Content deleted Content added
m Added living=yes parameter to {{WikiProject Biography}}, talk page general fixes & other cleanup per WP:TPL using AWB (10218) |
Arthur Rubin (talk | contribs) →Comments: new section |
||
Line 11:
I'm going to be Bold and not wait for comment. --[[User:Roxy the dog|Roxy the dog]] ([[User talk:Roxy the dog|resonate]]) 17:24, 21 January 2014 (UTC)
== Comments ==
Sorry, I can't summarize this in one sentence.
It's good that the non-studies he uses to support his conclusions have been removed. However, so have the real studies that he also uses in support of his conclusions. Irregardless, However, his conclusions (at least, ''his'' statements on a PBS special airing now on [[KOCE]], as I write) that carbohydrates in general, and grains in particular, are responsible for all neurological disorders ([[Alzheimer's]] (and most other memory loss, not even falling into the category of [[ dementia]]) and depression) and some other disorders ([[diabetes]], etc.) should appear in the article.
I don't think I could improve the article (other than noting that the first critical article is quoting the second), because I believe his reasoning is absurd, and as noted in [[WP:FRINGE]], there are few scientists willing to debate the issue. <redacted my detailed opinion as to the basis of my belief, before posting. It's not relevant. I'm not a medical expert.> Perhaps this argues against my second sentence above, because it gives undue weight to the implication that his conclusions are justified.
Still, we should be able to state his conclusions without commenting or implying whether they are accurate or justified. — [[User:Arthur Rubin|Arthur Rubin]] [[User talk:Arthur Rubin|(talk)]] 08:58, 27 July 2014 (UTC)
| |||