Reversible programming language: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
merged duplicate references
merged duplicate references
Line 3:
== Core concepts and design principles ==
 
The fundamental goal of a reversible programming language is to support computation that is deterministic in both the forward and backward directions. <ref name="Glück-2022.06.010">{{cite journal
| last1 = Glück
| first1 = Robert
Line 19:
<!-- bibsource: dblp computer science bibliography, https://dblp.org -->
<!-- timestamp: Mon, 03 Mar 2025 22:24:24 +0100 -->
}}</ref> This is typically achieved by ensuring that every primitive operation and composite statement within the language is locally invertible. <ref name="Glück-2022.06.010"/>{{cite journalLocal invertibility means that each basic computational step has a well-defined inverse, and the inverse of a sequence of steps is the sequence of inverse steps performed in reverse order.
| last1 = Glück
| first1 = Robert
| last2 = Yokoyama
| first2 = Tetsuo
| title = Reversible computing from a programming language perspective
| journal = Theoretical Computer Science
| volume = 953
| article-number = 113429
| year = 2023
| doi = 10.1016/j.tcs.2022.06.010
| url = https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tcs.2022.06.010
<!-- bibtex source: DBLP:journals/tcs/GluckY23 -->
<!-- biburl: https://dblp.org/rec/journals/tcs/GluckY23.bib -->
<!-- bibsource: dblp computer science bibliography, https://dblp.org -->
<!-- timestamp: Mon, 03 Mar 2025 22:24:24 +0100 -->
}}</ref> Local invertibility means that each basic computational step has a well-defined inverse, and the inverse of a sequence of steps is the sequence of inverse steps performed in reverse order.
 
Key in the design of many reversible languages is cleanliness or garbage-free computation.<ref>{{cite arXiv
Line 75 ⟶ 59:
To achieve local invertibility and cleanliness, reversible languages typically incorporate several features:
 
* '''Reversible Updates:''' Standard assignment statements (<code>x = expression</code>) are inherently irreversible because they overwrite and erase the previous value of x. Reversible languages replace these with reversible updates, often denoted using operators like <code>+=</code>, <code>-=</code>, <code>^=</code> (bitwise XOR).<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007">{{cite conference
| last1 = Yokoyama
| first1 = Tetsuo
Line 94 ⟶ 78:
<!-- bibsource: dblp computer science bibliography, https://dblp.org -->
<!-- timestamp: Mon, 03 Mar 2025 21:37:52 +0100 -->
}}</ref> An important restriction is that the variable being updated (e.g., x in <code>x += e</code>) must not appear in the expression on the right-hand side (e) to ensure the operation is bijective.<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/> The swap operation (<code>x <=> y</code>), which exchanges the values of two variables, is another fundamental reversible update.<ref name="Choudhury">{{cite web
| last1 = Choudhury
| first1 = Vikraman
Line 103 ⟶ 87:
<!-- If it were for a specific institution, you could add: |institution=... -->
}}</ref>
* '''Reversible Control Flow:''' Conventional control flow structures like [[If-then-else]] and [[While loop]]s merge computational paths, making them irreversible. Reversible languages introduce specialized constructs. Conditionals often require both a test condition (evaluated on entry) and an assertion (a predicate that must hold true on exit from one branch and false on exit from the other).<ref name="Palazzo-2501.05259">{{cite arXiv
| last1 = Palazzo
| first1 = Matteo
Line 115 ⟶ 99:
<!-- timestamp: Wed, 19 Feb 2025 21:19:08 +0100 -->
| class = cs.PL
}}</ref> Similarly, loops might require entry assertions and exit tests.<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/> These additional predicates store the necessary information to determine the execution path uniquely during backward execution, where the roles of tests and assertions are typically swapped.<ref name="Palazzo-2501.05259"/>{{cite arXivThis explicit management of control flow information is a significant difference from conventional programming.
| last1 = Palazzo
| first1 = Matteo
| last2 = Roversi
| first2 = Luca
| title = Reversible Computation with Stacks and "Reversible Management of Failures"
| eprint = 2501.05259
| year = 2025
<!-- biburl: https://dblp.org/rec/journals/corr/abs-2501-05259.bib -->
<!-- bibsource: dblp computer science bibliography, https://dblp.org -->
<!-- timestamp: Wed, 19 Feb 2025 21:19:08 +0100 -->
| class = cs.PL
}}</ref> This explicit management of control flow information is a significant difference from conventional programming.
* '''Procedure Calls:''' Languages need mechanisms to invoke procedures both forwards and backwards. This is often achieved through paired commands like <code>call</code> (forward execution) and <code>uncall</code> or <code>rcall</code> (backward execution).<ref name="Choudhury"/>
* '''Data Structures:''' Early reversible languages often restricted data types to simple ones like integers and fixed-size arrays.<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/> Handling dynamic data structures like stacks requires careful semantic design to maintain reversibility, such as assuming variables are zero-cleared before being pushed onto a stack, ensuring <code>pop</code> can perfectly reverse <code>push</code>.<ref name="Choudhury"/> More recent research has explored reversible object-oriented features, including user-defined types, inheritance, and polymorphism.<ref>{{cite conference
| last1 = Haulund
| first1 = Tue
Line 158 ⟶ 130:
== Janus Language ==
 
