Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Several Monty Python sketches: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 05:11, 23 September 2007

Revision as of 12:13, 23 September 2007

Line 20:

*'''Merge'''. Information is worthwhile, but not as separate articles. [[User:Operating|Operating]] 21:46, 22 September 2007 (UTC)

*'''Keep''' why delete two sheds but keep nudge nudge? Either get rid of every MP sketch article or keep them all. The only other sensible alternative is to only keep "notable" sketches, which would be sketches that have been written about or reviewed independently. But that would be silly. We have a separate article for every Frasier episode, not just the "notable" ones. Likewise, it is fine to have an article for every MP sketch. [[User:Capmango|Capmango]] 23:33, 22 September 2007 (UTC)

:*[[WP:WAX]] is not a reasonable argument <s>for</s> against deletion. Maybe we shouldn't have an article on every Frasier episode. I don't know. It doesn't matter, because the existence of those articles has nothing to do with the existence of these. The existence of other MP sketch articles is not a valid reason for keeping these. [[User:Otto4711|Otto4711]] 00:30, 23 September 2007 (UTC)

::*I'm not arguing for deletion. And I was using the Frasier example illustritively. There are plenty of situations where it makes sense as an encyclopedia to have a complete set. We had similar discussions about NY subway stops. Some are clearly notable, some maybe not so much, but if we're going to cover subway stops, it makes sense to cover all of them. If we're going to cover Monty Python sketches (and we should), it makes WP:SENSE to cover them all. [[User:Capmango|Capmango]] 03:46, 23 September 2007 (UTC)

:::*I don't agree that it makes sense to cover every MP sketch simply for the sake of completeness. [[User:Otto4711|Otto4711]] 12:13, 23 September 2007 (UTC)

*'''Keep All''' or '''Renominate Separately''' so that we can discuss the merits of each separately. I know that the Anne Elk Brontosaurus episode is notable and the Kilamanjaro episode might be considered notable. [[User:Pocopocopocopoco|Pocopocopocopoco]] 23:44, 22 September 2007 (UTC)

:*I have confidence in the ability of my fellow editors to be able to review this small selection of similar and related articles and come to a decision. If you have [[WP:RS|reliable sources]] that attest to the notability of the Anne Elk sketch then please add them to the article. [[User:Otto4711|Otto4711]] 00:30, 23 September 2007 (UTC)