The study group reveals they made a festfeast in Jeff's honor because he has been graduated. When he suggests to play roll and -the-die, he accidentally re createsrecreates the darkest timeline, and Evil Jeff appears in the Dean's office. He escapes and tries to ruin the fiesta, making bad things in orderattempting to sabotage Jeff's relations with histhe friendsrest of the study group. Jeff mistakes Evil Annie for the real one and getsis surprised to find nobody at thehis graduation ceremony until the Dean (disguised in damsel drag) shows up in order to tell him he is a bad guy. Meanwhile, Abed hashimself beengets sent into anthe alternatedarkest realitytimeline, where he meets hisAbed doppelganger(who is no longer Evil) who gives him some paintball guns in order to shoot the doubles (the paintballs these guns fire have the ability to transport an individual between timelines). When Jeff arrives at Troy's and Abed's apartment, he explainstries whatto happenedexplain his behavior, but nobody believebelieves him until Abed shows up and convinceconvinces the others that Jeff is actually righttelling the truth. Meanwhile, the Evil Study Group (minus Evil Abed) arrive in the realprime timeline and meet Evil Pierce who actuallyapparently ''faked'' his death, though he has now has a metal leg and crutches. They discuss their plans for the study group until Evil Britta accidentally shoots herself and gets sent inback to the evildarkest worldtimeline. The real stugystudy group then shows up and processproceeds to eliminate onetheir byevil doppelgangers one theirby demoniac doppelgangersone. With only Evil Jeff left, Abed explains to Jeff that he was stressed about graduation because he thought that Greendale diddidn'ntt change him.; However, thanks to Abed, Jeff realizes that he now has friends and that made his life better. He manages to destroydefeat Evil Jeff and sendsends him back into his own reality. The scene is then backreverts atto the moment wherethat Jeff decided to throw the die but(revealing that the events of the episode took place in his own mind), and he forgetsinstead decides against tossing it. andHis thegraduation ceremony then takes place in the study room with the study group (sans Pierce), Magnitude, Quendra, Leonard, Garrett, Fat Neil, and Vicky. AtJeff gives a most heartfelt speech about his time at Greendale and the endlove he has for his friends. During the ceremony, Pierce isbreaks finallyin, graduatedannouncing toohis intention to graduate as well, and a meal follows the reception.
The end tag shows Evil Troy and Evil Abed, who introducesintroduce us to a parallel universe (Wheretimeline 5, where Pierce was chosen to get the pizza) and shows us Britta and Troy having a non-human baby. The Evil Jeff appears, saying that the show Evil Troy and Evil Abed host is not watched by anybody and does not exist anymore (an obvious meta-reference to the actual show Community's own likely end), to which Evil Troy and Evil Abed shrug in agreement.
