Talk:Võ Nguyên Giáp: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
Kingbotk (talk | contribs)
Tag with {{WPBiography}} for WP1.0 assessments/Living persons bio
Is this really a biography of Giap?
Line 54:
 
This article seems to have a bias that is in some ways antagonistic toward the Vietminh, and in particular the government of Vietnam that in the time of the Vietnam War was called the Viet Cong. I think that this article needs to be thoroughly vetted for bias. While not an expert about Vietnam from 1940 - 1975 I have studied the period at undergraduate level, and there seems to be a distinct bias in the selection of source material, if not a particuarly overt bias by its authors.
 
== Is this really a biography of Giap? ==
 
I came here to find out about the man, but what I actually found was more of a history of the Vietnamese wars and politics that Giap was a part of — not a specific biography of the man himself. [[User:Joe Descartes|Joe Descartes]] 19:26, 7 October 2006 (UTC)