Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Civility enforcement/Questionnaire table

This is one of the pages for coordinating analysis of views submitted to the RFC on civility enforcement. Also see the coordination discussion page and the expanded questionnaire analysis page.

Questionnaire responses

No. edits	Editor's page link	First edit	Last edit	Bytes added	Live link[n 1]	Reviewed by	Comments & summary
25	Adjwilley	Nov 29	Nov 30	6151	[1]
1	Agathoclea	Nov 30	Nov 30	0	[2]
4	AGK	Nov 03	Nov 03	2232	[3]
34	Alanscottwalker	Nov 03	Dec 01	5795	[4]
35	Andrewa	Nov 30	Dec 04	6992	[5]
7	Ansumang	Nov 13	Dec 09	2530	[6]
16	Anthonyhcole	Nov 29	Dec 01	5470	[7]
5	Art LaPella	Dec 03	Dec 03	2319	[8]
28	AutomaticStrikeout	Nov 29	Nov 30	7068	[9]
28	Beeblebrox	Nov 29	Nov 29	9625	[10]
3	Begoon	Nov 29	Nov 29	3970	[11]
2	Bejnar	Nov 16	Nov 16	2495	[12]
10	Binksternet	Nov 29	Nov 29	4783	[13]
1	Bluerasberry	Nov 07	Nov 07	0	[14]
3	Boson	Nov 05	Dec 03	15718	[15]
15	Buster7	Nov 29	Nov 30	1439	[16]
11	Carolmooredc	Oct 30	Oct 30	6499	[17]
3	Chaos5023	Nov 15	Nov 15	2957	[18]
3	Chaosdruid	Dec 11	Dec 11	0	[19]
31	CMBJ	Nov 21	Nov 21	3285	[20]
2	Collect	Nov 29	Nov 29	8435	[21]
12	DCI2026	Nov 23	Nov 23	9102	[22]
28	DGG	Nov 01	Nov 02	4138	[23]
1	Djembayz	Nov 03	Nov 03	584	[24]
4	Doctree	Nov 10	Nov 16	4979	[25]
19	DreamGuy	Dec 02	Dec 02	9402	[26]
4	Ebe123	Nov 17	Dec 01	2044	[27]
1	Elen of the Roads	Dec 06	Dec 06	1687	[28]
12	Elonka	Nov 29	Dec 03	12648	[29]
3	Epbr123	Nov 29	Dec 01	2940	[30]
1	Eraserhead1	Nov 29	Nov 29	0	[31]
6	ErrantX	Nov 29	Nov 29	4759	[32]
9	Fifelfoo	Oct 28	Oct 28	-9597	[33]
12	Fluffernutter	Nov 05	Nov 06	18171	[34]
1	Francophonie&Androphilie	Nov 29	Nov 29	0	[35]
17	Fylbecatulous	Oct 29	Nov 04	6304	[36]
4	Gandydancer	Nov 01	Nov 01	3050	[37]
21	GeorgeLouis	Nov 29	Nov 29	2834	[38]
1	Ghmyrtle	Dec 01	Dec 01	0	[39]
1	Gobonobo	Dec 03	Dec 03	0	[40]
8	GRuban	Nov 29	Nov 29	1509	[41]
18	Hamiltonstone	Nov 29	Nov 30	4316	[42]
26	Hasteur	Oct 29	Oct 29	4986	[43]
2	Hex	Nov 22	Nov 22	612	[44]
9	Hut 8.5	Nov 05	Nov 18	5316	[45]
3	Intothatdarkness	Oct 30	Oct 30	2976	[46]
5	Isarra	Dec 01	Dec 02	9596	[47]
24	Jayron32	Oct 29	Oct 29	10006	[48]
2	Jc37	Dec 04	Dec 04	3042	[49]
6	Jennavecia	Nov 29	Nov 30	1248	[50]
27	Jezhotwells	Nov 12	Nov 12	1320	[51]
10	John	Nov 30	Nov 30	1150	[52]
3	Johnbod	Nov 29	Nov 29	806	[53]
1	Jon C.	Nov 30	Nov 30	0	[54]
6	Kaldari	Oct 30	Oct 30	3204	[55]
