Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Edition Silvertrust
This website has a huge amount of historical information on composers that cannot be found elsewhere. Further, it has the largest source of sound soundbites of chamber music on the internet available for all at no cost.
No notability
editPlease review WP:Company; we're not interested in how awesome the company is or claims to be. If there's no currently no independent media coverage of the company, then it's not fit for inclusion in Wikipedia, no matter how important the company is. People interested in Edition Silvertrust can just go straight to the Edition Silvertrust Website.
I could not find any independent media coverage; if you can find and supply links to independent media coverage, and if the sources are reasonably notable, then the deletion can be prevented or undone, and the media coverage can be integrated with the article, so that it will no longer be unacceptably unreferenced. Rolf H Nelson (talk) 02:23, 10 October 2013 (UTC)
Very Useful Entry
editThis is one of the most useful music resource entries on Wikipedia. Myself and my fellow music instructors have found a great deal of useful information as a result of this entry both on Wikipedia as well as elsewhere. I think, as do my colleagues at our music school that removal would be a mistake. What a waste just because you cannot find any reference in a newspaper or media. Surely Wikipedia does not use the same standard as People or Us Magazine, i.e. notoriety as a guide for inclusion or removal. i am guessing you are not a classical musician or familar with classical chamber music to have come to this decision. But as a music teacher and performing musician, I can tell you it is a valuable addition. . Please reconsider this decision. I hope that the ultimate decision will be made by more than one person and include some classical musicians. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Peter Klossbruhe (talk • contribs) 04:32, 15 October 2013 (UTC)
19:38, 18 October 2013 (UTC)19:38, 18 October 2013 (UTC)19:38, 18 October 2013 (UTC)~== A Useful Musical Resource ==
I am a music teacher, performer and specialize as a chamber music coach. I come to this page often as a resource to get me to other pages on Wikipedia and the net. I also send my students here. I was shocked to learn you are going to delete it. I agree with what Peter Klossbruhe has written. You will make a mistake by deleting this page. I am sure that there are lots of chamber music players that come to and use this page as a resource. There must be some other criteria besides notoriety in deterining the usefulness of a page entry. I encourage you to keep this page. Signed Lawrence Block, Violinist, Clarinetist, college orchestra director and member or the Cantabile String Quartet — Preceding unsigned comment added by Lawrence Larry Block (talk • contribs) 19:35, 18 October 2013 (UTC)
- If the page is deleted, you can just as easily send them straight to Edison Silverlight's home page, or build your own Web page (for example, on your school's Web site), with the composers you think your students should know. Rolf H Nelson (talk) 02:03, 20 October 2013 (UTC)