Affirmative action: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
rmv unsourced commentary
m Typo fixing, using AWB
Line 1:
{{expert-subject-multiple|Sociology|Politics|date=January 2010}}
 
The term '''affirmative action''' refers to policies that take race, ethnicity,{{Citation needed|date=December 2009}} physical disabilities, military career,{{Citation needed|date=December 2009}} sex, or a person's parents' social class<ref name="Heinz-Peter Meidinger 2009">Heinz-Peter Meidinger: "Berliner Schullotterie". Profil 07-08/2009 (August 24th. 2009)</ref> into consideration in an attempt to promote [[equal opportunity]] or increase ethnic or other forms of diversity. The focus of such policies ranges from employment and education to public contracting and health programs. The impetus towards affirmative action is twofold: to maximize diversity in all levels of society, along with its presumed benefits, and to redress perceived disadvantages due to overt, institutional, or involuntary discrimination. Opponents argue that it promotes [[reverse discrimination]].
 
Affirmative action is also known as '''reservation''' in India, and '''employment equity''' in Canada.
Line 33:
*[[Japan]]. Admission to universities as well as all government positions (including teachers) are determined by the entrance exam, which is extremely competitive at the top level. It is illegal to include sex, ethnicity or other social background (but not nationality) in criteria; however, there are informal policies to provide employment and long term welfare (which is usually not available to general public) to [[Burakumin]] at municipality level.
 
*[[South Korea]]. Admission to universities is also determined by the strict entrance exam, which is extremely competitive at the top level. But most of all Korean universities at the top level are adapting some affirmative actions in cases of Chinese ethnic minority, North Korean refugees, etc. in their recruiting new students. Besides, national universities have been pressed by the Korean govermentgovernment, so now they are trying to meet the governmental goal which is to recruit a proportion of female professors.
 
===[[South East Asia]] and [[Oceania]]===
Line 47:
 
[[Image:Dahrendorf.jpg|thumb|[[The Right Honourable]] The Lord Dahrendorf, KBE, was in favour of affirmative action]]
*[[Germany]]. Article 3 of the [[Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany|German basic law]] provides for equal rights of all people regardless of sex, race or social background. There are programs stating that if men and women have equal qualifications, women have to be preferred for a job; moreover, the handicapped should be preferred to healthy people. This is typical for all positions in state and university service as of 2007, typically using the phrase "We try to increase diversity in this line of work". In recent years, there has been a long public debate about whether to issue programs that would grant women a privileged access to jobs in order to fight discrimination. Germany's ''[[The Left (Germany)|Left Party]]'' brought up the discussion about affirmative action in [[Education in Germany|Germany's school system]]. According to [[Stefan Zillich]], quotas should be "a possibility" to help working class children who did not do well in school gain access to a ''[[Gymnasium (Germany)|Gymnasium]]'' (University-preparatory school).<ref>Susanne Vieth-Entus (29. Dezember 2008): "Sozialquote: Berliner Gymnasien sollen mehr Schüler aus armen Familien aufnehmen". Der Tagesspiegel</ref> Headmasters of ''Gymnasien'' have objected, saying that this type of policy would "be a disservice" to poor children.<ref>Martin Klesmann (23. February 2009). "'Kinder aus Neukölln würden sich nicht integrieren lassen' - Ein Politiker und ein Schulleiter streiten über Sozialquoten an Gymnasien". Berliner Zeitung</ref><br>In 2009 the Berlin senate decided that Berlin's Gymnasium should no longer be allowed to handpick all of their students. It was ruled that while Gymnasien should be able to pick 70 % to 65 % of their students, the other places at the Gymnasien are to be allocated by lottery. Every child will be able to enter the lottery, no matter how he or she performed in primary school. It is hoped that this policy will increase the number of working class students attending a Gymnasium.<ref> name="Heinz-Peter Meidinger: 2009"Berliner Schullotterie". Profil 07-08/2009 (August 24th. 2009)</ref> [[The Left (Germany)|The Left]] proposed that Berlin Gymnasien should no longer be allowed to expel students who perform poorly so that the students who won a Gymnasium place in the lottery have a fair chance of graduating from that school.<ref> name="Heinz-Peter Meidinger: 2009"Berliner Schullotterie". Profil 07-08/2009 (August 24th. 2009)</ref> It is not clear yet if Berlin's senate will decide in favour of [[The Left (Germany)|The Left]]s proposal. There is also a discussion going on if affirmative action should be employed to help the children and grandchildren of the so called [[Gastarbeiter]] gain better access to German universities. One prominent proponent of this was Lord [[Ralf Dahrendorf]]<ref>Christine Prußky: "Zuwanderer an die Unis - Soziologe Ralf Dahrendorf fordert Migrantenquote"</ref> It is argued that the Gastarbeiter willingly came to Germany to help build the industry and this should be honored.
 