8	Keilana	Oct 30	Nov 07	3705	[56]
2	Kilopi	Oct 31	Oct 31	2228	[57]
11	Kudpung	Nov 29	Nov 29	1939	[58]
11	Kurtis	Nov 29	Nov 29	1762	[59]
10	Legoktm	Oct 29	Dec 02	6491	[60]
1	Martinevans123	Dec 03	Dec 03	0	[61]
2	Mdann52	Oct 30	Oct 30	1299	[62]
2	Moriori	Nov 29	Dec 04	3191	[63]
5	NaBUru38	Nov 22	Nov 22	4383	[64]
5	NE Ent[n 2]	Nov 21	Nov 21	1135	[65]
2	Nø	Nov 10	Nov 10	2842	[66]
19	Od Mishehu	Nov 18	Nov 19	5480	[67]
2	Op47	Nov 06	Nov 06	1859	[68]
6	Orlady	Nov 26	Nov 28	3226	[69]
33	pablo	Dec 13	Dec 20	22535	[70]
20	PamD	Nov 07	Nov 27	6221	[71]
45	PartTimeGnome	Nov 10	Nov 30	54389	[72]
1	Piotrus	Dec 04	Dec 04	9204	[73]
1	Primergrey	Dec 12	Dec 12	3586	[74]
26	Ravenswing	Nov 29	Nov 29	6409	[75]
29	RedSoxFan2434	Oct 29	Nov 30	24113	[76]
8	Refdoc	Nov 30	Nov 30	1918	[77]
3	RegentsPark	Nov 29	Nov 29	2876	[78]
3	RexxS	Nov 29	Nov 29	6881	[79]
25	Reyk	Nov 29	Dec 03	2724	[80]
20	Richwales	Nov 29	Nov 29	13949	[81]
7	Rivertorch	Dec 03	Dec 05	6992	[82]
13	Rschen7754	Oct 29	Nov 06	1776	[83]
11	SandyGeorgia	Nov 30	Nov 30	1821	[84]
24	SarahStierch	Oct 30	Oct 30	7540	[85]
1	Scray	Nov 29	Nov 29	0	[86]
3	Secretlondon	Nov 04	Nov 04	2237	[87]
33	Skyring	Oct 30	Nov 14	9244	[88]
26	Smallbones	Oct 28	Nov 02	4537	[89]
26	SmokeyJoe	Oct 30	Oct 30	9092	[90]
6	SoWhy	Nov 29	Dec 01	8199	[91]
2	Sphilbrick	Nov 29	Dec 02	3364	[92]
5	Squeamish Ossifrage	Nov 29	Nov 29	34868	[93]
36	Steelpillow	Dec 05	Dec 08	7819	[94]
23	Stfg	Nov 30	Dec 04	6820	[95]
30	Sue Rangell	Nov 18	Nov 18	5793	[96]
3	Swatjester	Dec 03	Dec 03	18657	[97]
1	Tarc	Nov 29	Nov 29	1220	[98]
48	ThatPeskyCommoner	Nov 01	Nov 03	22384	[99]
15	The Anonymouse	Dec 04	Dec 11	1949	[100]
3	Thegreatgrabber	Nov 06	Nov 06	326	[101]
3	Thincat	Nov 30	Nov 30	2277	[102]
19	Thparkth	Nov 09	Nov 09	4187	[103]
9	Thryduulf	Nov 30	Nov 30	7020	[104]
3	Timtrent	Nov 29	Nov 29	3546	[105]
4	Tom Morris	Dec 03	Dec 03	5265	[106]
9	TParis	Nov 30	Nov 30	7182	[107]
3	Tryptofish	Oct 30	Oct 31	13540	[108]
4	TutterMouse	Nov 14	Nov 14	7710	[109]
3	Volunteer Marek	Oct 28	Oct 28	1099	[110]
1	WaitingForConnection	Nov 24	Nov 24	0	[111]
2	Wikidemon	Nov 29	Nov 29	7313	[112]
17	Worm That Turned	Nov 29	Nov 29	13311	[113]
19	Ynhockey	Nov 01	Dec 04	4550	[114]
13	YOLO Swag	Dec 06	Dec 06	4849	[115]
34	Zenswashbuckler	Nov 16	Dec 04	16119	[116]

Phase one contributions

Phase one ended on 28 October 2012. Edits on or after this date are part of a later phase.

