Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2019/Candidates/Fish and karate/Questions: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
→Questions from Joe Roe: replies |
→Question from Gerda: reply to Gerda |
||
Line 39:
#{{ACE Question
|Q=Same case, same thread, we had some facts open, and I looked, and found them unclear: subheader {{diff|Wikipedia talk:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Fram/Proposed decision|915429372|915426570|LouisAlain}}. Imagine you had been an arb, what would you have written in reply?
|A=I do not consider Fram's interactions with LouisAlain to be at all a reasonable justification for what happened, Fram was brusque and too quick to label edits he doesn't feel were helpful as "vandalism" - a bugbear of mine and something I see a lot at [[WP:RFPP|RFPP]], for example - but that in and of itself would not warrant anything more than what seemed to happen, which was a reminder to Fram to be more civil and calm. Again, without all the facts, I can't speculate on whether anything more than this occurred behind the scenes.}}
===Question from Calidum===
#{{ACE Question
| |||