*[[Norway]]. In all [[public limited company|public limited companies (PCL)]] boards, either gender should be represented by 40%.<ref>http://www.lovdata.no/all/tl-19970613-045-032.html#6-3</ref> This affects roughly 400 companies.
Line 53:
*[[Sweden]]. Swedish democracy, although very solicitous about minorities' rights and integration, does not allow affirmative action.
 
*[[United Kingdom]]. In the UK, new discrimination laws are proposed in the [[Equality Bill]] published in April 2009. It sets out discrimination laws such as permitting mothers to breastfeed unashamedly in public, prevention of descriminative pension plans and the rights of a magistrate to examine any pay difference between male and female employees and many more<ref name="publications.parliament.uk">http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200809/cmbills/085/voli/09085i.i-ii.html</ref> There are strict definitions in equality law in relation to the illegality of all discrimination. Concern is focused on the illegality of discriminatiom rather than the the encouragement of it.<ref name="cre"/><ref>Personneltoday.com "Is there a case for positive discrimination?" http://www.personneltoday.com/Articles/2006/01/17/33430/is-there-a-case-for-positive-discrimination.html</ref> That bill does not apply to [[Northern Ireland]] although similar laws apply. A requirement of the 1998 [[Good Friday Agreement]] was that the [[Police Service of Northern Ireland]] recruit equal numbers of [[Roman Catholic Church|Catholics]] as [[Protestants]] where before there were very few. Actively encouraging people from minority backgrounds to apply for jobs is permitted in the UK but it is illegal to discriminate in favour of them in awarding employment or anything else.<ref>http://www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/forbusinessesandorganisation/employers/pages/recruitmentandjobadvertisements.aspx</ref> A form of discrimination is permitted and employed by the [[Labour Party (UK)|Labour Party]], which uses [[All-women shortlists]] to ensure that more women are selected as election candidates. This permission was extended from the [[Sex Discrimination (Election Candidates) Act 2002]]. The proposed Equality Bill includes prohibiting discrimination and harrassmentharassment based upon a previous relationship even if the relationship has not ended. The new bill does mention the term "positive action" but does not suggest that positive action is a term specific to discrimination but implies a term specific to action itself and gives the examples under that heading that a breast screening clinic could be provided for lesbians-only if studies showed them to be more susceptablesusceptible and that providing a law enforcement job to an under represented ethnic group would be lawful but employing a woman in a job that a more qualified man had applied for would be illegal.<ref name="publications.parliament.uk"/>
 
* [[Republic of Macedonia]]. Minorities, most notably [[Albania]]ns, are allocated quotas for access to state universities, as well as in civil public services.{{Citation needed|date=April 2008}}
Line 69:
===[[Israel]]===
 
Israel has affirmative action for the [[Aliyah from Ethiopia]] (jewishJewish Ethiopians), with regard to housing, education and integration into employment.<ref>http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Archive/Communiques/1996/The%20Absorption%20of%20Ethiopian%20Immigrants%20in%20Israel%20-</ref>
 
==Other types of affirmative action==
Line 178:
[[fi:Positiivinen syrjintä]]
[[sv:Kvotering]]
 
[[ta:சீர்திருத்த செயலாக்கம்]]
[[zh:積極平權措施]]