Some parts of phase one took place at Wikipedia talk:Civility, and were later moved to the main RFC page. Where an editor contributed in both places, two contribution links are shown in the "Editor" column. Note that the Wikipedia talk:Civility talk page was also used to discuss matters outside of the RFC, so not all of a user's contributions to that page are necessarily related to the RFC.

No. edits	Editor	First edit	Last edit	Bytes added	Reviewed by	Comments & summary
4	28bytes	Oct 04	Oct 17	601	RedSoxFan2434	Supports hatting instances of incivility; Opposes civility enforcement; Believes civility enforcement is too unevenly enforced, easily gamed, and causes expanded incivility.
9	85.167.108.93, 88.88.165.212, 88.88.166.230	Oct 20	Oct 22	8620	RedSoxFan2434	Supports enforcement against ad hominem arguments; Opposes enforcement against "bad language"; Believes that civility cannot be a pillar unless it is enforced, and that ad hominem arguments are inherently uncivil.
1	213.196.195.236	Oct 24	Oct 24	211
5	99of9	Oct 11	Oct 11	501	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility enforcement, User:FT2/Civility draft, and "the point where the conversation ceases to be about what you were talking about and begins to be derailed by how you're talking about it" as the boundary of civility; Opposes leniency towards good content contributors; Believes declaring the right to be uncivil is a sign of deliberate incivility.
1	AGK	Oct 13	Oct 13	383
57	Alanscottwalker	Oct 04	Oct 23	16116	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility enforcement (esp. against the habitually uncivil), focusing "on the edit, not the editor", anti-incivility templates, and right to discuss accused incivility; Opposes leniency towards good content contributors, and taking issue with incivility accusations; Believes criticism is not necessarily incivility, most incivility should be ignored, civility issues are rarely caused by respectful intentions, that "the ends" do not "justify the means", and that WP is not a "free speech forum".
4	Amadscientist[n 3]	Oct 03	Oct 03	1993	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility enforcement; Opposes making more rules, and demoting civility to a guideline.
4	AndyTheGrump	Oct 04	Oct 06	1810	RedSoxFan2434	Opposes civility enforcement; Believes enforcers would only enforce policy against opponents, confirmation bias is a bad factor, civil POV-pushers are a major problem, and criticism is not incivility
18	Anthonyhcole	Oct 21	Oct 22	3305	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility enforcement on article talk pages and move to dispute resolution of ad hominem discussions; Believes accusations of bias are uncivil, ad hominem arguments are uncivil, and conflicts of interest do not lower argument quality (but should be declared).
1	Apteva	Oct 20	Oct 20	1165	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility enforcement in some form.
2	A Quest For Knowledge	Oct 18	Oct 18	272	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility enforcement in some form; Opposes leniency towards good content contributors.
1	AutomaticStrikeout	Oct 26	Oct 26	509	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility enforcement in some form.
1	Axl	Oct 04	Oct 04	188	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility enforcement in some form.
