Wikipedia:WikiProject Stub sorting/Proposals/Archive/2020/September
Proposals, September 2020
Please check how many articles qualify for a stub type before proposing it.
NEW PROPOSALS
Scotland football bios
Category:Scottish football forward stubs (808) and Category:Scottish football midfielder stubs (808) and given that Category:Scottish football biography stubs is at 644 I guess there are more to go in. I suggest splitting by dob as per the defenders
- {{Scotland-footy-midfielder-1900s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football midfielder, 1900s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-midfielder-1910s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football midfielder, 1910s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-midfielder-1920s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football midfielder, 1920s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-midfielder-1930s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football midfielder, 1930s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-midfielder-1940s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football midfielder, 1940s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-midfielder-1950s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football midfielder, 1950s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-midfielder-1960s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football midfielder, 1960s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-midfielder-1970s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football midfielder, 1970s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-midfielder-1980s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football midfielder, 1980s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-midfielder-1990s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football midfielder, 1990s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-forward-1900s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football forward, 1900s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-forward-1910s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football forward, 1910s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-forward-1920s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football forward, 1920s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-forward-1930s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football forward, 1930s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-forward-1940s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football forward, 1940s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-forward-1950s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football forward, 1950s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-forward-1960s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football forward, 1960s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-forward-1970s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football forward, 1970s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-forward-1980s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football forward, 1980s births stubs
- {{Scotland-footy-forward-1990s-stub}} - Category:Scottish football forward, 1990s births stubs
Categories only where the templates pass 60 Waacstats (talk) 23:24, 18 September 2020 (UTC)
Speedies
A few places that I have noticed where categories could be created from existing upmerged templates.
- Category:Jordanian politician stubs - {{Jordan-politician-stub}} (67)
- Category:Burmese politician stubs - {{Myanmar-politician-stub}} (155)
- Category:Kyrgyzstani politician stubs - {{Kyrgyzstan-politician-stub}} and {{Kyrgyzstan-mayor-stub}} (60)
- Category:Thrips stubs - {{Thrips-stub}} (473)
- Category:Mecoptera stubs - {{Mecoptera-stub}} (79)
- Category:Archaeognatha stubs - {{Archaeognatha-stub}} (93)
- Category:Tongan rugby union biography stubs - {{Tonga-rugbyunion-bio-stub}}
- Category:Samoan rugby union biography stubs - {{Samoa-rugbyunion-bio-stub}}
- Category:Georgia (country) rugby union biography stubs - {{Georgia-rugbyunion-bio-stub}}
- Category:Canadian rugby union biography stubs - {{Canada-rugbyunion-bio-stub}}
Waacstats (talk) 13:46, 14 September 2020 (UTC)
Split of Pakistani railway station stubs
Category:Pakistani railway station stubs is oversized, anyone any better idea than the traditional split by province.
- {{AzadKashmir-railstation-stub}} - Category:Azad Kashmir railway station stubs
- {{Balochistan-railstation-stub}} - Category:Balochistan railway station stubs or Category:Balochistan, Pakistan railway station stubs
- {{GilgitBaltistan-railstation-stub}} - Category:Gilgit-Baltistan railway station stubs
- {{KhyberPakhtunkhwa-railstation-stub}} - Category:Khyber Pakhtunkhwa railway station stubs
- {{PunjabPK-railstation-stub}} - Category:Punjab, Pakistan railway station stubs
- {{Sindh-railstation-stub}} - Category:Sindh railway station stubs
I note that the geo-stub category has Balochistan (Pakistan) were as the article is at Balochistan, Pakistan do we need a rename of the geo-stub cat. Waacstats (talk) 13:46, 14 September 2020 (UTC)
- Support I did this for India in February-March 2017, splitting by state if there were 60+ qualifying articles. See Wikipedia:WikiProject Stub sorting/Proposals/2017/February#Subdividing Indian railway station stubs. But you suggest six stub templates, and apparently Pakistan has four provinces; I expect that you are including territories, of which there are three, for a total of seven potential stub templates - there would be one for each of: Azad Kashmir; Balochistan; Gilgit-Baltistan; Islamabad; Khyber Pakhtunkhwa; Punjab and Sindh. --Redrose64 🌹 (talk) 18:53, 14 September 2020 (UTC)
- That will teach me to just use the geo category as reference. Can I add {{Islamabad-station-stub}} - Category:Islamabad railway station stubs or do you think that {{IslamabadCT-station-stub}} - Category:Islamabad Capital Territory railway station stubs would be better? Waacstats (talk) 20:43, 14 September 2020 (UTC)
Split of German noble stubs
Another oversized category, based on a play with petscan the following should be viable:
- {{Germany-margrave-stub}} - Category:Margraves of Germany stubs (70)
- {{Germany-count-stub}} - Category:Counts of Germany stubs (290)
- {{Germany-countess-stub}} - Category:German countess stubs (59)
- {{Germany-duke-stub}} - Category:Dukes of Germany stubs (347)
- {{Germany-duchess-stub}} - Category:German duchess stubs (62)
Waacstats (talk) 13:46, 14 September 2020 (UTC)
Speedy Nepal district stub cats
{{IlamNP-geo-stub}}, {{Sunsari-geo-stub}}, {{Kaski-geo-stub}}, and {{Salyan-geo-stub}} have all been deployed on 60+ articles. Speedy categories? Her Pegship (?) 05:58, 13 September 2020 (UTC)
- Looks good to me. Waacstats (talk) 13:47, 14 September 2020 (UTC)
German airport stubs
In order to add to the categories French/Italian/Russian/Turkish and UK airport stubs, this new cat would fit into the Category:European airport stubs.
The same applies to Category:Germany transport stubs, in which "Germany rail transport stubs" and "Germany road stubs" are already existing.
In addition, there would be a certain degree of relief of the current Category:Germany transport stubs, which is currently parent to over 100 articles. --Uli Elch (talk) 10:06, 8 September 2020 (UTC)
- Category:European airport stubs is oversized at 569 articles, but {{Germany-airport-stub}} is only linked to 36 of those articles. I suggest the template remain upmerged for now, until such time as it's used on 60+ articles. It might help for someone to assign more specific templates to the European airport stubs articles; {{Europe-airport-stub}} is used on 284 articles, and I bet some of them are in Germany. Her Pegship (?) 18:07, 8 September 2020 (UTC)
South American hospital stubs
I would like to propose a new category, Category:South American hospital stubs. This category would be populated by two existing templates,
Currently, these two templates populated the Category:Hospital stubs (111 articles) and Category:Brazilian building and structure stubs (415 articles, for the Brazil template). The "Category:Hospital stubs" would contain non-geographic hospital stubs and stubs about hospitals in Oceania (New Zealand and other islands). Australia, which is also in Oceania, has its own category for Australia hospital stubs.
I have updated all the hospital stubs that are in the "Hospital stubs" category, so that stubs with categories use the appropriate template.
This new category would allow users to locate and improve articles more easily on South American hospital stubs.
WP:HOS -- Talk to G Moore 12:06, 7 September 2020 (UTC)