Brouwer fixed-point theorem: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
m Add the "You can't comb a hairy ball smooth" version. Speaking of smoothing, the wording could probably be smoothed...
No edit summary
Line 9:
A full proof of the theorem would be too long to reproduce here, but the following paragraph outlines a proof omitting the difficult part. It is hoped that this will at least give some idea why the theorem might be expected to be true. Note that the boundary of ''D''<sup>&nbsp;''n''</sup> is ''S''<sup>&nbsp;''n''<tt>-</tt>1</sup>, the (''n''<tt>-</tt>1)-[[sphere]].
 
Suppose ''f''&nbsp;:&nbsp;''D''<sup>&nbsp;''n''</sup>&nbsp;<tt>-<math> \rightarrow </math></tt>&nbsp;''D''<sup>&nbsp;''n''</sup> is a continuous function that has no fixed point. The idea is to show that this leads to a contradiction. For each ''x'' in ''D''<sup>&nbsp;''n''</sup>, consider the straight line that passes through ''f''(''x'') and ''x''. There is only one such line, because ''f''(''x'') &ne; ''x''. Following this line from ''f''(''x'') through ''x'' leads to a point on ''S''<sup>&nbsp;''n''<tt>-</tt>1</sup>. Call this point ''g''(''x''). This gives us a continuous function ''g''&nbsp;:&nbsp;''D''<sup>&nbsp;''n''</sup>&nbsp;<tt>-></tt>&nbsp;''S''<sup>&nbsp;''n''<tt>-</tt>1</sup>. This is a special type of continuous function known as a retraction: every point of the [[codomain]] (in this case ''S''<sup>&nbsp;''n''<tt>-</tt>1</sup>) is a fixed point of the function.
 
Intuitively it seems unlikely that there could be a retraction of ''D''<sup>&nbsp;''n''</sup> onto ''S''<sup>&nbsp;''n''<tt>-</tt>1</sup>, and in the case ''n'' = 1 it is obviously impossible because ''S''<sup>&nbsp;0</sup> isn't even connected. The case ''n''=2 takes more thought, but can be proven by using basic arguments involving the [[fundamental group]]s. For ''n'' > 2, however, proving the impossibility of the retraction is considerably more difficult. One way is to make use of [[homology group|homology groups]]: it can be shown that ''H''<sub>''n''<tt>-</tt>1</sub>(''D''<sup>&nbsp;''n''</sup>) is trivial while ''H''<sub>''n''<tt>-</tt>1</sub>(''S''<sup>&nbsp;''n''<tt>-</tt>1</sup>) is infinite [[cyclic group|cyclic]]. This shows that the retraction is impossible, because a retraction cannot increase the size of homology groups.