 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Conduct during arbitration cases |number=9 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Recidivism |number=10 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Enough is enough |number=11 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Neutral point of view |number=12 |support=12 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Harassment |number=13 |support=10 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Limitations of arbitration |number=14 |support=12 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
 
''These notes were last updated by <b>[[User:Callanecc|Callanecc]]</b> ([[User talk:Callanecc|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Callanecc|contribs]] • [[Special:Log/Callanecc|logs]]) 23:10, 28 January 2015 (UTC); the last edit to this page was on {{#time: H:i, j F Y "(UTC)"|{{REVISIONTIMESTAMP}}}} by [[User:{{REVISIONUSER}}]].''
|findings =
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Locus of the dispute |number=1 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=History of the dispute |number=2 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=DungeonSiegeAddict510 |number=3 |support=13 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Gamaliel |number=4 |support=7 |oppose=7 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=NorthBySouthBaranof |number=5 |support=11 |oppose=2 |abstain=1 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Ryulong |number=6 |support=4 |oppose=5 |abstain=0 |notes=<ref name=F6>As F6 is failing second choice votes on finding R6.1 have been counted and second choice votes on R6 have not been counted.</ref>}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Ryulong (alternate) |number=6.1 |support=12 |oppose=0 |abstain=2 |notes=<ref name=F6/>}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Tarc |number=7 |support=11 |oppose=1 |abstain=2 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=The Devil's Advocate |number=8 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=TheRedPenOfDoom |number=9 |support=12 |oppose=0 |abstain=1 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Titanium Dragon |number=10 |support=13 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Tutelary |number=11 |support=13 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=TaraInDC |number=12 |support=12 |oppose=1 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Parties topic-banned by the community
|number=13 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Loganmac |number=14 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Willhesucceed |number=15 |support=13 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Masem |number=16 |support=2 |oppose=11 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
 
