Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Distributed Language: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
Line 6:
*'''Delete.''' Hmm-m, don't quite know what to say here. Upon superficial and admittedly uninformed examination (I am a mathematician and know nothing about linguistics), the concept does appear to be notable in linguistics, see GoogleScholar[http://scholar.google.com/scholar?um=1&q=%22distributed%20language%22%20Linguistics&sa=N&tab=ps] and GoogleBooks[http://books.google.com/books?tab=sp&sa=N&um=1&q=%22distributed+language%22+Linguistics&sa=N]. However, at present the article is written as an [[WP:OR|OR]] essay, and a polemic one at that, with a substantial dose of POV, and fairly incomprehesible (to the extent that a clear definition of the main concept seems unrecoverable from the current text). "Language is viewed as a heterogeneous meshwork of events, processes and material artifacts, when language dynamics influence what individuals do, think and, thus, how the meshwork evolves". Come again? If someone can completely rewrite the article from scratch, give an understandable definition of the concept and list a few references, the article could be kept as a stub. As things stand now, however, it is hard to see anything salvageable in the article. So unless some-one comes forward and takes on a major clean-up and rewrite task, it is better to delete the article. [[User:Nsk92|Nsk92]] ([[User talk:Nsk92|talk]]) 01:25, 13 May 2008 (UTC)
*'''Comment''' Would definitely like to see it stubbed if it appears to be a real concept; this looks to me like ''another'' school assignment. [[User:JeremyMcCracken|JeremyMcCracken]] ([[user talk:JeremyMcCracken|talk]]) ([[Special:Contributions/JeremyMcCracken|contribs]]) 02:22, 13 May 2008 (UTC)
| |||