Content deleted Content added
Line 6:
How does reflection relate to [[self-modifying code]]? The terms are used in quite different contexts, of course, but aren't they really forms of the same thing? Self-modifying code is usually done in assembly language, and is normally considered bad form; reflection is usually considered a good thing, especially if the language is set up for it. I might at least add a "see also" to the other one on both pages. [[User:Benhoyt|Benhoyt]] 20:56, 22 December 2005 (UTC)
I don't think that reflection is self-modifing code, they are two different things. With reflection, code does not change at runtime at all, it's only introspection, code knows about itself, but does not change at all. You could do reflection even in C (but it's not portalbe), as you can call functions via pointers, and you could search for the required pointer to be called by browsing through the debug symbol database for example.
Also I think that every example there that uses code interpretation (that still is NOT QUITE full self-modifing code, because you're just invoking the interpreter to parse more text, but you are not allowed to modify existing code, or at least, not easily, that's something that is only doable in ASM or in languages that have code-as-data equivalence, like LISP) are _plain wrong_. There you don't have reflection, you are not allowed to know the type given a string, to query the interpreter database... you're only hacking the function call by interpreting it in runtime, instead of having it hardcoded. It's not, conceptually, the same thing. For example, if I have an interpreted language that makes me interpret strings in runtime, I surely can call methods given the string of the class and of the method, but still is not quite the same thing as getting the type object via a string. IMHO those examples are only confusing, and are one of the typical Wikipedia problems, users add everything just to add things to the article, even if the examples are not useful to clarify the concept, and rather they make it harder to be understood. This is really bad.
== Is reflection slow? ==
| |||