{|class="wikitable" style="text-align:center !important;"
|remedies =
|-
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Discretionary sanctions |number=1.1 |support=14 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
!colspan="8" style="background:#FFFF99 !important;"|[[#Proposed principles|Proposed Principles]]
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Sanctions available |number=1.2 |support=12 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
|-
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Scope of standard topic ban (I) |number=2.1 |support=13 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=<ref name=R2>As R2.1 is passing, second choice votes have not been counted on 2.2.</ref>}}
!Number
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Scope of standard topic ban (II) |number=2.2 |support=3 |oppose=6 |abstain=0 |notes=<ref name=R2 />}}
!Proposal Name
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Gamaliel reminded |number=3 |support=6 |oppose=8 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
!Support
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=NorthBySouthBaranof topic-banned |number=4.1 |support=9 |oppose=3 |abstain=2 |notes=<ref name=R4 />}}
!Oppose
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=NorthBySouthBaranof admonished |number=4.2 |support=5 |oppose=1 |abstain=1 |notes=<ref name=R4>As R4.1 is passing, second choice votes on R4.2 have been counted in the total.</ref>}}
!Abstain
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Ryulong topic-banned |number=5.1 |support=9 |oppose=0 |abstain=1 |notes=See below}}
!Status
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Ryulong: other topics restriction |number=5.2 |support=1 |oppose=11 |abstain=0 |notes=See below}}
!Support needed
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Ryulong banned |number=5.3 |support=8 |oppose=4 |abstain=1 |notes=See below}}
!Notes
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Ryulong warned |number=5.4 |support=4 |oppose=4 |abstain=1 |notes=See below}}
|-
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Ryulong: 1RR |number=5.5 |support=5 |oppose=7 |abstain=0 |notes=See below}}
|-
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=TaraInDC topic-banned |number=6.1 |support=6 |oppose=6 |abstain=2 |notes=<ref name=R6>As R6.1 is failing, second choice votes for R6.2 have been counted.</ref>}}
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 1
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=TaraInDC admonished |number=6.2 |support=11 |oppose=2 |abstain=0 |notes=<ref name=R6 />}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Purpose of Wikipedia|Purpose of Wikipedia]]'''
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Tarc banned |number=7.1 |support=5 |oppose=10 |abstain=1 |notes=<ref name=R7>As R7.1 is failing Beeblebrox and David Fuch's second choice votes for R7.2 have been counted and their first choice on R7.1 have not. David Fuch's third choice vote on R7.3 has not been counted.</ref>}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Tarc topic-banned |number=7.2 |support=11 |oppose=2 |abstain=1 |notes=<ref name=R7 />}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Tarc warned |number=7.3 |support=8 |oppose=2 |abstain=2 |notes=<ref name=R7 />}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Tarc: 1RR |number=7.4 |support=5 |oppose=6 |abstain=3 |notes=}}
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=The Devil's Advocate banned |number=8.1 |support=2 |oppose=4 |abstain=1 |notes=<ref name=R8>Votes from R8.1 have been distributed as it is not currently passing (Beeblebrox & Euryalus). T. Canens' conditional vote on R8.1 has not been counted.</ref>}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=The Devil's Advocate topic-banned |number=8.2 |support=13 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=<ref name=R8/>}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=The Devil's Advocate: 1RR |number=8.3 |support=10 |oppose=1 |abstain=0 |notes=<ref name=R8/>}}
|-
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=The Devil's Advocate: Noticeboards |number=8.4 |support=10 |oppose=1 |abstain=0 |notes=<ref name=R8/>}}
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 2
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=The Devil's Advocate warned |number=8.5 |support=8 |oppose=3 |abstain=1 |notes=<ref name=R8/>}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Battlefield conduct|Battlefield conduct]]'''
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=TheRedPenOfDoom admonished |number=9 |support=10 |oppose=4 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Tutelary topic-banned |number=10.1|support=13 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=<ref name=R10>David Fuchs' and Guerillero's second choice votes on 10.2 have not been counted, their first choice votes on R10.1 have.</ref>}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Tutelary banned |number=10.2|support=0 |oppose=11 |abstain=0 |notes=<ref name=R10 />}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Editors focused primarily on Gamergate with agendas
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
|number=11 |support=7 |oppose=7 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=ArmyLine, DungeonSiegeAddict510, and Xander756 topic-banned
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|number=12 |support=12 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
|-
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Titanium Dragon topic-banned |number=13 |support=12 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 3
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Loganmac topic-banned |number=14.1|support=12 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Biographical content|Biographical content]]'''
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Loganmac banned |number=14.2|support=0 |oppose=9 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Willhesucceed topic-banned |number=15 |support=11 |oppose=0 |abstain=1 |notes=}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Masem topic-banned |number=16 |support=2 |oppose=10 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=DungeonSiegeAddict510 banned |number=17 |support=5 |oppose=9 |abstain=0 |notes=}}
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Review of articles urged |number=18 |support=12 |oppose=0 |abstain=2 |notes=}}
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 4
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Administrators and BLPs|Administrators and BLPs]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 5
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Accuracy of sources|Accuracy of sources]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 6
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Administrators and 'involvement'|Administrators and 'involvement']]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 7
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Single purpose accounts|Single purpose accounts]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 13
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 8
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Decorum|Decorum]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 9
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Conduct during arbitration cases|Conduct during arbitration cases]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 10
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Recidivism|Recidivism]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 11
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Enough is enough|Enough is enough]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Neutral point of view|Neutral point of view]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 13
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Harassment|Harassment]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 10
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Limitations of arbitration|Limitations of arbitration]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
!colspan="8" style="background:#FFFF99 !important;"|[[#Proposed findings of fact|Proposed Findings of Fact]]
|-
!Number
!Proposal Name
!Support
!Oppose
!Abstain
!Status
!Support needed
!Notes
|-
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Locus of the dispute|Locus of the dispute]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#History of the dispute|History of the dispute]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 3
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#DungeonSiegeAddict510|DungeonSiegeAddict510]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 13
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 4
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Gamaliel|Gamaliel]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 7
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 7
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 5
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#NorthBySouthBaranof|NorthBySouthBaranof]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 11
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 6
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Ryulong|Ryulong]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 4
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 5
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 4
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} <ref name=F6>As F6 is failing second choice votes on finding R6.1 have been counted and second choice votes on R6 have not been counted.</ref>
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 6.1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Ryulong (alternate)|Ryulong (alternate)]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} <ref name=F6/>
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 7
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Tarc|Tarc]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 11
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 8
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#The Devil's Advocate|The Devil's Advocate]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 9
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#TheRedPenOfDoom|TheRedPenOfDoom]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 10
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Titanium Dragon|Titanium Dragon]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 13
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 11
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Tutelary|Tutelary]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 13
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#TaraInDC|TaraInDC]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 13
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Parties topic-banned by the community|Parties topic-banned by the community]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Loganmac|Loganmac]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 15
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Willhesucceed|Willhesucceed]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 13
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 16
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Masem|Masem]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 11
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}}
|-
!colspan="8" style="background:#FFFF99 !important;"|[[#Proposed remedies|Proposed Remedies]]
|-
!Number
!Proposal Name
!Support
!Oppose
!Abstain
!Status
!Support needed
!Notes
|-
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 1.1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Discretionary sanctions|Discretionary sanctions]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 14
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 1.2
