Revision as of 06:47, 17 October 2006 edit Mahawiki (talk \| contribs) 1,389 edits →protected until script issues resolved ← Previous edit		Revision as of 07:02, 17 October 2006 edit undo Sarvagnya (talk \| contribs) 9,152 edits →protected until script issues resolved Next edit →
Line 81: ::Stop your empty rhetoric and if possible give a justification for having hindi/devanagari script there. Like I've already said before, this is an Urdu song and the English wikipeidia and the use of Hindi here is superfluous and meaningless. [[User:Sarvagnya\|Sarvagnya]] 06:24, 17 October 2006 (UTC) :::This is the last time i am requesting u to tone down ur language.If u read my post clearly its not rhetoric and with a justification of why Hindi transliteration should be used here. :::I do agree that Hindi is not our sole national language but it is a fact that it is the official and main link language of India [http://indiaimage.nic.in/languages.htm] :::Colloquially and linguistically, the distinction between the Urdū and Hindi is nearly meaningless'''[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindi#Hindi_and_Urd.C5.AB] [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urdu#Urd.C5.AB_and_Hind.C4.AB] :::*The song is ewually popular with Hindi speakers.In fact song is referred as tarana-e-Hindi [http://www.geocities.com/drmuhammadiqbal/39.htm] :::Since u want to remove the transliteration, onus is upon YOU to justify why to remove it?According to me u r just showcasing ur hatred against Hindi.Morever there's a consensus to include Hindi transliteration.Remember, this is not hindi virodh sabha. Thanks. [[User:Mahawiki\|Mahawiki]] 06:45, 17 October 2006 (UTC)▼ ~~Thanks.~~ ::::None of the reasons you give is acceptable on WP. WP runs according to its own rules. It does not run according to the Indian constitution. Moreover, this song has no special sanction ''even'' under the Indian constitution. This is just another song and it happens to be in Urdu. As for Hindi people singing it, I know it for a fact that people from all over India(of all languages, castes and creed) sing it. That doesnt mean we need to infest this article with transliterations of all the 200 odd languages in India. Also stop citing sources like [http://news.sulekha.com/newsanalysisdisplay.aspx?cid=97485 this] and [http://www.geocities.com/drmuhammadiqbal/39.htm this]. They are somebody's private blogs and are worthless as far as WP is concerned. See [[WP:Citing Sources]] [[User:Sarvagnya\|Sarvagnya]] 07:02, 17 October 2006 (UTC) ▲[[User:Mahawiki\|Mahawiki]] 06:45, 17 October 2006 (UTC)

Talk:Sare Jahan se Accha: Difference between revisions