Content deleted Content added
→[[User_talk:Mccready#Block_for_Wikistalking]]: f you wanted to block him for disruption for frivolous postings to AN/I after being warned, I could understand that, but stalking? |
|||
Line 1,020:
Jayjg, I hope you don't take it the wrong way me saying this, but there are serious problems with the article on Hamas and [[User:Tazmaniacs]] and [[User:Bertilvidet]] have been making a real and serious effort to deal with them in a fair way. I know you are a serious editor and genuinely concerned with objectivity, and I would like to ask you to help resolve these issues in the talk page discussion. A number of editors (of various points of view) seem to be angry enough about the issues to just revert everything they see as done "by the other side"; I think we are both likely to agree that this isn't a helpful way of addressing whatever problems the page may have. I am sure that with your input to discussion, an agreed version could eventually be hammered out with full respect for NPOV, {{WP:CS]] etc. Please excuse me if you feel this remark is out of turn (or a breach of your talk page rule!). Regards, [[User:Palmiro|Palmiro]] | [[User talk:Palmiro|Talk]] 13:34, 10 May 2006 (UTC)
:I get your point; however, I think they were acting in good faith there as well; there was what would normally count as a ridiculous number of citations, but they were there for a good reason, i.e. to establish the contention, which had been disputed, that Hamas was well-known or best-known abroad for suicide bombings. Probably the best thing to have done would have been to combine all these citations into one footnote, which is unproblematic, but this doesn't seem to have occurred to anyone. I don't think Bertil or Tazmaniacs were disputing the contention that the notes were there to support, at least in its milder ("well-known" rather than "best-known") version. I have more thoughts on the broader subject, but I'm afraid I really have to go now. Thanks for the reply. [[User:Palmiro|Palmiro]] | [[User talk:Palmiro|Talk]] 17:01, 10 May 2006 (UTC)
== [[User_talk:Mccready#Block_for_Wikistalking]] ==
| |||