28	Beeblebrox (2)[n 3]	Oct 04	Oct 16	19468	RedSoxFan2434	Supports continuing "case-by-case basis" of handling most incivility, hatting instances of incivility, middle ground regarding good content contributors, and strict civility enforcement upon any civility enforcers; Opposes User:FT2/Civility draft, having any "bright line rule", and User:Mindspillage/disputes becoming policy; Believes many misunderstandings caused by "text-only interaction", criticism and disagreement are not incivility, that "civility police" are part of the problem, and that context is important.
5	Beetstra	Oct 10	Oct 11	7633	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility enforcement, with civility blocks as a last resort; Believes "consensus does not change the feeling of the victim" and therefore advises editors to be careful with tone.
1	Bishonen	Oct 22	Oct 22	1503	RedSoxFan2434	Believes COIs should only be pointed out politely, and "quality of argument isn't a monolith in a void."(The reviewer may not understand what that means.)
7	Boson	Oct 08	Oct 23	2881	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility enforcement and continuing "case-by-case basis" of handling most incivility; Opposes leniency towards good content contributors; Believes civility cannot be policy unless it is enforced, context is crucially important, and that ad hominems are not inherently uncivil, but that abusive ones are personal attacks which should be enforced against.
35	Buster7	Oct 09	Oct 16	13748	RedSoxFan2434	Supports "ironclad" civility enforcement, continuing "case-by-case basis" of handling most incivility, hatting instances of incivility, User:FT2/Civility draft, and pointing out incivility to those who do it; Opposes leniency towards good content contributors; Believes editors should assume the presence of "ladies" and/or their mothers, proportion of content work vs. arguments is important, criticism and disagreement are not incivility, and that consensus doesn't overrule the victim's feelings.
8	Carolmooredc	Oct 07	Oct 13	2051	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility enforcement, asking for uncivil comments to be struck, creating a humorous instructional video to prevent incivility; Opposes hatting instances of incivility as a solution (but finds it useful); Believes civil POV-pushing is easy to deal with, criticism and disagreement are not incivility.
1	Carrite	Oct 04	Oct 04	125	RedSoxFan2434	Supports continuing "case-by-case" basis for handling most incivility; Believes "civility police" are part of the problem, and that context is important.
9	Casliber	Oct 04	Oct 11	2900	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility enforcement, hatting instances of incivility, bans/blocks for users who spend 33% of their on-wiki time being uncivil; Opposes User:Mindspillage/disputes becoming policy; Believes issues should be resolved as quickly as possible without bans/blocks, and "civility police" are part of the problem.
4	CBM[n 3]	Oct 02	Oct 02	4015	RedSoxFan2434	Supports civility blocks; Believes need for collaboration should be emphasized, and consensus exists that bad language is incivility.
1	Charles Matthews	Oct 09	Oct 09	503
3	Chedzilla	Oct 20	Oct 20	604
1	ClemRutter[n 3]	Oct 04	Oct 04	1901
2	Corporate Minion[n 4]	Oct 22	Oct 22	997
4	CT Cooper	Oct 05	Oct 16	1472
1	Czarkoff[n 3]	Oct 03	Oct 03	770
2	Davewild	Oct 27	Oct 27	193
3	Dennis Brown	Oct 22	Oct 22	1355
2	DGG	Oct 07	Oct 07	495
