Content deleted Content added
MalnadachBot (talk | contribs) m Fixed Lint errors. (Task 12) |
SMcCandlish (talk | contribs) |
||
Line 54:
:Where it is impractical to rearrange a name into a last/first pair, the {{para|author}} parameter (and its numbered siblings) may be used. --[[User:Redrose64|<span style="color:#a80000; background:#ffeeee; text-decoration:inherit">Red</span>rose64]] ([[User talk:Redrose64|talk]]) 07:59, 25 May 2014 (UTC)
::{{U|Redrose64}} I was perhaps too verbose; I object to instructing editors to put unnecessary titles in any field at all. If required, I think the documentation should instruct editors to put courtesy titles such as "Rev." in {{para|first}} and suffixes in {{para|last}}. Your comment didn't address the issues I was trying to raise; however, your comment would make an ''excellent'' addition to the documentation, just as you have written it. Thanks.—[[User:D'Ranged 1|<span style="color:#FF6600;">'''D'Ranged 1'''</span>]] [[User talk:D'Ranged 1|<span style="color:#660000;"><sup>'''VTalk'''</sup></span>]] 00:46, 26 May 2014 (UTC)
::What is an example of "Where it is impractical to rearrange a name into a last/first pair"? And how can we encapsulate such examples into an exception or otherwise specific instruction? When it comes to things like "Jr[.]" and "III", these go at the end of {{para|first}} since they are not part of the surname and putting them in {{para|last}} will both pollute the surname data and mess with by-surname sorting. There is nothing complicated or confusing about {{para|last|Chen}}{{para|first|Jaime C. Jr.}} We're doing this thousands and thousands of times (though, yes, there still mangled instances like {{para|last|Chen Jr.}}{{para|first|Jaime C.}} or {{para|author|Chen, Jr., Jaime C.}} or {{para|author|Chen, Jaime C., Jr.}} to still clean up). <span style="white-space:nowrap;font-family:'Trebuchet MS'"> — [[User:SMcCandlish|'''SMcCandlish''']] [[User talk:SMcCandlish|☏]] [[Special:Contributions/SMcCandlish|¢]] 😼 </span> 04:14, 25 October 2023 (UTC)
== Abuse of the "last"/"author" parameter for last-first name pairs ==
{{para|last}} and its alias {{para|author}} are not for full lastname-firstname[s] sets. They are the last name (surname, family name), or can be used for an organizational editor (e.g. a committee), or a mononymic author (like Madonna or James I). Putting full "First Last" or "Last, First" human name sets in there is directly polluting (blatantly lying about) the nature of the data in the parameter, and undermines the whole point of providing COinS metadata in the first place. (In particular, we are emitting <code>rft.aulast</code> metadata for this parameter, which claims that the data in the parameter is the author's last name. When the author only has one name, being mononymic or an organizational entity, this is not misleading, but when it's somethinge like "Chen, Jaime C." it is a patent falsehood, for no defensible reason, and it harms [[WP:REUSE]] of our material as well as parsing, e.g. by bibliographic software, by our more technically/academically inclined readers.)
What we have now in [[Template:Citation Style documentation/author]] is:
{{tqb|1='''author''': this parameter is used to hold the complete name of a single author (first and last) or to hold the name of a corporate author. This parameter should never hold the names of more than one author.}}
I sensibly changed this to:
{{tqb|1='''author''': this parameter is used to hold the complete name of an organizational author (e.g. a committee). This parameter should never hold the names of more than one author. Use to hold first and last names of an individual author is deprecated.}}
But I got reverted by Nikkimaria. (Reglardless of the rest of this discussion, "corporate" should be changed, since this doesn't have anything to do with corporations in particular, and people keep mistaking this for an instruction to repeat the {{para|publisher}} as the {{para|author}}, or even put the company name in {{para|author}} {{em|instead}} of in {{para|publisher}}, both of which practices are obviously incorrect; I've had a to fix about a dozen instances of this stuff today alone).
We also relatedly have:
{{tqb|1='''authors''': Free-form list of author names; use of this parameter is discouraged because it does not contribute to a citation's metadata; not an alias of '''last'''.}}
Trappist the monk changed this to:
{{tqb|1='''{{xtd|authors}}''': deprecated <s>Free-form list of author names; use of this parameter is discouraged because it does not contribute to a citation's metadata; not an alias of '''last'''.</s>}}
but was again reverted by Nikkimaria.
Arguably it should have been:
{{tqb|1='''{{xtd|authors}}''': deprecated <s>Free-form list of author names</s>; use of this parameter is discouraged because it does not contribute to a citation's metadata; not an alias of '''last'''.}}
since that provides one of the deprecation reasons, and the closing statement remains correct.
I think both of these changes should be put back in, because they actually reflect best practices, both in theory and in action. The parameters is this template are for rather specialized/specific purposes, and abusing them (out of, frankly, laziness about using multiple parameters properly) does harm to the data they emit, makes for confusing markup for editors, does nothing whatsoever to help readers, and is simply not how these templates are in practice used by the vast majority of our editors. For over a decade, I have been correcting such misuses of these template parameters (especiall {{para|last}} and {{para|author}} being abused for full human names; {{para|authors}} is rare). I've done this many thousands of instances (mostly very old ones dating from before the templates were so well-developed, and in some cases injected by tools that have since been re-coded to do better markup, though there is a small handful of editors who manually keep abusing the template parameters out of bad habit), and I've never been reverted on one these corrections, ever, even once. It's time that the documentation made better sense, and stopped including misguiding wording that results in a massive waste of editorial cleanup time. <span style="white-space:nowrap;font-family:'Trebuchet MS'"> — [[User:SMcCandlish|'''SMcCandlish''']] [[User talk:SMcCandlish|☏]] [[Special:Contributions/SMcCandlish|¢]] 😼 </span> 04:14, 25 October 2023 (UTC)
I have faith that this can be accomplished, since we've made substantial progress already on the confusion between {{para|publisher}} and {{para|work}} (or its aliases like {{para|website}}, {{para|newspaper}}, {{para|magazine}}, etc.). Mike Novikoff and I tried to resolve that issue [[User talk:Nikkimaria/Archive 43#%7B%7BCite web%7D%7D documentation|back in May of last year]] only to be reverted by Nikkimaria again, but the wording of the {{para|publisher}} entry at [[Template:Citation Style documentation/publisher]] today now does in fact address the issue very clearly, and I don't see anything at entries like {{para|website}} in [[Template:Citation Style documentation/web]], or {{para|work}} at [[Template:Citation Style documentation/work]], that any longer work against this clarity. If we can fix that problem, we can fix this one, too.<br /><span style="white-space:nowrap;font-family:'Trebuchet MS'"> — [[User:SMcCandlish|'''SMcCandlish''']] [[User talk:SMcCandlish|☏]] [[Special:Contributions/SMcCandlish|¢]] 😼 </span> 04:14, 25 October 2023 (UTC)
| |||