|
| Jimmy Pelzel || {{VolleySB UNI California Irvine}} || Carlos Moreno || {{VolleySB UNI Brigham Young}}
|-
| [[Sean Rooney]] || {{VolleySB UNI Pepperdine}} || [[Jeff Ptak]] || {{VolleySB UNI IPFW}}
|-
| [[Christopher Tamas]] || {{VolleySB UNI Pacific}} || Justin Schnor || {{VolleySB UNI Loyola Chicago}}
|-
| '''[[Costas Theocharidis]]''' || {{VolleySB UNI Hawaii}} || Ryan Stuntz || {{VolleySB UNI Lewis}}
|-
| [[Delano Thomas]] || {{VolleySB UNI Hawaii}} || [[Frederic Winters]] || {{VolleySB UNI Pepperdine}}
|-style = "border-top:2px solid black;"
|rowspan=10| 2004<ref>{{cita web|url=http://www.avca.org/articles/index.cfm?action=view&articleID=430&menuID=1469|titolo=2004 AVCA All-America Teams|lingua=en|editore=avca.org/|accesso=13-01-2014}}</ref>
| -[[Tyler Hildebrand]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Long Beach}} || -Pedro Azenha || {{VolleySB UNI -Hawaii}}
|-
| -Keith Kowal || {{VolleySB UNI -Penn State}} || -[[Víctor Batista]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Brigham Young}}
|-
| -[[David Lee (pallavolista)|David Lee]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Long Beach}} || -Joe Hillman || {{VolleySB UNI -Brigham Young}}
|-
| -'''Carlos Moreno''' || {{VolleySB UNI -Brigham Young}} || -Ricky Mattei || {{VolleySB UNI -Penn State}}
|-
| -Fernando Pessoa || {{VolleySB UNI -Brigham Young}} || -[[Evan Patak]] || {{VolleySB UNI -California Santa Barbara}}
|-
| -[[Sean Rooney]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Pepperdine}} || -Jimmy Pelzel || {{VolleySB UNI -California Irvine}}
|-
| -Adam Shrader || {{VolleySB UNI -Los Angeles}} || -Chris Pena || {{VolleySB UNI -Los Angeles}}
|-
| -[[Scott Touzinsky]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Long Beach}} || -Keith Schunzel || {{VolleySB UNI -Ball State}}
|-
| -[[Frederic Winters]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Pepperdine}} || -Ty Tramblie || {{VolleySB UNI -California State Northridge}}
|-
| -Matt Zbyszewski || {{VolleySB UNI -IPFW}} || -Brian Waite || {{VolleySB UNI -California State Northridge}}
|-
|-style = "border-top:2px solid black;"
|rowspan=10| 2005<ref>{{cita web|url=http://www.avca.org/articles/index.cfm?action=view&articleID=428&menuID=1469|titolo=2005 AVCA All-America Teams|lingua=en|editore=avca.org/|accesso=13-01-2014}}</ref>
| -Pedro Azenha || {{VolleySB UNI -Hawaii}} || -Michael Burke || {{VolleySB UNI -Brigham Young}}
|-
| -[[Kevin Hansen]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Stanford}} || -Mark Greaves || {{VolleySB UNI -Ohio State}}
|-
| -[[Andrew Hein]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Pepperdine}} || -Scott Greene || {{VolleySB UNI -Loyola Chicago}}
|-
| -[[Tyler Hildebrand]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Long Beach}} || -Keith Kowal || {{VolleySB UNI -Penn State}}
|-
| -Paul Johnson || {{VolleySB UNI -Los Angeles}} || -Krystian Krzyzak || {{VolleySB UNI -Loyola Chicago}}
|-
| -Nate Meerstein || {{VolleySB UNI -Penn State}} || -Nils Nielsen || {{VolleySB UNI -California State Northridge}}
|-
| -[[Evan Patak]] || {{VolleySB UNI -California Santa Barbara}} || -[[Iván Pérez (pallavolista)|Iván Pérez]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Brigham Young}}
|-
| -Alfred Reft || {{VolleySB UNI -Hawaii}} || -[[Matthew Proper]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Penn State}}
|-
| -'''[[Sean Rooney]]''' || {{VolleySB UNI -Pepperdine}} || -Brian Waite || {{VolleySB UNI -California State Northridge}}
|-
| -[[Robert Tarr]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Long Beach}} || -[[Jonathan Winder]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Pepperdine}}
|-
|-style = "border-top:2px solid black;"
|rowspan=10| 2006<ref>{{cita web|url=http://www.avca.org/articles/index.cfm?action=view&articleID=360&menuID=1469|titolo=2006 AVCA All-America Teams|lingua=en|editore=avca.org/|accesso=13-01-2014}}</ref>
| -Brent Asuka || {{VolleySB UNI -California Irvine}} || -Duncan Budinger || {{VolleySB UNI -Long Beach}}
|-
| -Brian Beckwith || {{VolleySB UNI -Hawaii}} || -Matt Carere || {{VolleySB UNI -Hawaii}}
|-
| -James Grunst || {{VolleySB UNI -Loyola Chicago}} || -[[Russell Holmes]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Brigham Young}}
|-
| -Lauri Hakala || {{VolleySB UNI -Hawaii}} || -C.J. Macias || {{VolleySB UNI -IPFW}}
|-
| -[[Andrew Hein]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Pepperdine}} || -[[Matthew Proper]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Penn State}}
|-
| -[[Tyler Hildebrand]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Long Beach}} || -Alfred Reft || {{VolleySB UNI -Hawaii}}
|-
| -'''[[Jayson Jablonsky]]''' || {{VolleySB UNI -California Irvine}} || -[[Brian Thornton]] || {{VolleySB UNI -California Irvine}}
|-
| -Chris Kozlarek || {{VolleySB UNI -Loyola Chicago}} || -Brian Waite || {{VolleySB UNI -California State Northridge}}
|-
| -Shaun Powell || {{VolleySB UNI -George Mason}} || -Matt Webber || {{VolleySB UNI -California Irvine}}
|-
| -[[Robert Tarr]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Long Beach}} || -[[Jonathan Winder]] || {{VolleySB UNI -Pepperdine}}
|-
|-style = "border-top:2px solid black;"
| 