1	Djathinkimacowboy	Oct 21	Oct 21	872
1	EatsShootsAndLeaves[n 3]	Oct 03	Oct 03	352
2	Ebe123	Oct 07	Oct 07	791
1	Elonka	Oct 23	Oct 23	200
4	Epipelagic	Oct 22	Oct 23	1170
6	Eraserhead1	Oct 08	Oct 08	1330
1	Fences and windows	Oct 09	Oct 09	658
15	Fluffernutter	Oct 04	Oct 11	25908
7	Fred Bauder	Oct 10	Oct 22	2984
11	FT2	Oct 04	Oct 04	3903
3	Gigs	Oct 06	Oct 06	1160
4	Gimmetoo	Oct 23	Oct 23	1870
14	GoodDay	Oct 07	Oct 16	1844
2	Guy Macon	Oct 04	Oct 04	344
7	Hasteur[n 3]	Oct 02	Oct 03	23895
4	Heimstern	Oct 11	Oct 11	1440
1	Herostratus	Oct 08	Oct 08	1341
29	HiLo48	Oct 04	Oct 29	14964
2	Hut 8.5	Oct 06	Oct 06	303
15	Hyacinth	Oct 04	Oct 14	2921
1	Iantresman[n 3]	Oct 04	Oct 04	234
2	Intothatdarkness	Oct 09	Oct 09	222
15	IRWolfie-	Oct 18	Oct 22	3459
1	Isaacl	Oct 10	Oct 10	212
2	Jasper Deng	Oct 06	Oct 06	246
17	Jayron32	Oct 04	Oct 17	11861
8	John	Oct 16	Oct 20	2525
5	Jtrainor (2)[n 3]	Oct 02	Oct 10	1253
1	Kaldari	Oct 07	Oct 07	96
4	Kiefer.Wolfowitz	Oct 11	Oct 12	2347
1	Ks0stm	Oct 09	Oct 09	234
5	Kudpung	Oct 23	Oct 23	5372
4	Legoktm	Oct 06	Oct 26	638
5	Littleolive oil[n 3]	Oct 02	Oct 02	4056
30	Lothar von Richthofen	Oct 05	Oct 11	13808
1	LtPowers	Oct 09	Oct 09	147
4	Mann jess	Oct 16	Oct 18	1353
3	Martin Hogbin[n 3]	Oct 14	Oct 15	910
12	Monty845 (2)[n 3]	Oct 02	Oct 20	5640
2	Newyorkbrad	Oct 08	Oct 08	3311
2	Nick-D	Oct 04	Oct 04	209
8	Nikkimaria (2)[n 3]	Oct 02	Oct 11	3340
10	Nobody Ent (2)[n 3][n 2][n 5]	Oct 11	Oct 23	4658
2	North8000[n 3]	Oct 04	Oct 04	525
1	OrangesRyellow	Oct 19	Oct 19	403
13	Pablo X	Oct 04	Oct 22	4016
2	Peridon	Oct 09	Oct 09	533
1	Pigsonthewing	Oct 09	Oct 09	327
13	Quiddity (2)[n 3]	Oct 02	Oct 09	8693
20	Rd232	Oct 04	Oct 20	10153
10	RedSoxFan2434	Oct 21	Oct 22	3824
1	Richwales	Oct 12	Oct 12	1625
1	RightCowLeftCoast	Oct 13	Oct 13	671
1	Risker	Oct 11	Oct 11	305
1	Rlendog	Oct 12	Oct 12	210
1	Roscelese	Oct 08	Oct 08	655
20	Rschen7754	Oct 04	Oct 12	4247
3	Ryan Vesey	Oct 07	Oct 16	599
23	Skyring	Oct 04	Oct 23	10882
23	SMcCandlish	Oct 12	Oct 12	17140
5	Sphilbrick	Oct 05	Oct 09	3390
1	Steven Zhang	Oct 23	Oct 23	296
8	Sun Creator (2)[n 3]	Oct 18	Oct 18	2202
4	Sven Manguard	Oct 06	Oct 07	2150
5	Tarc[n 3]	Oct 02	Oct 02	1884
60	ThatPeskyCommoner	Oct 04	Oct 18	44024
4	Themfromspace	Oct 18	Oct 18	2011
17	TheRedPenOfDoom	Oct 05	Oct 21	5206
3	Timeshift9	Oct 04	Oct 04	575
6	TParis	Oct 22	Oct 22	1608
7	Voceditenore	Oct 11	Oct 22	2866
16	Volunteer Marek	Oct 04	Oct 23	8886
1	WaitingForConnection	Oct 18	Oct 18	1148
4	Wikishagnik	Oct 05	Oct 08	2932
5	Wnt (2)[n 3]	Oct 04	Oct 13	2530
2	ZuluPapa5[n 3]	Oct 02	Oct 03	765

Footnotes

1. The "live link" offers a quick way to verify if any changes have been made after this table was updated. Also, if you un-check the box; "group by user", and "Load", all edits will be displayed, which can enhance the tool's usefulness.
2. During phase one, NE Ent was known as Nobody Ent. The account was renamed on 11 November 2012.
3. Some or all of this user's contributions to phase one originally took place at Wikipedia_talk:Civility#Civility Enforcement RFC, and were subsequently moved to the main RFC. Check the history of that page to find the original contributions.
4. User account Corporate Minion was renamed to CorporateM on December 13, 2012.
5. On October 23, Nobody Ent moved a discussion from Wikipedia talk:Civility to the RFC. The table does not count this as a contribution by Nobody Ent, but instead as by the original commenters in that discussion.