[[Janus (time-reversible computing programming language)|Janus]] is widely recognized as the first structured, imperative programming language designed explicitly for reversible computation.<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/> Originally conceived by Christopher Lutz and Howard Derby at [[Caltech]] in the 1980s,<ref name="Choudhury"/> it was later rediscovered, formalized, and extended, notably by Tetsuo Yokoyama and Robert Glück.<ref name="Choudhury"/>
 
===Design philosophy===
Line 165 ⟶ 137:
===Syntax and semantics===
* ''Program Structure:'' A Janus program consists of global variable declarations followed by procedure declarations. The execution starts at a procedure named <code>main</code>, or the last procedure defined if <code>main</code> is absent.
* ''Data Types:'' Janus primarily uses 32-bit integers (interpreters may differ on signed vs. unsigned) and one-dimensional integer arrays of fixed size.<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/> Some versions include stacks.<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/> All variables and array elements are initialized to zero.<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/>
* ''Statements:''
** '''Assignment:''' Reversible updates <code>x op= e</code> or <code>x[e] op= e</code>, where <code>op</code> is <code>+</code>, <code>-</code>, or <code>^</code> (bitwise XOR). The variable <code>x</code> must not appear in the expression <code>e</code>.<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/>
** '''Swap:''' <code>x <=> y</code> exchanges the values of <code>x</code> and <code>y</code>.
** '''Conditional:''' <code>if e1 then s1 else s2 fi e2</code>. The expression <code>e1</code> is the test evaluated upon forward entry. The expression <code>e2</code> is an assertion evaluated upon forward exit; it must be true if <code>s1</code> was executed and false if <code>s2</code> was executed. For backward execution (e.g., via <code>uncall</code>), <code>e2</code> acts as the test to determine which inverse branch (s1<sup>−1</sup> or s2<sup>−1</sup>) to take, and <code>e1</code> becomes the assertion checked upon exiting backward.<ref>{{cite arXivname="Palazzo-2501.05259"/>
** '''Loop:''' <code>from e1 do s1 loop s2 until e2</code>. Upon forward entry, assertion <code>e1</code> must be true. <code>s1</code> is executed. Then, test <code>e2</code> is evaluated. If true, the loop terminates. If false, <code>s2</code> is executed, after which assertion <code>e1</code> must now be false for the loop to continue back to <code>s1</code>. In reverse, <code>e2</code> is the entry assertion, s2<sup>−1</sup> is executed, <code>e1</code> is the test (loop continues if false, terminates if true), and s1<sup>−1</sup> is executed if the loop continues.<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/>
| last1 = Palazzo
** '''Stack Operations:''' <code>push(x, stack)</code> and <code>pop(x, stack)</code>. Reversibility often relies on assumptions about the state of <code>x</code> (e.g., <code>x</code> must be 0 before <code>push</code> so <code>pop</code> can restore it).<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/>** '''Local Variables:''' <code>local t x = e in s delocal t x = e</code> This block introduces a local variable <code>x</code>, initializes it reversibly using <code>e</code>, executes <code>s</code>, and then uncomputes <code>x</code> back to its initial state (usually 0) using the inverse of <code>e</code> upon exit.<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/>
| first1 = Matteo
| last2 = Roversi
| first2 = Luca
| title = Reversible Computation with Stacks and "Reversible Management of Failures"
| eprint = 2501.05259
| year = 2025
<!-- biburl: https://dblp.org/rec/journals/corr/abs-2501-05259.bib -->
<!-- bibsource: dblp computer science bibliography, https://dblp.org -->
<!-- timestamp: Wed, 19 Feb 2025 21:19:08 +0100 -->
| class = cs.PL
}}</ref>
** '''Loop:''' <code>from e1 do s1 loop s2 until e2</code>. Upon forward entry, assertion <code>e1</code> must be true. <code>s1</code> is executed. Then, test <code>e2</code> is evaluated. If true, the loop terminates. If false, <code>s2</code> is executed, after which assertion <code>e1</code> must now be false for the loop to continue back to <code>s1</code>. In reverse, <code>e2</code> is the entry assertion, s2<sup>−1</sup> is executed, <code>e1</code> is the test (loop continues if false, terminates if true), and s1<sup>−1</sup> is executed if the loop continues.<ref name="Yokoyama-71-81"/>
** '''Stack Operations:''' <code>push(x, stack)</code> and <code>pop(x, stack)</code>. Reversibility often relies on assumptions about the state of <code>x</code> (e.g., <code>x</code> must be 0 before <code>push</code> so <code>pop</code> can restore it).<ref name="Yokoyama-71-81"/>** '''Local Variables:''' <code>local t x = e in s delocal t x = e</code> This block introduces a local variable <code>x</code>, initializes it reversibly using <code>e</code>, executes <code>s</code>, and then uncomputes <code>x</code> back to its initial state (usually 0) using the inverse of <code>e</code> upon exit.<ref name="Yokoyama-71-81"/>
** '''Procedure Call:''' <code>call id</code> executes procedure <code>id</code> forwards; <code>uncall id</code> executes procedure <code>id</code> backwards.<ref name="Choudhury"/> Procedures operate via side effects on the global store.
** '''Skip:''' <code>skip</code> does nothing and is its own inverse.
Line 189 ⟶ 149:
 