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Sanctions available|Sanctions available]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 2.1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Scope of standard topic ban (I)|Scope of standard topic ban (I)]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 13
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} <ref name=R2>As R2.1 is passing, second choice votes have not been counted on 2.2.</ref>
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 2.2
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Scope of standard topic ban (II)|Scope of standard topic ban (II)]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 3
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 6
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 5
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} <ref name=R2 />
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 3
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Gamaliel reminded|Gamaliel reminded]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 6
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 8
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 4.1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#NorthBySouthBaranof topic-banned|NorthBySouthBaranof topic-banned]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 9
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 3
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} <ref name=R4 />
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 4.2
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#NorthBySouthBaranof admonished|NorthBySouthBaranof admonished]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 5
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} <ref name=R4>As R4.1 is passing, second choice votes on R4.2 have been counted in the total.</ref>
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 5.1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Ryulong topic-banned|Ryulong topic-banned]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 9
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} See below
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 5.2
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Ryulong: other topics restriction|Ryulong: other topics restriction]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 11
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} See below
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 5.3
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Ryulong banned|Ryulong banned]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 8
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 4
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} See below
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 5.4
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Ryulong warned|Ryulong warned]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 4
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 4
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 3
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} See below
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 5.5
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Ryulong: 1RR|Ryulong: 1RR]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 5
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 7
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} See below
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 6.1
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#TaraInDC topic-banned|TaraInDC topic-banned]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 6
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 6
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} <ref name=R6>As R6.1 is failing, second choice votes for R6.2 have been counted.</ref>
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 6.2
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#TaraInDC admonished|TaraInDC admonished]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 11
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} <ref name=R6 />
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 7.1
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Tarc banned|Tarc banned]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 5
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 10
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} <ref name=R7>As R7.1 is failing Beeblebrox and David Fuch's second choice votes for R7.2 have been counted and their first choice on R7.1 have not. David Fuch's third choice vote on R7.3 has not been counted.</ref>
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 7.2
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Tarc topic-banned|Tarc topic-banned]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 11
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} <ref name=R7 />
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 7.3
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Tarc warned|Tarc warned]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 8
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} <ref name=R7 />
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 7.4
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Tarc: 1RR|Tarc: 1RR]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 5
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 6
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 3
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 8.1
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#The Devil's Advocate banned|The Devil's Advocate banned]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 4
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 5
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} <ref name=R8>Votes from R8.1 have been distributed as it is not currently passing (Beeblebrox & Euryalus). T. Canens' conditional vote on R8.1 has not been counted.</ref>
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 8.2
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#The Devil's Advocate topic-banned|The Devil's Advocate topic-banned]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 13
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} <ref name=R8/>
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 8.3
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#The Devil's Advocate: 1RR|The Devil's Advocate: 1RR]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 10
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} <ref name=R8/>
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 8.4
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#The Devil's Advocate: Noticeboards|The Devil's Advocate: Noticeboards]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 10
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} <ref name=R8/>
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 8.5
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#The Devil's Advocate warned|The Devil's Advocate warned]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 8
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 3
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} <ref name=R8/>
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 9
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#TheRedPenOfDoom admonished|TheRedPenOfDoom admonished]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 10
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 4
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 10.1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Tutelary topic-banned|Tutelary topic-banned]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 13
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} <ref name=R10>David Fuchs' and Guerillero's second choice votes on 10.2 have not been counted, their first choice votes on R10.1 have.</ref>
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 10.2
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Tutelary banned|Tutelary banned]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 11
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} <ref name=R10 />
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 11
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Editors focused primarily on Gamergate with agendas|Editors focused primarily on Gamergate with agendas]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 7
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 7
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#ArmyLine, DungeonSiegeAddict510, and Xander756 topic-banned|ArmyLine, DungeonSiegeAddict510, and Xander756 topic-banned]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 13
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Titanium Dragon topic-banned|Titanium Dragon topic-banned]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 14.1
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Loganmac topic-banned|Loganmac topic-banned]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 14.2
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Loganmac banned|Loganmac banned]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 9
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 15
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Willhesucceed topic-banned|Willhesucceed topic-banned]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 11
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 1
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 16
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#Masem topic-banned|Masem topic-banned]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 10
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#FDEDED !important;" {{!}} 17
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} [[#DungeonSiegeAddict510 banned|DungeonSiegeAddict510 banned]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 5
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 9
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#FFCCCC" {{!}} [[Image:Symbol delete vote darkened.svg|20px|alt=NOT PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}} Cannot pass
| bgcolor="#FDEDED" {{!}}
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 18
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Review of articles urged|Review of articles urged]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 12
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 2
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''·'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}}
|-
!colspan="8" style="background:#FFFF99 !important;"|[[#Proposed enforcement|Proposed Enforcement Provisions]]
|-
!Number
!Proposal Name
!Support
!Oppose
!Abstain
!Status
!Support needed
!Notes
|-
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Enforcement of restrictions|Enforcement of restrictions]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 8
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} Passes by default
|-
! style="background:#E9FEE9 !important;" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} '''[[#Appeals and modifications|Appeals and modifications]]'''
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 0
| bgcolor="#CCFFCC" {{!}} [[File:Artículo bueno.svg|20px|alt=PASSING|link=]]
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} 8
| bgcolor="#E9FEE9" {{!}} Passes by default
|}
 
;Notes
|enforcement =
<references/>
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Enforcement of restrictions |number=0 |support=0 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |pass=pass |notes=Passes by default}}
{{ACImplNotes/Proposal|name=Appeals and modifications |number=0 |support=0 |oppose=0 |abstain=0 |pass=pass |notes=Passes by default}}
 
}}
 
{{cot|Ryulong remedy calculation}}
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/GamerGate/Proposed_decision"