Content deleted Content added
GO WHARTON (talk | contribs) vandal MBAguy/Gekko escalates his war to the next level |
m refactored page, added section titles. |
||
Line 1:
{{oldafdfull|date=10 April, 2006|result='''keep'''|votepage=Ivy League business schools}}
==Response to Gekko's reversions==
'''NOTE TO ALL''': READ the comments here from [[User:GO WHARTON|GO WHARTON]] and decide for yourself what is going on. You can see that [[User:GO WHARTON|GO WHARTON]] is attempting to give the appearance of discussion whereas in fact he considers NPOV rankings information as "grafitti" while he reverts to his completely one-sided bit of Ivy League propaganda. The rankings I included (and I thank those reverting back to it) are not grafitti, this piece of propaganda masquerading as an article is grafitti. [[User:MBAguy|MBAguy]] 02:11, 19 April 2006 (UTC)▼
:Please note that MBAguy/Gekko is now reordering the messages in this discussion so that he can force everyone to read his message first (even though it's not first in chronological order). It's another of his bullying tactics in his war against this article. His bold face "NOTE TO ALL: READ" is MBAguy's way of screaming, "how dare anyone vote down MBAguy/Gekko's AfD." He is using lots of sleazy tactics to do an end around of the AfD voting process. His goal over time is to overload this article with his forced rankings talk, a little now, more later. Then he'll use his rankings-saturated version of this article as the reason to resubmit his AfD within the next few months. This article was neutral (see the "17:12, 9 March 2006" version) before MBAguy/Gekko declared his war against it, trying to force everyone to accept his POV and his extreme bias against the Ivy League. MBAguy/Gekko's history and tactics are very clear when one reviews the article revision history, the AfD voting discussion and history, and this article discussion history. MBAguy/Gekko is still beating his war drums ... [[User:GO WHARTON|GO WHARTON]] 17:03, 21 April 2006 (UTC)▼
:Crazy but true - MBAguy/Gekko has again escalated his war against the Ivy League. MBAguy/Gekko is now going throughout the Wikipedia encyclopedia and deleting all references, links, and mentions of Ivy League that he can find. Seems maybe MBAguy/Gekko wants to eradicate the Ivy League from civilization. [[User:GO WHARTON|GO WHARTON]] 17:32, 21 April 2006 (UTC)▼
This is in response to Gekko's reversions.
Line 22 ⟶ 16:
:::Suggestion for Gekko: why don't you add a link in the External Links section to your favorite ranking, or you could create a new School Rankings article and put a link to your new article at the bottom of this article. After all, this is not a rankings article. [[User:GO WHARTON|GO WHARTON]] 15:59, 18 April 2006 (UTC)
▲'''NOTE TO ALL''': READ the comments here from [[User:GO WHARTON|GO WHARTON]] and decide for yourself what is going on. You can see that [[User:GO WHARTON|GO WHARTON]] is attempting to give the appearance of discussion whereas in fact he considers NPOV rankings information as "grafitti" while he reverts to his completely one-sided bit of Ivy League propaganda. The rankings I included (and I thank those reverting back to it) are not grafitti, this piece of propaganda masquerading as an article is grafitti. [[User:MBAguy|MBAguy]] 02:11, 19 April 2006 (UTC)
▲:Please note that MBAguy/Gekko is now reordering the messages in this discussion so that he can force everyone to read his message first (even though it's not first in chronological order). ''(Page refactored to original order by [[User:JDoorjam|JDoorj]][[User:JDoorjam/Esperanza|<font color="green">a</font>]][[User:JDoorjam|m]] [[User Talk:JDoorjam|Talk]].))'' It's another of his bullying tactics in his war against this article. His bold face "NOTE TO ALL: READ" is MBAguy's way of screaming, "how dare anyone vote down MBAguy/Gekko's AfD." He is using lots of sleazy tactics to do an end around of the AfD voting process. His goal over time is to overload this article with his forced rankings talk, a little now, more later. Then he'll use his rankings-saturated version of this article as the reason to resubmit his AfD within the next few months. This article was neutral (see the "17:12, 9 March 2006" version) before MBAguy/Gekko declared his war against it, trying to force everyone to accept his POV and his extreme bias against the Ivy League. MBAguy/Gekko's history and tactics are very clear when one reviews the article revision history, the AfD voting discussion and history, and this article discussion history. MBAguy/Gekko is still beating his war drums ... [[User:GO WHARTON|GO WHARTON]] 17:03, 21 April 2006 (UTC)
▲:Crazy but true - MBAguy/Gekko has again escalated his war against the Ivy League. MBAguy/Gekko is now going throughout the Wikipedia encyclopedia and deleting all references, links, and mentions of Ivy League that he can find. Seems maybe MBAguy/Gekko wants to eradicate the Ivy League from civilization. [[User:GO WHARTON|GO WHARTON]] 17:32, 21 April 2006 (UTC)
::To MBAguy/Gekko: Your first involvement with this article was to submit an AfD. In your nomination, you harped that an article with Ivy League in it must be an "agenda," and that it must mean all Ivy Leaguers think they're "superior to others." However, none of your remarks are supported by the long-standing neutral tone of this article before you recently blasted onto the scene (see first message in this discussion for details). Your AfD nom was voted down, so you switched to your alter-ego Gekko. Under that name, you have the same arrogant tone and insistently reverted all new content (without discussion) in order to restore your article vandalisms during the voting process. I've constructively suggested often that you could put a link to your favorite rankings in the External Links section. I've also suggested that you could create a School Rankings article. You could then place a link to your new rankings article at the bottom of this article's page. Instead of discussing those possibilities, you switched back to MBAguy and wrote the above "NOTE TO ALL" which is the same harping about Ivy League, your personal issues, and boosterism that you stuck into the voting discussion. Seems as though you're trying to do an end-around of the AfD process. [[User:GO WHARTON|GO WHARTON]] 19:06, 19 April 2006 (UTC)
==Regarding Gekko/MBAguy's NPOV tag
(Please see the discussion for this article which gives the history of Gekko/MBAguy's recent assaults on this article.) (Please also see the resulting discussion of MBAguy/Gekko's recent AfD which was overwhelmingly voted down by our fellow wikipedians.) Now, he seems to be attempting an end around of the AfD process. Prior to Gekko/MBAguy's recent declaration of war on this article, the article was neutral, as can be seen in the "17:12 9 March 2006" version of this article. Since Apr. 3, 2006, however, an onslaught of sleazy tactics, graffiti, and vandalism has been perpetrated on this article, coincident with the arrival of MBAguy/Gekko. Regrettably, Gekko/MBAguy continues using his typical approach of vandalizing and complaining about the article, while shunning discussion on the merits and refusing to discuss many constructive suggestions offered to him. Gekko/MBAguy is clearly not interested in improving this article. His scheme appears to be to continually mutilate this article, so that he can resubmit his AfD in the upcoming months, using his mutilated version of the article as the reason for deletion of this article - all because of his belief that the term "Ivy League" equates to "boosterism," as he has said. His extreme tactics against this article do not seem to be in the Wikipedia spirit. Since MBAguy/Gekko has shown he has no interest in civil discourse, perhaps it would help if a third party would step in and help out here. [[User:GO WHARTON|GO WHARTON]] 16:51, 20 April 2006 (UTC)
| |||