===Implementations and code examples===
Several online interpreters for Janus exist.<ref>{{cite web |url=https://topps.diku.dk/pirc/?id=janus |title=Janus: a reversible imperative programming language |website=University of Copenhagen (DIKU) |access-date=April 9, 2025}}</ref> Janus has been used to implement various algorithms reversibly, including computing Fibonacci pairs,<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/> simulating RTMs,<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/> Fast Fourier Transform (FFT)<ref>{{cite web |url=https://cra.org/ccc/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2020/11/Jayson-Lynch_ReversibleAlgorithmsTalk.pdf |title=Reversible Algorithms |website=Computing Research Association |access-date=April 9, 2025}}</ref>, graph algorithms <ref>{{cite web |url=https://cra.org/ccc/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2020/11/Jayson-Lynch_ReversibleAlgorithmsTalk.pdf |title=Reversible Algorithms |website=Computing Research Association |access-date=April 9, 2025}}</ref>, and simulating the Schrödinger wave equation.<ref>{{cite conference
| last1 = Yokoyama
| first1 = Tetsuo
Line 211 ⟶ 171:
}}</ref>
 
The following fibpair procedure in Janus calculates a pair of consecutive Fibonacci numbers.<ref name="Glück-2022.06.010"/>{{cite journalGiven an input <code>n</code>, it sets <code>x1</code> to <code>F(n)</code> and <code>x2</code> to <code>F(n+1)</code>, assuming <code>x1</code> and <code>x2</code> are initially <code>0</code>:
| last1 = Glück
| first1 = Robert
| last2 = Yokoyama
| first2 = Tetsuo
| title = Reversible computing from a programming language perspective
| journal = Theoretical Computer Science
| volume = 953
| article-number = 113429
| year = 2023
| doi = 10.1016/j.tcs.2022.06.010
| url = https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tcs.2022.06.010
<!-- bibtex source: DBLP:journals/tcs/GluckY23 -->
<!-- biburl: https://dblp.org/rec/journals/tcs/GluckY23.bib -->
<!-- bibsource: dblp computer science bibliography, https://dblp.org -->
<!-- timestamp: Mon, 03 Mar 2025 22:24:24 +0100 -->
}}</ref> Given an input <code>n</code>, it sets <code>x1</code> to <code>F(n)</code> and <code>x2</code> to <code>F(n+1)</code>, assuming <code>x1</code> and <code>x2</code> are initially <code>0</code>:
 
<pre>
Line 641 ⟶ 585:
| class = cs.PL
}}</ref>
* '''Flowchart Languages:''' Languages like R-CORE, R-WHILE, and SRL provide structured representations of reversible control flow, often serving as intermediate languages or theoretical models.<ref name="Palazzo-2501.05259"/> Their semantics can also be captured using categorical frameworks.<ref>{{cite arXivconference
| last1 = Palazzo
| first1 = Matteo
| last2 = Roversi
| first2 = Luca
| title = Reversible Computation with Stacks and "Reversible Management of Failures"
| eprint = 2501.05259
| year = 2025
<!-- biburl: https://dblp.org/rec/journals/corr/abs-2501-05259.bib -->
<!-- bibsource: dblp computer science bibliography, https://dblp.org -->
<!-- timestamp: Wed, 19 Feb 2025 21:19:08 +0100 -->
| class = cs.PL
}}</ref> Their semantics can also be captured using categorical frameworks.<ref>{{cite conference
| last1 = Glück
| first1 = Robert
Line 787 ⟶ 719:
 
{| class="wikitable"
|+ Comparison of Reversible Programming Languages<ref name="Yokoyama-71-812010.02.007"/><ref name="Choudhury"/><ref>{{cite arXiv
| last1 = Haulund
| first1 = Tue