Talk:I'm with Cupid/GA1: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
Will do review.
 
GA Review: Evaluating for 1 and 2.
Line 7:
 
:I'll take this one on. --'''[[User:Starstriker7|Starstriker7]]'''<sup>([[User talk:Starstriker7|Talk]])</sup> 23:57, 23 June 2011 (UTC)
===Criteria 1a (Prose clear, spelling correct) and 1b (lead, layout, W2W, fiction, list stuff)===
====Lead====
*Valentine's day (capitalize Day)
*"Apu gives his wife "--> gives to his wife?
*"Apu, in order to sabotage" - Remove ", in order"
*"would air on" --> was to air on
*"to be relate to" --> to relate to
*The lead should also discuss stuff from the Cultural references section.
 
====Production====
*"Valentine's day" - capitalize Day
*The article says that the episode was created because it aired on Valentine's Day. I'm not quite sure what that means.
*Are you able to specify which the TV series that had an episode that conflicted with this episode's name?
*"He does not believe that copyright issues will arise though:" --> However, he did not believe that copyright issues would arise:
 
====Reception====
*The reviews are probably better described as generally positive. Not all the included reviews approved of the episode.
 
===Criterion 2a (All stuff cited, separate ref section)===
*The Plath ref [http://www.dvdtown.com/review/simpsons-the-the-complete-10th-season/dvd/5056/2 should link to page 2].
 
===Criterion 2b (Argue-able stuff is cited)===
*In the lead, cite the 7.7 million/48th place tidbit.
 
===Criterion 2c (WP:NOR)===
All clear here.