Content deleted Content added
→Trino vs Presto: Reply |
Brianolsen2 (talk | contribs) |
||
Line 143:
I have redirected [[Trino (SQL query engine)]] to [[Presto (SQL query engine)]] (see [[Special:Diff/1047289450/1047617762|diff]] to avoid a [[WP:CONTENTFORK]]. The new Trino article was started as a fork of this one, and it just added even more confusion about Presto and Trino. I think it would be better to improve this article, in particular the History section, and discuss in this talk page how the content about Presto and Trino should be split. [[User:MarioGom|MarioGom]] ([[User talk:MarioGom|talk]]) 10:55, 3 October 2021 (UTC)
-----
Hi {{u|MarioGom}}.
Thanks for clearing up the way to go about this and I apologize for doing so outside of the Wikipedia policies. I still a little new and figuring out the right way to go about this.
Line 158 ⟶ 160:
:Hi {{u|Brianolsen2}}: First of all, I left a message in [[User talk:Brianolsen2|your talk page]] about paid editing requirements. Note that you can propose changes, and discuss them in the talk page like any other editor. You should generally avoid making these changes directly.{{pb}}
:I'm aware of the Trino/Presto dispute, as well as the Jenkins/Hudson one. Thank you for bringing that example up. My main issue with the [[Special:Permalink/1047289450|version of the Trino article]] you created initially is that it felt like retroactively rewriting history, as well as copying content in a way that both articles offered parallel realities.{{pb}}
:We should start with what [[Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources]] say about the topic. Is there any reliable source that says that Trino is the original Presto, and that the current Presto is a fork of the original Presto? Or any similar claim? How is the naming dispute and fork described by such sources? [[User:MarioGom|MarioGom]] ([[User talk:MarioGom|talk]]) 17:44, 7 October 2021 (UTC)
Hi {{u|MarioGom}}, It's been a while. I wanted to follow up on a few questions.
My first question is, should the CEO of Ahana {{u|StevenMih88}} be able to [[Special:Diff/1102559891/1084776295|make edits on the Presto page]] since there is a clear conflict of interest as there was with my case?
Also, I wanted to know if we provide [[Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources]], would I be able to ask for your help to create a small initial Trino software page to at least distinguish between the two forks of the software? I'm curious to know if [https://trino.io/blog/2020/12/27/announcing-trino.html this blog created by the founders of both Trino and Presto] would be enough to validate the story behind the project split. These sources are reliable as they are the founders of the project as can be seen by the GitHub contribution graphs for both [https://github.com/trinodb/trino/graphs/contributors Trino] and [https://github.com/prestodb/presto/graphs/contributors Presto]. Martin (martint), Dain(dain), and David (electrum) are in the top 4 contributors and have the longest history in both repositories. They are responsible for creating both the original project and the Trino fork. Would accounts from them be good enough to establish that Trino is a reputable fork and would you be willing to make a separate page so that it clearly distinguishes between the two projects?
Would it also be possible for us to list these forks [[Wikipedia:List_of_software_forks | on this List of Software Forks Wikipedia page]]?
Thanks for all the help {{u|MarioGom}}!
| |||